Chapter 84: The truth exposed

NANCY’S POV

I exhaled loudly, stabilizing my breath before pushing the door open.

I’d seen his car outside, so I knew he would be in here. The entire time, while I took a walk down the street, my mind had replayed everything that I had seen.

Till now, it still seemed unbelievable, but I had seen it all clearly, with my own eyes, so I had to believe it.

After stepping into the house, I inhaled again, knowing I would have to face him soon. My mind told me now was the right time to confront him with what I had found, but a smaller part of me was against it.

The latter told me to let things be and not raise an argument, and for a brief second, I debated agreeing with it.

I was still trying to think of what to do when his voice reached me.

“I was wondering when you would return.”

My entire body went rigid.

Slowly, I turned my body.

When I walked in, I had been so engrossed in my thoughts that I hadn’t realised he was in the living room, sitting on the sofa.

The only thing brightening up the room was the dim lamp on a stool in the corner, and the lights being turned off was the reason I was unsuspecting of his presence in the living room.

Unhurriedly, he stood up and turned around as well, facing me.

The look on his face made my stomach drop instantly.

“Mr Landon…” I stopped at that, clueless as to what else to say.

While I was out, I had practiced this conversation with him so many times, more times than I could count.

I imagined what I would say to him, how he would react to whatever I said. But now that he stood in front of me, I was stumped on what to say to him.

My mind couldn’t think of a way to begin or what to say to break the silence, so I just stared at him.

While I was still wondering what to say to him, he spoke.

“You went into my study.”

He wasn’t asking me; he spoke like he already knew.

My chest hammered once. For half a second, I considered denying it or lying, but my expression must have betrayed me because his gaze hardened immediately.

“You did, didn't you?”

My lips parted, and I struggled to formulate words.

“I…” My voice broke slightly, and I cleared my throat. “I don’t know what you’re talking about.”

That was the wrong answer.

He started walking toward me with slow steps.

My eyes enlarged slightly, and I backed up a few steps, avoiding him.

He stopped a few feet from me, then muttered flatly, “You’re a terrible liar.”

Okay, I think I kind of agreed with that.

My reaction had already given me away even before I spoke.

“Even if you don’t admit it, I know you went into my study.”

Staring back at his certain eyes, I knew I could no longer deny it, so I whispered, “Yes.”

Silence fell between us, stretching so long until it became smothering. I didn’t know what to do with my hands, or my thoughts, not even myself.

After what seemed like forever, he finally spoke again.

“Why?”

I hesitated a while before answering, “Because I needed answers.”

His jaw tightened slightly.

“About what?”

I swallowed hard. “The photos.”

Something flickered across his face, not shock but recognition and confirmation, as if he already knew what I had seen.

I took a shaky step back. “And Lily.”

That did it.

His eyes hardened instantly.

“So you couldn’t just trust me? You had to go snoop around in my office?”

“I didn’t…” He cut me off before I could finish.

He shook his head slightly, eyes filling with disappointment. “You could have just asked me, Nancy.”

I don’t know what it was exactly, but something about the way he said it, and how disappointed he looked while saying that, made my breath stutter.

It made me realise that I would rather have us argue out of anger than see him lose his trust in me.

The emotions rose from nowhere, and without stopping to think about what I was about to do, my voice rose.

“Then explain it, Mr Landon. Lily is missing, and I saw her picture in your drawer!”

I expected to feel a measure of relief after yelling at him like that, but all my chest did was tighten instead, until it felt like I couldn’t breathe.

That was the moment I should have stopped, but I didn’t.

His gaze flattened on me until it looked like every emotion in his eyes had ebbed away.

“You had no right to go through my things,” he said.

“I had no right?” I let out a bitter laugh that came out wrong. “You have pictures of girls being watched like they don’t know it! What am I supposed to think?”

“Moreover, just like with Hudson, all I did was tell you about Lily approaching me, and now she’s missing.”

The part of me that was still logical told me not to accuse him, but I already did, and now, I had to stand on my words.

He didn’t speak and instead took a step closer.

I stepped back immediately, in a bid to put more distance between us.

My eyes roved, and my heart began to beat faster, faster than it should have, even though I was angry.

“No,” I choked out quickly, holding my hands in deterrence. “Don’t come near me.”

He paused for a moment, his eyes flickered, and then his voice dropped lower. “Nancy, calm down. You’re panicking.”

I thought I heard his voice soften, but I was too caught up in my emotions to process it.

“I’m not panicking…I’m thinking clearly for the first time!”

My back hit the wall soon enough. I didn’t even realize I’d been retreating until I couldn’t go further.