Chapter 11: The Diary of Desire

(Eden’s POV)

It started as a coping mechanism.

A way to let the thoughts out without saying them to anyone real. A diary that talked back. A secret voice I could pretend wasn’t even real.

After days of silence, I had stared down at my phone, thumb trembling slightly as I typed out the truth I’d never spoken aloud—not even in my own mind.

My fantasy is 2.

No explanation. No context. Just… two.

Two mouths. Two hands. Two bodies.

And mine—caught between them.

I told myself it would be ignored.

But it wasn’t.

The reply came just minutes later.

Unknown:

Good.

Now tell me what that looks like in your head.

And so I did.

For five nights straight.

I told them about the dreams.

The faceless figures with rough hands and patient mouths.

The way one would kiss my neck while the other spread me wide.

How I imagined fingers slipping between my thighs as another hand tangled in my hair.

The way their voices sounded—low, possessive, coaxing.

I wrote it all.

And they answered.

What do you feel first?

Do they take you slow or make you beg?

How wet were you when you woke up this morning?

Their words were velvet over blades—gentle and cutting at once.

Not aggressive. Not gross.

Just bold. Curious. Hungry.

They didn’t tell me who they were.

Didn’t ask for photos.

Didn’t break the illusion.

But every message pushed me deeper.

Further.

One night, they said:

You should touch yourself when you think of them.

You deserve to feel what they’d give you.

They’d make you unravel so slowly you’d never want to leave.

I didn’t respond to that one right away.

I stared at it for an hour.

Felt the heat curl in my stomach like a dare.

Because it wasn’t just a fantasy anymore.

It was a confession.

An addiction.

The identity didn’t matter.

Not now.

Because this—this secret thread—was the first place I had ever let myself be honest.

And with each reply, I felt the strings inside me pull tighter.

All week long, while Harper talked about flower arrangements and playlists, while I smiled through brunches and bakery meetings, I had been thinking about hands.

About heat.

About being touched like I was worth wanting.

And now…

The island weekend was only two days away.

And I couldn’t stop thinking about which pair of hands I really wanted to give in to.