Chapter 101: Broken Trust II

NANCY’S POV

"...Oh my God.” I had to clamp a hand over my mouth to keep from crying out loud, as my body trembled with the shock of what I had just found out.

“Nancy..." Nathan called out anxiously. He grabbed my hand but I yanked it back and shoved him hard.

“How long?” I demanded. “How long have you known?!”

He paused, looking conflicted. “It’s complicated..."

I stared at him with my jaw wide open. There were so many excuses he could think off. Heck, I even hoped he would lie to me and tell me it wasn't true but that was all he had to say?

“No, it’s not!” I snapped. “It’s a yes or no question!”

I was fuming. I stared at him unblinkingly, waiting for his response. He hesitated, and then his head dropped.

"Yes."

The word shattered something inside me. I staggered back a few steps, and my body swayed with the wind.

My gaze didn't leave Nathan, and as I watched him, tears pooled in my eyes.

Here was the one person I trusted with my life, the one person I believed would never lie to me or betray my trust.

When Nathan left New Jersey, it shattered me. I thought I'd lost the only thing that mattered to me and after finding him in Florida, after realizing he had intentionally left without looking back, I didn't blame him.

Because I knew he wouldn't have if he had a choice. I knew he wouldn't have left me behind with our shitty father if he could help it and that was why this hurt ten times as much as Mr Landon's betrayal of my trust.

It was as if someone had taken my heart and shattered it into a million pieces.

The air suddenly felt too tight and I found that I couldn't breathe.

I felt suffocated and all I could manage to choke out was, "You lied to me."

Nathan's gaze lifted and a flicker of panic crossed his face. "I was trying to protect you."

"From what?" I yelled. "The truth?!"

“From this." he gestured around us. “From everything that’s happening right now."

“Well, great job!” I laughed bitterly. “Because I’m right in the middle of it anyway!”

“Nancy..."

“Don’t,” I said, stepping back quickly. “Just...don’t.”

My chest rose and fell rapidly. Everything felt like too much, it was all happening too fast.

"

“No...let go of me!”

My voice echoed sharply as Nathan dragged me out of the villa, his grip firm but not rough.

“I’m not trying to hurt you, I just want you to calm down," he said.

“Don’t fucking tell me to calm down!” I snapped, trying to yank my arm free. “You don’t get to decide how I feel right now, not after lying to me!"

“I’m not deciding anything,” he shot back. “I’m reacting to the fact that you just walked straight into danger and somehow made it back alive.”

“That’s not my fault!”

“It becomes your fault when you ignore warnings, Nancy!”

I froze for a split second, then a bitter laugh wrenched out of me. Just because of someone's order, my own brother could treat me like this.

The truth was right before me, even though I refused to believe it.

“Warnings?” I turned to face him fully now. “Is that what we’re calling it? Because from where I’m standing, it looks a lot like secrets and lies.”

Nathan exhaled sharply, running a hand over his face.

“This is exactly what I was trying to avoid.”

“Well congratulations,” I said flatly. “You failed.”

His jaw tightened, but he didn’t argue. I steady, he began to lead me towards the car that was parked a couple of feet away, the one Mr Landon had used to bring us here.

“Get in.”

“No.” I clenched my jaw stubbornly, refusing to comply.

“Nancy..." Nathan exhaled.

“I said no!” I snapped. “I’m not moving another inch until someone actually explains what the hell is going on!”

Nathan looked at me for a long second.

Not angry, he wasn't annoyed either, he just looked tired.

“Things are far more complicated than you understand."

The words hit something deep in my chest.

Something that had already been bruised too many times tonight.

“Oh my God,” I breathed out, shaking my head. “There it is again.”

“What?”

“That tone,” I said, pointing at him. “That exact tone. Like I’m some clueless kid who wandered into a situation she can’t possibly understand.”

“That’s not what I’m saying..."

“That’s exactly what you’re saying!” I cut in. “You think I can’t handle it, so you just… what? Keep everything from me? Decide what I should and shouldn’t know?”

“I’m trying to protect you!”

“By lying to me?!”

“I didn’t lie!”

“You withheld the truth!” I shot back. “Which, last I checked, is just lying with extra steps!”

Nathan’s patience cracked slightly.

“You think this is simple?” he asked, his voice rising. “You think we can just sit down and explain everything like it’s some kind of story?”

“Yes!” I snapped. “Because it is my life!”

He went quiet. And for a moment, I thought maybe, just maybe...He would finally tell me something.

But then, he shook his head.

“You don’t understand the kind of world you’ve stepped into.”

“Then make me understand!” I demanded.

“I can’t.”

“Why not?!”

“Because knowing more puts you in more danger!”

I stared at him, then shook my head. "I was already in danger tonight.”

Soon as I said that, I yanked the car door open and got in, slamming it hard behind me.

They had both done what they wanted, keeping me in the dark about everything, saying it was all to protect me but all that protection had ended up doing was hurting me instead.

Now, I was left standing in the middle of a chaotic situation, picking up the broken pieces of my shattered heart in the process.

I sat in the car, breathing heavily and genuinely, I wondered if I would ever heal from this hurt.

It didn't seem like I would. Not now, not ever.