Chapter 46

Kaelen's POV

Elise is not just some random girl I can turn down easily. She is not just an ex. This is the girl I have known for over four years, the girl who has treated me better than anyone I know in my life. The girl who learned my moods before I ever understood them myself and the girl my parents already call a daughter.

For so long I thought we would end up together and I pictured this happening. Just not like this. I know she is not asking for love or a second chance. It doesn't have to mean anything and I know it won't, at least for me. But still, I hesitate.

"Kaelen," she whispers. "I'm not going to beg for it." It's the way her voice shakes that breaks me. "You don't owe me anything but this is the one thing you can give me, out of your own will to give me some closure."

I sit back in bed, my gaze turned away from her. I let the words sink in. My whole body feels cold, like it doesn't belong to me. Perhaps that's what I need it to be in this moment.

"Alright," I say in a low voice and slowly turn to her. "But this isn't what's going to stop us from falling apart."

"I know that very well," she nods, and she doesn't smile. She leans in closer, slowly like she is afraid I'm going to change my mind. But I don't.

I don't remember how the rest of it unfolds, not clearly. I remember her fingers on my skin, soft and uncertain. I remember her breath catching when I touched her and I remember feeling everything and nothing at once.

I try to close my eyes and imagine it's someone else but I don't. I let it be what it really is— sad, empty, haunting. There is no passion or joy in it and at the end of it all, I simply don't know what to think of what used to be between us.

Afterward, she lies curled up beside me, breathing slowly. We don't talk. Neither of us says a word. I lie on my back staring at the ceiling and all I can think about is Jordan. What I've just done is wrong. I don't want to imagine how he would feel if he knew. This is a betrayal even if Elise and I aren't anything more. And even though I knew that, I still let it happen.

The entire night I don't sleep. I just wait for morning to come so I can go back to the life that finally started to feel like mine, far away from the mansion that now feels like a prison, from the perfect lies, and from the girl who once had my future written all over her.

But life has a way of torturing someone when they desperately want a break, doesn't it?

I find myself trapped at the breakfast table the following day, pushing the food around on my plate absently. My mother's voice chatters on like a distant murmur in my ears. Elise sits next to me, chatty as ever with my Mom, smiling like nothing has changed between us. I hate that I have to carry all this weight alone. But I brought it on myself.

"You okay, Kae?" she nudges me, leaning closer with a smile.

"Yeah, I'm fine," I mutter, my voice thick. I can't bring myself to look at her.

"Are you sure?" she asks, her voice lower. I'm sure she means well, but the soft look in her eyes only makes my guilt gnaw at me more.

"Kaelen, Thanksgiving is coming soon. You are going to be here, right? We are hosting it this time and the Thompson's are flying in to join us. Elise has been telling me how excited she is that she is going to see her parents after so many months." I turn to Elise slowly but barely hold her gaze for two seconds. "I know you have gotten attached to the school, surprisingly but don't miss Thanksgiving. You can't possibly have other plans and if you did, cancel them."

My mind flashes to Jordan. Thanksgiving hasn't been part of our conversations. I guess because it's still a bit far but now, I would rather be with him than be trapped here. I don't have a choice though.

"Sure," I say flatly, my voice distant.

The word tastes bitter in my mouth. I don't want to come home again so soon. Not with the demons hanging in the air, whooshing and whispering about my long line of stupid mistakes. My mother gives me a long questioning look but she doesn't ask anything.

Giving up on ever getting the food in my mouth, I push my plate away and get up. "It's time to head back," I announce and accord my mother a brief look. "I'll see you next time."

I don't wait for her response as my mind switches off, Jordan's thoughts seeping right in. The way he makes me feel like I matter, like I don't have an image to maintain. What will I say to him now? How will I explain this mess?

★★★

The plane ride is quiet except for the hum of the engines that does little to calm my racing thoughts. I can feel Elise's gaze on me but I don't dare look at her. Until she breaks the silence.

"Okay, come on. What's with the sulking? Most guys would be thrilled to get free sex with no strings attached but here you are acting like you are about to be crucified."

"I'm not most guys," I grumble under my breath.

"Why do you look like you have committed the worst crime in the universe?" She chuckles wearily. "Jeez, it's like you have cheated on someone and now you can't handle the guilt." I turn to her slowly, feeling like my whole skin has been peeled off exposing everything going on inside me. My mistake. Elise's face falls, her skin turning pale. She stares at me with a mixture of confusion and hurt. "You lied to me?"

"Elise, it's not that easy," I try.

"You lied to me, Kaelen. You looked me in the eyes and said that there was no one else!" she breathes. "I believed you and now you are... what? Mad at me for what we did last night?"

"I'm not mad at you, Elise. I'm mad at myself!" I snap, then lean back in my seat with a heavy sigh. She looks at me, waiting for more explanation but I go silent. The truth is too complicated right now and I don't know how to explain it to her without making it worse. "I'm sorry," I manage.

She stares at me for a long time before she sighs. "It's fine. You should have just told me the truth but it's fine. Like I said, there are no strings attached. But do better for the other person."

I nod but it doesn't make me feel better. The guilt weighs me down making it hard to breathe. By the time the plane lands, I'm damn near exploding. I don't feel like I'm in the right condition to see Jordan in that moment so I head straight back to school. The lonely dorm feels like a refuge now more than ever. I lock myself inside and slump on my bed, letting everything inside me crash me down.