Chapter 14: Caught in the Act (Caleb POV)

Ryan’s still holding that crumpled paper when I sit down next to him on the couch. Miles’s fraud—his dad’s name twisted into a trap—has him quiet, eyes dark. I’m buzzing, ready to tear Miles apart, but the cash shortfall’s nagging at me too. Fifty bucks gone last night, maybe more. It’s small next to fifty grand, but it’s something we can fix now.

“We need to check the money,” I say, leaning in. “You said it’s off. Let’s figure it out.”

He nods slow, sets the paper down. “Yeah,” he says, voice rough. “Been thinking that too. Someone’s taking it—or we’re messed up somewhere.”

“Leah,” I say, low. “She was weird last night—left fast. And Miles gave her that card.”

His jaw tightens. “You think she’s stealing?”

“Don’t know,” I say, shrugging. “But we can find out. Set a trap.”

He looks at me, eyes narrowing. “Trap how?”

“Mark the cash,” I say, leaning forward. “Put some bills in the register—ones we know. See if they’re gone later. If it’s her, we’ll catch it.”

He rubs his face, sighs. “Okay. Let’s do it. Tonight.”

We don’t waste time. Downstairs, the bar’s quiet—midday, no crowd yet. Ryan grabs a marker from the drawer, pulls out a stack of tens from the safe. “These,” he says, scribbling a tiny dot in the corner of each—small, easy to miss unless you’re looking. “Ten bills. Hundred bucks.”

I watch him, hands steady even now. “Enough to tempt her,” I say. “Not enough to kill us.”

“Yeah,” he mutters, sliding them into the register. “Shift starts soon. We’ll see.”

Leah shows up at five, apron on, hair pulled back. She’s quiet—quieter than usual—nodding at us as she takes over the bar. The night’s slow—few regulars, soft music from the jukebox. I stick by the soundboard, pretending to tweak it, keeping an eye on her. Ryan’s near the back, wiping tables, watching too. We don’t talk, just move like nothing’s up.

She’s good—smooth, pouring beers, chatting with Hank at the counter. But I see her hands—quick, darting to the register more than they need to. My gut twists. I want to be wrong, but I’m not sure I am. Around ten, the place thins out—Hank stumbles home, last few stragglers pay up. Ryan nods at me, subtle, and I head to the bar.

“Closing early,” he says loud enough for her to hear. “Slow night. Count it out, Leah.”

She nods, starts pulling cash from the register—bills, coins, stacking them neat. Ryan steps up, casual, but his eyes are sharp. “I’ll check it,” he says, taking the pile.

I lean on the counter, heart thumping, watching him flip through. He stops, pulls out a ten—there’s the dot, clear as day. Then another. My chest goes tight. “Leah,” he says, voice low, holding them up. “These are marked. Where’d the rest go?”

She freezes, eyes wide, hands still on the bar. “What?” she says, voice shaky. “I don’t—”

“Don’t,” he cuts in, tired, not mad. “Ten bills went in. Six here. Where’s the other forty?”

Her face goes white, lips trembling. “Ryan, I—” She stops, looks down, hands twisting her apron. “I’m sorry,” she whispers, barely loud enough to hear.

I step closer, anger bubbling. “You’ve been stealing? From us?”

“Caleb,” Ryan says, sharp, holding a hand up. I stop, but my fists clench. He turns to her, eyes heavy. “Why?”

She’s shaking now, tears brimming. “I’m broke,” she says, voice cracking. “Rent, bills—I can’t keep up. I thought—I thought the bar’s done anyway. Just borrowed it. I swear.”

“Borrowed?” I snap. “That’s crap, Leah. We’re fighting to save this place, and you’re taking?”

“Caleb, enough,” Ryan says, quieter now. He looks at her, not yelling, just worn out. “How much? Total?”

She swallows hard. “Hundred, maybe. Over a few nights. I—I was gonna pay it back.”

He sighs, rubs his eyes. I wait for him to fire her—yell, something—but he doesn’t. “You’re done taking,” he says, slow. “One last chance, Leah. Help us fix this, or you’re out. No more.”

She nods fast, tears spilling now. “I will. I’m sorry, Ryan. I didn’t mean—”

“Save it,” he says, cutting her off. “Go home. Shift’s over.”

She grabs her bag, heads out quick, head down. The door shuts, and it’s just us. I turn to him, mad still. “You’re letting her stay? After that?”

“She’s scared,” he says, voice flat. “Broke. I get it. Doesn’t make it right, but I’m not tossing her yet.”

“She could’ve cost us,” I say, pacing. “And that card from Miles—what’s that about?”

“Don’t know,” he says, stacking the cash again. “We’ll watch her. But we’ve got bigger fights.”

I stop, lean on the bar. He’s right—Miles, the loan, that’s the real mess. Leah’s small next to it. But it stings, her taking from us when we’re barely hanging on. Ryan’s too soft sometimes—too good. I’d have kicked her out.

He locks the cash box, looks at me. “You okay?”

“Yeah,” I lie, shrugging. “Just pissed.”

“Me too,” he says, soft. “But we’re still here.”

I nod, let it drop. He heads upstairs, and I follow, lights off behind us. The bar’s quiet again—too quiet. My head’s loud, though—Miles, Leah, the marked bills. We’re holding, but it’s thin.

I crash on the couch, Ryan in the backroom. I don’t sleep much, just stare at the ceiling, thinking. Leah’s face sticks with me—scared, guilty, breaking. I almost feel bad, but then I don’t. She chose this.

Next morning, I’m up early, coffee burning my throat. Ryan’s still out, so I head down, check the bar. It’s empty, air cold. I spot Leah’s apron on a stool—forgot it last night. I grab it, shake it out, and something falls—a white card, sharp edges. I pick it up, flip it over. Miles Carver, Carver Holdings. His number’s there, bold and black.

My gut twists. She’s got it—kept it. I stare at it, her guilt hitting me again. She’s caught, yeah—but now what?