Chapter 339: Under the Same Sky

The night had fallen with a melancholic air over the campus. The wind blew softly, moving the dry leaves across the paths dimly lit by the streetlights. Ana Lucía was in the small garden behind the women’s residence, sitting on the damp grass, looking at the starry sky. She liked that place. It was her refuge when everything felt too heavy, when the stares and whispers became unbearable.

That week had been hell. Since the rumors started, she hadn’t had a single moment of peace. In the hallways, conversations stopped when she walked by. In the cafeteria, laughter faded and whispers began. Some people looked at her with pity, others with disdain.

—Opportunist —she had heard a girl say when she thought Ana Lucía couldn’t hear her.

That word had pierced her heart like a thorn.

She had tried to ignore everything, but what hurt her the most was knowing that Ethan had heard it too. She had seen it in his eyes that day, when he could barely hold her gaze. That mix of confusion and disappointment. She didn’t blame him. If she were in his place, she would doubt too. Everything had been perfectly planned to look like the truth.

She touched the small pendant hanging around her neck, the one he had given her on their first walk together. It was hard to believe everything had gotten so tangled.

Suddenly, she heard footsteps behind her. She didn’t need to turn around to know who it was. Her breathing changed instantly, her heart started hammering in her chest.

—Ana Lucía —Ethan’s voice sounded firm, although there was a crack of uncertainty in it.

She closed her eyes for a few seconds before answering.

—What are you doing here, Ethan?

—I needed to talk to you —he said, walking closer slowly—. I've been trying to all week, but you keep avoiding me.

—I haven’t avoided you —she answered in a low voice, still not looking at him—. I just… didn’t have anything to say.

—Nothing? —he repeated, hurt—. Do you really think after everything we’ve been through there’s nothing to say?

She sighed, not moving her eyes from the sky.

—Sometimes it’s better not to say anything.

Ethan took another step, standing in front of her. He looked at her closely. Her face looked tired, her eyes red, as if she had cried more than once in recent days.

—I’ve heard things —he finally said—. Rumors. And I didn’t want to believe them. I don’t want to believe them.

Ana Lucía pressed her lips together.

—Then don’t believe them.

—But I need to hear it from you —he insisted—. I need you to tell me what’s going on.

She lifted her gaze, with a restrained shine between pride and pain.

—What do you want me to say, Ethan?

—The truth. Just that.

Ana Lucía swallowed. She knew it was time to clear everything up, but fear stopped her. Fear that even if she told the truth, he wouldn’t believe her. Fear of seeming weak. Fear of loving someone who maybe already doubted her.

So she chose the path that hurt most.

—Fine —she said coldly—. The rumors are true.

Ethan looked at her, not understanding.

—What?

—Yes, it’s true —she repeated, forcing herself to keep her tone firm—. I took advantage of you. I needed someone to help me raise my grades, and you were perfect. Smart, responsible, kind… too good.

Every word hurt like she was stabbing herself, but she kept talking, convinced pushing him away was the best option.

—When I saw I could do it on my own, I just stopped needing you. That’s all.

Ethan stepped back, as if her words had hit him in the chest.

—No… you can’t be serious.

—I am —she lied.

Silence fell between them, heavy, unbearable. Only the sound of the wind and leaves filled the space. Ethan tried to read her eyes, but she didn't give him the chance; she kept them fixed on the stars, as if she could find courage in them.

—I know you —he said in a low trembling voice—. I know when you lie.

She gave a humorless smile.

—Then you don’t know me as well as you think.

—Ana, look at me —Ethan asked, stepping closer—. Look me in the eyes and tell me you really used me.

She did. She looked straight at him, eyes filled with tears but without letting a single one fall.

—I used you.

Ethan clenched his fists.

—Why are you doing this?

—Because it’s the truth.

—It’s not! —he raised his voice, losing control for a moment—. You’re not like that!

Ana Lucía stood up abruptly.

—And what do you know about what I am? —she shouted—. What do you know about what I need or what hurts me? You have everything, Ethan. A family that supports you, a secure future. I was just trying to survive.

—Don’t say that…

—It’s the truth! —she cut him off, eyes overflowing—. Since I got here, everyone has judged me. I’ve had to prove I’m worth something, that I’m not just a poor scholarship girl who needs help from a perfect guy like you.

—I never thought that of you —Ethan replied, hurt.

—Maybe you didn’t say it, but I felt it —she whispered, lowering her voice—. Every time you helped me, every time you looked at me with pity…

—It wasn’t pity —Ethan said, stepping closer—. It was affection. It was… something more.

Ana Lucía looked at him, and for an instant all her strength crumbled. She wanted to run to him, hug him, tell him none of it was true, that it was all a lie planned by others, that she had loved him from the first day. But she couldn’t. She mustn’t.

So she lied again.

—I’m sorry, Ethan. I don’t want this anymore. Don’t look for me again.

Ethan held her arm gently but desperately.

—I don’t believe you. I can’t.

She lowered her gaze, avoiding his eyes.

—Then that’s not my problem.

Ethan slowly let her go.

—Is that all I meant to you? —he asked, voice breaking—. Just a way to reach your goals?

Ana Lucía pressed her lips, feeling her heart shatter.

—Yes —she whispered, barely audible—. Just that.

Ethan watched her a few seconds longer, trying to find a crack, a sign she was lying. But he didn’t find it. He only saw a cold mask hiding unbearable pain.

He nodded slowly.

—Alright —he finally said, stepping back—. If that’s what you want me to believe, I will. But remember this, Ana Lucía: not everyone has the strength to lie with pain in their eyes.

She stared at him, stunned, unable to answer.

Ethan gave a sad smile.

—I learned to pretend too —he murmured—. But unlike you, I can’t pretend I don’t care about you.

And he turned around, walking away.

Ana Lucía stayed still, watching his figure disappear among the garden lights. The moment he vanished, she collapsed. She fell to her knees on the grass, heart shattered. The tears she had held back for so long finally spilled.

—Forgive me… —she sobbed—. Forgive me, Ethan.

She looked up to the sky, searching for comfort among the stars.

—I never wanted to hurt you —she whispered—. I just wanted to protect you.

The breeze moved her hair gently, as if trying to comfort her. But nothing could.

A few meters away, without her noticing, Julia watched from behind a tree. She smiled with satisfaction seeing Ana Lucía broken.

—Perfect —she whispered—. Now that he thinks you used him and you think he hates you, everything is back to normal.

But what Julia didn’t know was that Ethan, while walking away, had stopped halfway. He closed his eyes, remembering every moment with Ana Lucía: her laughter, her tenderness, her sincerity. And even though everything seemed against her, his heart refused to believe her words.

—I don’t believe you —he repeated softly, looking up at the sky—. I can’t believe you lied to me.

And under that same starry sky, two hearts broke for the same reasons: love, pride and fear.

Neither of them knew the storm had just begun, and love, even when it hurts, still had more to say.