Chapter 36
I saw the flicker of understanding, of a shared, unspoken pain, in her eyes. Or maybe it was just a trick of the light, my own exhaustion playing tricks on me. She sighed, her hands dropping from my arm. “Okay,” she said, her voice quiet. “Okay, David. Just… please be careful. And let me help. Whatever you need.”
Her words, her acceptance, were a small comfort in the storm. I nodded, already pulling up search engines, typing furiously. My old phone, my personal one, buzzed. It was Ben. He was loyal. He’d help. He was still inside. He could feed me information, quietly.
The laptop screen glowed, illuminating my grim, determined face. Suspended. Fine. They could take my badge. They could take my uniform. But they couldn’t take my purpose. They couldn’t take my drive to find the truth, no matter how ugly. The killer had woken me up, had shown me the way. And now, operating outside the system, unburdened by its corrupt rules, I felt a dangerous, exhilarating sense of freedom. The hunt was no longer just a job. It was personal. And I wouldn't stop until I exposed every last secret.
Ben
The precinct was a frigid, silent mausoleum after David got tossed out. You could cut the tension with a butter knife. Everyone knew what had gone down. Rhodes, the newly minted Assistant Commissioner, had hung David out to dry. Said he was “erratic,” “insubordinate.” Bullshit. David was a good cop, maybe too good, too stubborn for the kind of dirt Rhodes and Davies were so comfortable with. But now, David was gone, cooling his heels on suspension, and the air here felt thinner, colder, like the soul had been sucked right out of the place.
I sat at my desk, staring at the empty chair opposite me. David’s chair. It felt wrong. Like a missing tooth in the department’s smile. Nobody talked about it, not openly. You just heard whispers in the breakroom, hushed conversations about how David was “off the rails” or “letting it get to him.” A few guys, the older ones who actually remembered Davies before the big promotions, they’d give me a knowing look, a silent nod. They knew something wasn’t right. But fear was a powerful muzzle. Rhodes was watching everyone like a hawk, ready to pounce on any perceived disloyalty.
The pressure from Rhodes was a concrete thing you could feel pressing down on your chest. He barked orders, demanded progress, but all he really wanted was for us to tie a neat bow on this case, blame it on some random nutjob, and make it disappear. He didn’t want to hear about “patterns” or “silenced victims.” He just wanted the goddamn chaos to stop. And he certainly didn’t want anyone digging deeper into the rot Davies had cultivated. That’s why he canned David. David was too close to pulling back the curtain.
My own stomach was churning. Caldwell’s murder was… something else. Even after Davies and Thorne, Caldwell’s office, with those horrifying kids’ drawings, that little star on his wrist, the damn Velveteen Rabbit… it had hit me hard. I’d seen a lot of ugly in my years on the force, but that was a whole new level of sick. It was personal. It was a scream, loud and clear, and it was aimed right at us, at the system that had let these monsters flourish. David had been right. He always was.
The phone on my desk rang, making me jump. It was just Officer Miller from Forensics, asking about a stray fiber from Caldwell’s carpet. Routine. My heart didn’t even register it. It was still pounding from the phantom ring of the damn 3 AM call. Every time my phone vibrated in my pocket, I flinched. Every siren that wailed outside. Every shadow that seemed to move just a little too fast. The city was on edge, and so was I.
The briefing at 8 AM had been brutal. Rhodes, calm and collected as ever, despite the fury radiating off him like heat from a stove, had torn into us. “I want suspects, not theories!” he’d bellowed, his voice carrying through the conference room, making the windows rattle. “I want boots on the ground! I want results! This… this individual is mocking us! Making a mockery of this entire department! You will follow every lead, no matter how insignificant, to find this killer. And you will find them now!”
He talked about “restoring public confidence,” but his eyes said, “Clean up this mess before it costs me my job.” It was all about optics. It was sickening.
I spent the morning running down dead ends, re-interviewing people who’d already told us nothing, staring at security footage that showed only blurs and shadows. Every move felt pointless, like we were just spinning our wheels, desperate to look busy while the real lead, the real truth, was staring at us in the face. But David wasn’t here to point it out. And I was too damn scared to do it myself. Not yet.
The dread just sat in my gut, a cold, heavy stone. I kept thinking about the look on David’s face when he’d walked out of Rhodes’s office, the way his badge had clinked on the desk. He looked like a man who’d just lost everything, but his eyes… his eyes had still burned with that stubborn fire. That’s David. He doesn’t quit. Ever.
Just after lunch, the whole precinct exploded. Not with a call, not with a sudden break, but with pure, unadulterated pandemonium. The radios started squawking, overlapping voices, frantic and unintelligible. Officers started running, desks were knocked over, and a scream came up from the dispatch office. A high-pitched, guttural sound that made the blood drain from my face.
Another one. It had to be.
I grabbed my jacket and ran, pushing through the chaos towards dispatch. Every cop in the building seemed to have the same idea. The dispatcher, a tough, seasoned veteran named Brenda, was pale as a sheet, her hand clamped over her mouth, her eyes wide with horror as she listened to the headset.
“What is it, Brenda?!” I yelled, pushing closer, my voice strained.
She slowly pulled the headset off, her eyes fixed on nothing. “It’s… it’s Sterling,” she whispered, her voice barely audible. “City Council President Robert Sterling.”
My breath hitched. Sterling. Robert Sterling. The most powerful man in the City Council, practically ran the city behind the mayor. Rhodes’s closest ally in city hall. A picture of respectable, old-money power. This wasn't just high-profile. This was a direct, goddamn declaration of war.
“Where?” I asked, my voice flat, already knowing the answer would make my stomach drop even further.
“His penthouse,” Brenda whispered, a shiver running through her. “Upper East Side. Responding officers just got there. They’re saying… they’re saying it’s a bloodbath. Worse than Thorne. Worse than Caldwell. And… and there’s a message.”