Chapter 112: Acceptance of failure
JAXON’S POV
I leaned back in my chair, staring at the glass of melting ice water in my hand.
Earlier, I had grabbed it to cool myself down, but hadn’t actually taken a sip from it.
“I was at the hotel earlier to drop off Nancy’s phone, she left again.”
Nathan’s sigh broke through my thoughts, and the mention of Nancy’s name snagged my attention to him.
“She left the hotel?”
“Yes,” Nathan nodded, looking somewhat gloomy. “I understand she’s hurt….Hell, she's my sister, and I hate seeing her hurt, but she’s also being too stubborn.”
He sighed again, then lifted his hand to knead his shoulder, starting with his right before moving into his left, like he was carrying some kind of huge weight.
And to be fair, he was.
I had tasked him with getting Nancy to the hotel and keeping her safe, and knowing Nancy, I knew how difficult that task could turn out, even though it seemed and sounded easy.
However, instead of what Nathan said, my mind decided to focus on something else.
Like every other time when I thought of this, guilt swarmed me, causing my throat to tighten.
Even without hearing it from Nathan, I knew Nancy was hurt. I’d seen it in her expression, heard it from her words, and one thing I could tell now was that I absolutely hated that.
It was never my intention to hurt her, but I had ended up doing so.
Frankly, I’d hurt her even more than I ever imagined I could.
The feelings I thought I’d managed to bury after our conversation yesterday rose again, and my chest constricted.
I finally downed a gulp of the melted ice, feeling it cool a path down to my stomach.
If only my heart were as cold, if only…
My gaze lifted, and I began to stare at Nathan, whose lips were pursed tightly and whose brows were tightly drawn. He was no longer looking at me, and he seemed focused on his own thoughts.
A realization struck me then, and it turned out to be something I had been overlooking the entire time.
Now that my mind finally dredged it up for me, I couldn’t just keep silent.
“You knew, didn’t you?” I said, watching his reaction carefully.
My words weren’t even explicitly or directly said, but Nathan stiffened immediately, as though he had been fearing I would ask all along.
“About me and Nancy. You knew, didn’t you?”
His reaction had more or less given him away, but I still wanted to hear it from him.
He hung his head lower so I couldn’t see his face, and he kept it that way for a short while. I didn’t force him to raise his head, and silence stretched between us for a prolonged period of time.
Eventually, he lifted his head and gave a small nod.
“Yes, I did know.”
Silence fell between us again. This time, we glanced straight at each other as words passed between us.
Actually, on my end, I was trying to gauge how he felt about it, but there was one thing…. Nathan was just as unreadable as many said I was.
If he was really intent on keeping something hidden, then no one could force it out of him. The only reason I had even figured it out in the first place was because of his actions.
For someone who had seen my arguments with Nancy and heard what was said, he was too quiet.
Anyone else would have asked questions.
As her brother, he should have asked more, but he didn’t, and that was what gave away the fact that he already knew.
“Why didn’t you say anything?” I asked.
He withdrew his gaze then let out a loud, heavy exhale.
Leaning back, he shrugged lightly, and his lips curved slightly.
“She was happy.”
He didn’t add anything else, as if that was enough to explain everything else.
“You kept quiet because she was happy?”
I at least expected a punch across the face or a heated argument.
“Yes,” he nodded once more, as if this were just another conversation.
In a quieter voice, he added. “I was just trying to respect Nancy’s wishes. Moreover…she seemed content with you.”
“And that was enough for you?” I questioned, still not confused.
A bitter smile crossed his face. “I can’t dictate for her. Nancy’s her own person, and she’s smart enough to make her own choices.”
His gaze found mine once more, and another emotion slipped into his eyes, revealing a moment of vulnerability.
“Actually, if I’m being honest, I lost my cool when I found out. I was ready to kill you even if it cost me my own life, but…”
But?
I wanted to interrupt, but I held back and curled my fingers instead.
“When I first found out,” he continued. “I struggled really badly with it, but I guess I’m okay with it now.”
“Why?” The words slipped out before I could stop them.
Nathan smiled again.
“You know, New Jersey was a lot. Not just for me, but for Nancy. All our lives, we had to live under our father's control and do his wishes. Nancy felt that more than I did, and well, you know how it turned out.”
“She once told me she felt…trapped.”
Raising his hands, he wiped a palm across his face, then exhaled again.
“She didn’t look trapped with you. It was quite the opposite, and genuinely, that’s all I’ve ever wanted for her.”
Those words hit me hard, and I had to withdraw my gaze.
I couldn’t keep looking at Nathan when I now knew that I hadn’t lived up to his expectations.
Somehow, I seemed to have done even worse. At least, that was how I felt.
“I should have known better,” I muttered finally. “I ended up hurting her.”
Nathan let out a quiet breath. “Yeah, you did.”
His acknowledgment of my failure made me crumble, but I nodded slowly, accepting it.