Chapter 107: You did it anyway
NANCY’S POV
“Shut up!” I snapped, completely forgetting that I was just pleading with him a couple of seconds ago.
I turned to him with a glare. “You don’t get to….”
“Then say it’s not true,” he cut in, his voice low and deliberate.
My breath hitched while Diana’s eyes widened slightly.
“…Nancy? What is he talking about?”
“Say it,” Mason pressed softly. “Tell her.”
I couldn’t breathe. If I told her the truth, if I told Diana what I was hiding, I would lose her.
However, if I didn’t, Mason would tell her anyway, and that would be so much worse than I imagined.
While I hesitated, Diana grabbed my arm.
“You’re scaring me,” she said. “What is he talking about?”
My lips parted soundlessly again.
“I…”
The word felt like it weighed a thousand pounds.
Mason leaned closer, his voice barely above a whisper.
“Tick tock…” He clicked his tongue mockingly.
My chest tightened painfully, and I shot him the nastiest look I could muster, then shifted my gaze to Diana.
“I’m sorry,” I whispered. My face wilted, and my lids drooped like a wilting flower.
Diana frowned. “For what?”
Tears burned my eyes, and then, I lifted my lowered head. “I didn’t mean for it to happen.”
Her grip on my arm tightened. “…Nancy.”
“I didn’t plan it,” I said, shaking my head, my voice trembling. “I swear, I didn’t…”
“What are you saying?” she demanded, her voice rising.
I squeezed my eyes shut, and then I said it.
“I’m having an affair.”
Silence fell between us, loud and heavy.
Diana blinked. “I’m not following, what are you….”
“With your dad,” I finished, my voice barely audible.
The world stopped, and for a second, everything froze. Diana stiffened as well. She didn’t move, didn't blink, I wasn’t even sure she was still breathing.
That was how still she was.
I’d held my breath too, awaiting her reaction, but it wasn’t what I expected.
Instead of the curses and outbursts I anticipated, she laughed instead. Her laughter rang out, long and loud.
She chortled until she was wheezing for air.
“Oh my God, that was so funny. I don’t know what both of you were thinking, cooking up a joke like that.”
Her eyes switched between me and Mason, glistening at the corners with tears that had surfaced because of how hard she had laughed. “I knew you guys were playing a prank on me. How did I allow myself to fall for it?”
She chuckled again, harder.
“Diana…It’s not.” I bit down on my lower lip, unable to continue speaking.
As soon as I said that, Diana’s laughter ceased abruptly as though she had just processed what I said.
Her face went pale, quickly draining of all color.
“You’re joking.” She spat out in disbelief, head snapping from me to him, then back. “You can’t be serious.”
I wished I was joking.
Genuinely, I wished this were all a prank myself.
I shook my head slowly, mustering my courage to just rat myself out completely. Since I had already gathered enough courage to say the truth, I might as well own up to my actions and face the consequences.
With that thought in mind, I pressed my lips together and then answered Diana, speaking quietly.
“I wish I was.”
Her eyes went wide open, and she stumbled back.
“No,” she exclaimed, stepping back a couple of feet. “No, that’s… that’s disgusting.”
“I know….”
“That’s my father!” she shouted, interrupting me with a yell that rang out between us.
The force of her voice made me flinch. Many passersby turned their curious gazes to us, staring as they went on their way.
“I know,” I repeated weakly. “And I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to…”
“You didn’t mean to?”
“You didn't mean to? What the fuck do you mean by you didn't mean to, Nancy?!”
“How does something like that just happen?” she demanded, her voice shaking with anger.
A tear slipped down my cheeks before I could stop it.
“It just…did.”
“That’s not an answer!” she snapped. “You’re my best friend!”
“I know…”
“And you went behind my back and slept with my father?!”
“We didn’t…” I started, then stopped.
Because what was I going to say? I couldn’t lie, not anymore. Not when things had gotten to this stage. What excuse could I give that would make things right?
Nothing I said could excuse my behavior. The betrayal was already there.
Diana’s chest rose and fell rapidly, and she stared at me with bloodshot eyes, glaring daggers.
“How long?” she demanded.
“Tell me, how long has this nonsense been going on?” She yelled when I hesitated in giving her a response.
“…A while.” I forced out.
“A while?” she repeated incredulously. “A while?!”
“I was going to tell you…”
“When?!” she cut in sharply. “After what? After you get bored with him?!”
“No,” I muttered quickly, stepping forward.
“Or after he got bored of you?” she added bitterly.
That stung.
Badly.
“It’s not like that,” I said, shaking my head desperately. “It’s not just…”
“Oh my God,” she interrupted, dragging a hand through her hair. “I can’t believe this.”
“I’m sorry,” I whispered.
“Stop saying sorry!” she snapped. “Sorry doesn’t fix this! It won’t fix anything!”
“I know it doesn’t…” I said, trying to explain, but she cut me off.
“Then why did you do it?”
Her voice cracked. And that hurt more than anything because I could feel the pain beneath that anger.
It was what I had been avoiding all along, the reason I didn’t tell her. Because I knew exactly how it felt to be betrayed by people you trusted the most. I knew that pain too well, and it was why I also knew that Diana would never forgive me.
I couldn’t even forgive my own father for selling me off to a man like Mr Hudson, so how could I expect her to?
Tears pooled in my eyes, but I refused to let them fall. It would only make me look more shameless and pathetic than I already felt, just like asking for her forgiveness would.
“I swear I wasn’t planning for this to happen….”
“Yet you did it anyway!” She bellowed.
“I’m sorry,” I muttered apologetically, knowing nothing I said would appease her anger. I tried anyway. “I swear, Diana, I tried to stay away, I tried to ignore it, but…”
“But what?” she demanded. “He’s my father!”