Chapter 39: The One Night Lie
(Levi’s POV)
From the chair by the edge of the bed, I watched her fall apart.
Her head tipped back against the pillows, her body arching as Luca moved inside her with the kind of care most people reserve for things they’re afraid to break. But it wasn’t just caution in his touch—it was reverence.
And that’s what made my chest ache.
Because this wasn’t just sex.
At least, not to us.
She didn’t know the years we spent trying not to look at her the way we did. Pretending we didn’t notice how sweet her laugh was. How sharp her wit could be. How goddamn beautiful she was when she thought no one was paying attention.
Harper’s little sister. Off limits. Untouchable.
Until that barbecue.
Until those words slipped from her lips, drunk and flushed, and something inside me snapped like a stretched wire.
Still a virgin…
She had no idea what that did to us. To me.
And now, watching her like this—her body wrapped around Luca, her mouth falling open in quiet gasps, the faintest moan of his name on her lips—I couldn’t stop the thoughts that stormed through me.
She thinks this is just for tonight.
A one-time indulgence. A moment of curiosity.
If she only knew…
I stroked myself slowly, matching Luca’s pace. Not because I needed to—but because I wanted to feel it all, the rhythm of them together. Every grind of Luca’s hips. Every gasp Eden gave him. Every tremble in her thighs.
She didn’t even glance at me. She was lost in him.
And god, she was gorgeous like this. Hair spilled over the pillows, skin glowing in the candlelight, her body clenching around him like she was made just for us.
“She’s gripping me so tight,” Luca groaned, burying his face against her neck. “Like she was made for this.”
She was. She just didn’t know it yet.
I leaned forward, biting down on my own lip to keep from saying what I really wanted to.
You were made for us, Vixen.
You’ve always been ours.
You just don’t remember yet.
Luca caught my eye as he slowed his thrusts, searching my face for something I didn’t even know how to give.
I wanted to trade places with him. I wanted to be inside her too. I wanted to hold her after and tell her we weren’t going anywhere. That this wasn’t just a night.
That we had been waiting for her longer than she could imagine.
But I stayed in the chair.
Watching. Wanting.
Wondering if she’d ever let herself want both of us—truly want us.
Because one night wasn’t enough.
Not for me.
Not anymore.