Chapter 59

Elise's POV

I notice Kaelen's discomfort right from the moment I joined them. He is trying to hide it behind a calm front and politeness but his eyes keep flicking to me and Jordan, like he can't decide which one of us is the bigger threat. Truthfully, I didn't expect Jordan to be here but he is a welcome reprieve.

On the flight over I had rehearsed the awkward small talk I'd need to make with Kaelen, the smiles I would have to hand out to our parents, and the effort it would take to play along with whatever excuse he would give this time for our situation. Jordans presence is a curve ball I welcome openly because truth is, it makes things easier for me. He is the variable Kaelen can't control and I'm not sure I've ever been so grateful for someone's existence.

I know. I should probably be feeling some type of way... jealous maybe because I know it is Jordan who replaced me, but the truth is, he didn't really replace me. I was just holding his place until he came along. His presence gives me freedom not to perform. Instead of clinging to Kaelen's side or waiting for him too initiate another round of passive avoidance, I lean into Jordan. Not to be petty or cruel but because I genuinely want to.

Jordan is sweet, polite, awkward in a wat that makes you want to tease him but also protect him. I find myself watching him more than Kaelen throughout our shopping spree and it doesn't feel wrong. I mean... I'm not attracted to him obviously. I just feel strangely safe and secure around him. He has no layers or thick walls between him and his real character and that's something I haven't had with anyone. My parents, Kaelen or even my friends. Interacting with him is not suffocating at all.

At the mall, Kaelen squirms as he passively watches us and a part of me enjoys that. The bigger part however just enjoys how Jordan lights up when he talks about fashion, how his quiet opinions are surprisingly well informed. He doesn't try to impress. He is just in his element here. Right at home.

"You are officially my shopping partner now. I'm claiming you," I say as we walk out after paying for everything.

He purses his lips. "Just so we are clear... are you going to be paying me per hour or per each piece I help you decide to pick? Because you are a disaster when it comes to choosing and I rather think that would be a lucrative business deal for me."

I gasp. "You pick on too fast, huh?" I laugh. "And here I was thinking I could take advantage of you."

"Oh, darling. You thought wrong," he responds in the same teasing tone and we laugh it off heading to the car, Kaelen a few steps behind us.

We make one more stop for ice cream. I make sure to steer the conversation towards Jordan again like asking about his favorite flavors and toppings. Kaelen sits quietly like a guest in his own story, occasionally glancing at us while stirring his barely touched cup. He keeps trying to catch my eye but I actively ignore him.

He wants to talk, I know. I can see it in the way he fiddles with anything he can grasp, his mouth twitching like he is biting back words. He made me wait for hours, even ignored my messages. I think it's only fair to make him wait. I'm not yet ready to let him off the hook. I want to enjoy this moment, watching him squirm while I bond with the boy he us clearly terrified of losing but won't admit it out loud.

When we get home an hour later, the place is buzzing with activity in preparation for Thanksgiving dinner. Marta meets us at the door and informs us that our parents are home and are in a meeting in Kaelen's father's study. I don't say much except exchange greetings then take the familiar path upstairs to the room that has been called mine for years.

They never let me sleep in Kaelen's room which is laughable now. I remember sneaking to his room every night I was there, making out with him all through highschool like I meant something, even confiding in him thinking that we were going to last forever. Now I feel ridiculous.

I sit on the edge of the bed and run my fingers over the comforter. I feel the echo of my heartbreak mocking me in the silence. Why didn't he just tell me? Why did he let me believe in something that was never real? That could never be real. A few tears spill before I can stop them. I swipe them away quickly willing myself to stay composed. I can't let myself fall apart over this.

A knock at the door startles me. I clear my throat. "Come in." The door pushes open slowly and Kaelen appears, head first before he steps in cautiously. I square my shoulders and put my mask back on. "What are you doing here?" I ask casually.

He stops near the door, his expression stiff and awkward. "Can we talk? Please."

I nod, shifting on the bed for more comfort. "Okay. I guess you are finally ready to stop ignoring me."

"You asked what we are going to tell our parents," he says, dismissing my tone which I'm grateful for. I don't know what came over me. That is not how I want to handle this. "I didn't answer earlier because I didn't know how to. But I think..." he pauses and takes a step forward. "We should tell them the truth that we are not together. That we haven't been for a while."

I blink. "Really?" To be honest, this is not what I thought he was coming to say. Maybe he is after all more ballsy than I gave him credit for.

His gaze holds mine. "Do you really want to keep pretending forever? It's hurting everyone involved, including you."

I swallow. Well, at least he has noticed that. I nod. "Okay. Sounds good to me."

"I'm sorry," he says softly. "I'm sorry for stringing you along, Elise. You didn't deserve that."

"It's fine," I wave it off even though it stings. Then, I decide to bait him. "It's not like you are keeping any more secrets from me, right?"

"Actually..." he pauses, this time for too long that I can almost hear the air around us crackling with tension but that's nothing compared to the tension in his face. For a second, I think I see him quiver. "There is something else I've been meaning to tell you."

Here it is. Finally. I think as my heart makes a giant leap against my ribs. "Okay," I say gently trying to to sound too eager. "What is it?"

He opens his mouth to speak but before a sound comes out there is an urgent knock. We both turn.

"Kaelen," one of the maids calls from the hallway. "Your father needs you in his study. He said it's urgent."

Kaelen turns back to me slowly and exhales deeply. I'm not sure if the interruption relieved him or not but his eyes are apologetic.

"It's okay, go ahead," I say the moment I notice the conflict in his eyes.

"I'm sorry. I'll come find you as soon as I'm done with my father."

I nod but I don't speak. He leaves and I let out a long sigh. There is something about people like me and Kaelen, people who have grown up without the freedom to choose our own paths. While it was easy for me to just obey my parents wishes because I fell in love with Kaelen, his is a different case. Somehow even without him needing to say anything, I find myself feeling bad for him.

This is not going to be easy. It's either hell freezes over and Nate Ashford has a change of heart, or Kaelen stands up for himself like his brother Lucas did. And knowing Kaelen... let's just say I wish it was someone else on the verge of receiving an unrecoverable heartbreak and not sweet soft Jordan.