Chapter 26: Cut to Pieces (Caleb POV)

I’m still at Benji’s, sitting on his lumpy couch, when Friday morning drags on. My bag’s by my feet, stuffed with Diane’s legal papers—her note, live with it, still stinging in my head. Seth’s call stopped ringing a while ago, and I’m glad I didn’t pick up. My chest’s tight, but I shove it down, focus on Benji. He’s at his table, laptop open, digging through Miles’s fraud stuff—papers scattered, coffee cold. “Anything?” I ask, voice rough, leaning forward.

“Close,” he says, not looking up. “Got dates tying Miles to the fake loans. Need more for the bank.”

I nod, restless, tapping my foot. Ryan’s out there—cracked, maybe selling—and I’m here, fighting alone. My hands itch to do something, anything, but we’re stuck waiting. My phone’s on the table, quiet since Seth, and I grab it, just to keep busy. I scroll X, mindless, looking for noise—something to drown out Mom, Ryan, all of it. That’s when I see it—a post from Jake, pinned at the top, blowing up fast.

My stomach twists. It’s a video—old band footage, grainy, from years back. I click it, slow, heart thumping. It’s us—me, Jake, the old crew—onstage, mid-set. I’m up front, guitar slung low, yelling into the mic. The clip’s short, chopped up, and I look bad—real bad. My voice cracks, off-key, and I shove Jake mid-song, laughing like a jerk. It cuts quick—me tossing my guitar down, storming off, crowd booing soft. Caption says, Caleb Hart, the failure who tanked us.

I sit up fast, gripping the phone. “What the hell?” I mutter, loud, and Benji looks over. “What’s up?” he says, frowning.

“Jake,” I say, voice shaking, showing him the screen. “Posted this. Old gig—makes me look like an ass.”

He grabs it, watches, jaw tightening. “He cut it,” he says, handing it back. “That’s not how it went. You were pissed—he was drunk, missed cues.”

“Yeah,” I say, scrolling fast. Jake’s thread’s growing—more posts, piling on. Caleb blew his shot at fame. Too full of himself, trashed the band. My chest burns, hot and tight. I remember that night—Jake stumbling, me fed up, but not like this. He’s twisting it, making me the bad guy. I keep reading, can’t stop. Used Ryan for cash—leeching off The Static. That one hits hard, and I laugh, bitter, short.

“Used Ryan?” I say, loud, standing up. “That’s crap. He’s lying—spinning it all.”

Benji nods, back at his laptop. “He’s good at this,” he says, grim. “Look—another one.”

I swipe down—new post, fresh. Caleb’s running The Static into the ground, just like he ruined us. There’s a photo—me outside the bar, head down, looking beat. Comments are flooding—loser, washed up, selfish prick. My hands shake, phone screen blurring. “He’s trashing me,” I say, voice low, pacing now. “Making it sound like I’m the problem.”

“He’s a jerk,” Benji says, typing fast. “Trying to kick you while you’re down.”

“Down?” I laugh again, mean, kicking the couch leg soft. “He’s burying me. Look at this—hundreds of likes, shares. People believe it.” My head’s spinning—Jake’s voice, that recorder he tried, now this. He’s been waiting, building this, and I didn’t see it coming. My throat’s tight, chest heaving. I see Ryan’s face—hurt, yelling—and now this? Like I’m screwing him too?

I scroll more, can’t help it. Clips keep popping—me yelling at Jake, cut to look like I’m raging for no reason. Another—me late to practice, edited to seem lazy. It’s all fake, chopped up, but it works—paints me as arrogant, a mess. Caleb Hart, the guy who can’t hold it together. My hands clench, wanting to smash something—Jake, the phone, anything. “He’s got old stuff,” I say, loud, turning to Benji. “How’d he even keep this?”

“Planned it,” Benji says, grim, eyes on his screen. “He’s been sitting on it, waiting to hit you.”

I stop pacing, lean on the wall, breathing hard. My name’s out there, viral, turning to dirt. Used Ryan. Ruined the band. Lies, all of it, but they’re sticking—people eating it up. My stomach’s sick, head pounding. I see us back then—me and Jake, tight once, before he drank it all away. Now he’s twisting that knife, and it’s cutting deep.

I drop back on the couch, phone hot in my hand. “This is bad,” I say, quiet, rubbing my face. “If this hits Ryan—if he sees it—he’ll think it’s true.”

“He won’t,” Benji says, firm, looking up. “He knows you. This is Jake’s garbage.”

“Maybe,” I mutter, but doubt’s creeping in. Ryan’s cracked—Miles, the fight, everything. This could push him over. My chest hurts, sharp, and I scroll again—stupid, but I do. An article pops up—some music blog, fresh, titled Caleb Hart: The Failure Who Keeps Falling. I click it, fast, eyes burning. It’s all there—Jake’s clips, his story, me as the selfish jerk who blew it all. Took Ryan’s dream, ran it dry.

Comments load—dozens, then hundreds. What a loser. Should’ve stayed gone. Ryan deserves better. Hate, mockery, piling fast. My laugh’s gone—replaced with something cold, heavy. It’s viral—spreading, trashing me, and I can’t stop it. My hands shake, phone slipping a little. Jake’s won this round, and I’m sinking.