Chapter 29: I Can't Tell You
Evangeline P.O.V.
"What the hell do you mean no one gets out??"
"There are only two people who can enter and then leave this forest. Three if you count that thing out there." She crossed the room and sat down on a small sofa.
The cottage was quaint, with two sofas on the far side of the room beside a fireplace with small table in the middle. One wall had a sink and stove, while the other had a small kitchenette.
"Okay, who are the other two?" I stared at her, not daring to move in case this was a total trap.
"I can't tell you." She reached for a cup off of the table in front of her and took a small sip of whatever was inside of it. I studied her while she drank. She was well put together, like she hadn't been living out here at all. Her hair was long and fiery red, and her skin was pale. If she was scared of what was out there, she didn't show it. In fact, she had a calming demeanor that never left, not even when I was begging to come inside.
"Can you tell me who you are?" I crossed my arms, slowly starting to get irritated with her beating around the bush.
"I'm not supposed to, but then again, no one is supposed to enter the forest." She sighed and set her cup back down.
I threw my arms up in frustration at her. How the hell was I supposed to get out of here?
"You said you were camping? Were you with a group?" She turned her head towards me, her face lacked an expression.
"Why should I tell you anything when you won't do the same for me?"
"Do you want to live?" She said flatly.
My eyes widen and my heart beat started to pick up its pace. Holy shit, she was going to kill me. Maybe that thing outside was trying to keep me from coming in here.
"Relax. Evangeline, was it?"
I couldn't form any words, so I just nodded my head.
"Do you go to Maybury?" She looked away from me and stared at the ground. Wait- did she also go to Maybury? Is this how she got stuck out here?
"Yes." My voice came out small and squeaky. She hummed, never moving her gaze away.
A bang came at the door. I jumped and ran across the room towards the girl, ducking behind the side of the couch. The girl stood up and took small steps backward toward me.
"It'll go away, it does this sometimes." She said smoothly. Her calm demeanor did nothing to ease the panic that was surging through me. I stayed silent, afraid that if I spoke it would bang on the door again.
After what felt like an eternity of silence, she moved away and sat back down. I blew out a long breath and followed her. I sat across from her on the other sofa.
"How did you get stuck out here?" I managed to get it all out without my voice cracking.
"I was brought here. It was safer for me at the time." She leaned her head against her knuckles, her elbow propped on the side of the couch, staring at me.
"Safer? How if that thing is trying to kill us!"
"It isn't trying to kill me. It wants you. I've been out here long enough and it never comes near me." Her lips turned up, almost smirking, but faded within seconds. She wasn't going to show any hospitality besides allowing me in here.
"It lured you in here, and now it wants to finish what it started. It can't move on to the next until it does."
On to the next? I thought back to what Serenity had told around the campfire. Was her story true? That thing that lured me in wants to kill me just like it did to those other people?
"So you've seen it do this before?" I asked, hoping she would give me a straight answer.
"Oh I don't know, you're the first person to find my cottage. But I don't doubt it." She picked up the cup again and brought it to her lips.
A small knock sounded at the door. A lot softer than the first bang we heard. Two knocks followed after in a precise way that mimicked a code.
The girl whipped her head to the door as she listened.
"Hide. There's space under the sofa, don't make a sound." She whispered.
"What-" She shushed me and pointed to the bottom of the sofa that was covered by its skirt. I moved quickly and shoved my body under the sofa, making sure my feet didn't stick out from the bottom.
I could hear her footsteps move across the floor and to the door. There was a pause before she started unlocking the locks on the door.
The door creaked open and another pair of footsteps walked in, followed by another.
"Lily, how are you? Has anyone come by here? Another girl, perhaps?" The voice sounded familiar, but I couldn't figure it out.
"No one has been here. Did something happen?" The girl spoke."
The footsteps neared the sofa that the girl had been sitting on. I could see the shadows passing as they walked through the cottage.
"A girl went missing from the camp nearby. She was a student, I was hoping she may have crossed your path." Was that Dean Lainey?
I had only encountered her once during that silly meeting with Serenity, but now that I really listened, it sounded exactly like her.
"Lily, if someone comes by here, please inform us. We've kept you safe, so do us this much." Another voice, higher-pitched this time, spoke.
"Are you threatening me? I haven't seen anyone or heard anything. Now, is that all? If so, please leave." Lily's voice was sharp, angry, the most emotion I've heard from her since I showed up.
"Yes, Lily. That's all. Stay safe, okay? We'll come back for our monthly check-in soon." It was Dean Lainey speaking now.
I heard the door open again, and the footsteps moving towards the door. Eventually, the door shut, and the locks started clicking into place.
"You can come out now."
I crawled out from under the sofa. Lily was still by the door, her face had fallen back into her usual expression.
"Was that Dean Lainey?" I dusted myself off after getting up from the floor.
"Yes." Her reply was curt. I knew I shouldn't push because that hadn't worked the last time, but she seemed angry now so maybe she would crack.
"Why are they keeping you here?" She looked away from me.
"I told you, it's safer for me. Normally, no one finds my cottage, so it's safe."
Finally, something clicked. Lily. Juniper had mentioned her when she told me about Finley's previous relationship and Serenity. This was Lily. The Lily. The one that disappeared. No one knew what happened, and this was why.
She was here. In the forest.