Chapter 94: Tainted memories

NANCY’S POV

His face hardened. Gone was the pity I had just seen surface in his eyes for me. “Then you’re choosing to stay blind.”

That hit.

Hard.

I clenched my fists, forcing myself to look again.

At the two images, side by side. It was undeniably the same person.

It broke me further. My voice crumbled. “….Why?”

Before I could stop it, a tear slid down my face, running the length of my cheek until I felt it on my neck, pooling on my clavicle.

Mr Landon frowned, and his gaze locked on my neck.

“He got close to you,” he said finally. “Gained your trust. That’s how this works.”

Immediately after saying that, he looked away, as if he couldn’t bear to keep looking at me.

I didn’t try to find out if it was true. I shook my head again, slower this time.

“No, you don’t understand… he wasn’t just around me, he was…”

He was my friend.

I believed Mason would have my back anytime, just as much as I would have his.

“We did things together…” I breathed out instead. “Classes, lunch…he knew things about me.”

“Exactly.”

The word sliced through me.

“That’s not proof!” I argued. “That just means he cared!”

“Or that he was collecting information.”

My chest tightened again.

“No…” I whispered.

But the doubt, it was there now, growing steadily and surely.

The truth was ugly and unavoidable.

Mr Landon's gaze sharpened again. “What kind of questions did he ask you?”

“Normal ones,” I breathed in, pushing past the lump in my throat. I spoke slowly. “Just…normal. Like my schedules, where I lived before this…”

His expression hardened.

“That’s not normal.”

“It is,” I countered. “Anyone interested in you would ask such questions.”

He went quiet for a second, then shook his head loosely. “Stop running from the truth, Nancy.”

The implication sank in. And when it did, my stomach dropped.

I couldn’t breathe.

It felt like everything around me was closing in. The walls seemed to be pressing in closer, the air felt like it was tightening, and my mind felt too smothered, like it was carrying too much.

Mason.

The name alone made my stomach churn.

I turned away from Mr Landon, dragging in a deep breath through my nose as I ran my hand through my hair, like that would somehow make this all make sense.

It didn’t.

Nothing did.

“He said he loved me…” I whispered again, more to myself this time.

And now, now I didn't know if those words had ever been real.

My lips parted, and a broken laughter wracked through my body.

“Was anything even real?” I asked, my voice shaking.

Jaxon didn’t answer immediately.

I turned to him sharply. “Was it?”

“Yes.”

The certainty in his voice only made it worse.

“How do you know?” I demanded. “How do you know what’s real and what isn’t when everything around you is a lie?!”

Everything around me sure was turning out to be a lie. Statistically, how many people in the world have gone through this?

His jaw tightened. “Not everything is.”

“That’s easy for you to say!” I snapped. “You live a double life! You lie for a living!”

His eyes darkened slightly. “I only lied to protect you.”

I snorted. “Of course you’d call it protection.”

All over again, I was mad. Anger coursed through my veins like blood, boiling everything in its path.

“Throwing that word around doesn’t fix anything.” I bit out.

“It doesn’t fix anything,” he answered, levelling an even gaze on me. “But it keeps you alive.”

“I don’t care!” I burst out.

My voice cut through the silence.

“I don’t care about any of this right now!” I continued, chest now rising and falling fast. “I just..I need a minute. I need to think.”

“You don’t have that luxury.”

“I do!” I snapped back. “I’m not you, Jaxon! I can’t just…just switch off my emotions and act like this is normal!”

“I’m not asking you to act like anything,” he said, his tone hardening. “I’m asking you to stay inside.”

“I need air.”

“No.”

The refusal came instantly. His voice was firm and unyielding.

I clenched my teeth hard, and my voice turned frosty.

“You don’t get to tell me what to do.”

“You walk out that door right now,” he stood up and walked over, stepping in front of me, “and you’re putting a target on your back.”

“I already have a target on my back!” I shot back. “Thanks to all of this!”

“And walking out won’t change that.”

“I don’t care!” I repeated. “I need space!”

“You need to stay alive.”

“I need to breathe!”

Silence cracked between us, and his gaze locked onto me, suffocating in its intensity.

His voice softened.

“Don’t do this, Nancy.”

“Move.”

“I’m not stopping you,” he said, though his body didn’t shift an inch. “I’m warning you.”

“Move,” I repeated, my voice trembling now, not with fear, but frustration.

For a second, I thought he wouldn’t.

That he’d block the door, or force me to stay. But then, he stepped aside.

Not because he agreed, but because he knew I was going anyway.

“Five minutes,” he said.

I didn’t respond; I just sidestepped past him, walking straight to the door.

The cold air hit me the instant I walked out, sharp against my skin, but I didn’t stop.

I didn’t look back either, I just kept walking, doing all I could to get away from that house, from him, from everything.

My thoughts spiralled the second I stepped outside.

Mason’s face, his voice, the way he used to look at me.

Was that real?

Or just another lie?

I wrapped my arms around myself, but it did nothing to stop the chill crawling under my skin.

Every memory felt…tainted now.

“He was watching me…” I whispered to myself.

The words didn’t feel real, and a shaky breath left my lips.

“God…” I murmured, pressing my hand to my forehead. “What is happening to my life?”