Chapter 12: Watch Yourself
We hurried across the courtyard back to the dorms.
The screaming from the dining hall could still be heard from a distance meaning the food fight was still going on. I was probably going to be in deep shit for that later.
Entering the dorms, we took the elevator to the third floor. As soon as we got into our room, Juniper stopped in the middle and whipped her head around at me.
"That was HILARIOUS Evie! You should've seen everyone's face when you threw that tray at her." Juniper started laughing hysterically at the events that had just transpired.
"I thought you were going to be mad at me with the way you just walked in here, honestly. And I wasn't even focused on anyone else but her. I should've just let it go."
"Oh totally not Evie, she deserved that for calling you trash! Screw her, but you should watch your back. I heard what she said to you while we were escaping that disaster."
I folded my arms across my chest and just stared at the ceiling. I really shouldn't have thrown the tray at her, but I didn't want to just lay down and take whatever shit Serenity thought she could throw at me. Plus if she can't handle it being thrown back at her, she shouldn't dish it out.
"And how does one watch their back around her? I heard what people were saying about me in there, what exactly did she do to the other girl that was so horrible?"
Jeremy and Juniper both looked at each other and shared a questionable look.
"You should sit down for this if we're going to tell you." Juniper sat on our round carpet rug and patted the floor beside her.
I sat down with a thud and crossed my legs. Resting my face on my hands and my elbows on my knee, I raised my eyebrows at Juniper. "Okay, so spill it."
"At the beginning of our first year here, Serenity of course, developed the hots for Finley through archery. She talked about it nonstop. But there was another girl in archery as well..."
Juniper's face turned grim, as if she were reliving the memory by telling it to me.
"Her name was Lily, and she was on Finley's team, whereas Serenity was on another team. You can only imagine how upset Serenity was when they announced who was on which team."
"Wait- but then how is Serenity on Finley's team now? He was helping her during the training session today."
"She isn't, she just demands his attention, pretty sure she threatened Richards too which is why he takes a back seat to all of her shit."
"Oh, interesting..."
"Anyways, Lily and Finley started hanging out, they definitely liked each other at some point, but Serenity would, and still will, always have her way. She did everything she could to keep them separated and her as close to Finley as possible. One night at a house party, Serenity was seen talking to Lily, no one knows what was said, just that Lily ended up leaving in tears."
"I personally think she threatened the poor girl, which is why you need to be careful, as much as it is funny to see it handed back to her, she's dangerous." Jeremy interjected.
"That's not all though. After Lily left the party, several people saw her come back to the dorms. They said they could hear her screaming and saying things about Serenity. But after that night, she was gone. No one saw her leave the dorms, no one heard anything, her roommate said she came back and all of her stuff was gone. It was like Lily vanished into the night."
My mouth was a gaping hole after Juniper finished the story. This was sounding like a murder mystery as this point, and maybe dealing with Serenity was more daunting than I lead on with everyone.
"No one tried contacting her? Contacting authorities?"
"We did, but they closed the case. Someone came forward and said that she was safe, but I have a suspicion that a certain someone made up lies to get rid of her name around campus completely."
This was becoming too much. Was Serenity a secret murderer? She was a mean girl, no doubt about that, but she didn't come off as the type to actually physically hurt someone.
"So you're telling me, that Lily messed with what Serenity thought was hers, and maybe murdered her after a house party, a house party you now want me to go to, with Serenity having her murderous gaze locked onto me now?"
"Evie, I promise you, we would never let Serenity hurt you or do anything to you." Juniper grasped my hand in hers and gave me a weak smile.
I wasn't that worried about Serenity as long as I had them by my side, but I was still on edge after hearing the story. Something else that bothered me was what else Maybury had lurking under the surface.
First the town was odd, then the people on campus were also slightly weird, and now there's a chance the girl who could kill me with her glare actually killed someone and I was next.
I stood to my feet, honestly it was getting late and I needed to mentally prepare myself for tomorrow.
"Thanks for telling me the story Juniper, let's hope I'm not the next Lily of Maybury." I gave a dry laugh, trying to ease the tension that had been building in the room.
"You won't Evangeline, like Juniper said, we won't let her hurt you." Jeremy gave a soft pat on my back. "I'll catch you ladies tomorrow for breakfast, yeah?"
Jeremy kissed Juniper on the forehead and gave her a sweet smile before turning to the door and leaving.
Juniper and I exchanged a glance, one filled with uncertainty of what was to come tomorrow, and something else I couldn't put my finger on.
"Goodnight Juniper." I climbed into bed without a second thought or glance back to her, I just needed tonight to be over with.
"Goodnight Evie."
I heard the click of the light switch and everything went dark.