Chapter 15: OH SHIT

I was pretty shocked when Tobias picked me. It felt like a drunken choice, though, because I had always thought Tobias and Pearl were a thing. But now it seemed like they were this toxic, on-and-off couple that did things to spite each other. I glanced at Pearl, and either she was a really good pretender, or my assumptions were wrong.

I was drunk too, and this was the first time in my whole twenty-five years of living that I had been picked to play Truth or Dare—or, in this case, Drink or Dare. Aside from the minor rush pumping through my head, I couldn't help but think how great it would be to kiss Tobias in front of Aiden. Not that it would matter to him anyway. Anika was right there, throwing herself at him, and she was hot. I didn’t think I ran circles in his mind the way he did in mine.

“So, Cheryl—are you going to drink or—” Tobias’s voice drifted into my head, pulling me out of my drunken thoughts. I offered him a lopsided smile.

“I’ll do it. I don’t want to be a prude,” I said, side-eyeing Anika.

“But you’re clearly drunk,” Aiden cut in, his voice sharp.

“So? Isn’t that the whole point?” I shot back with a shrug and a chuckle.

Aiden shrugged too, though his expression was rigid. It might’ve been the liquor, but he had every reason to be a little tense tonight. I ignored him and watched Tobias scoot closer to me. His fingers brushed mine on the floor, and I looked into his eyes. His lips had barely brushed mine when someone yanked me away—it was Aiden.

“She’s clearly drunk, man,” Aiden said loudly. “And you know the rules—we don’t kiss drunk girls.”

“What rules?” Mickey’s confused voice came from the side.

“I don’t mind,” I slurred, determined to stay on my quest to be a bad girl.

“No one asked you,” Aiden snapped, ignoring Mickey entirely. Then he turned to me. “And you—don’t you think you’re a little too wasted to be kissing random guys?”

I stared at him with a confused, drunken look. Why did he care? I wasn’t kissing him—not that I didn’t want to. God, I needed to stop thinking about his stupidly perfect lips and focus.

“It’s Tobias,” I said, as if that explained everything.

“You’ve known him for, like, two minutes, and suddenly it’s ‘Tobias’?”

“Dude, we practically went to the same high school,” Tobias interjected.

“Oh, I must’ve missed when you two were so tight,” Aiden shot back before grabbing my hand and pulling me to my feet. “I’m taking you home before you do something you’ll regret by morning. And Tobias, I’m borrowing your car.”

“Is the game over? I didn’t even kiss anyone yet,” Pearl’s voice followed us as Aiden pulled me out of the room.

The sky was still darkening by the time we got outside, but a thousand stars littered the sky. The full moon cast a soft silver hue on Aiden’s face as we walked to the car.

The ride home was silent. Aiden’s eyes stayed focused on the road, not sparing me a glance, while I sat there, scared to open my mouth. I was too wasted to trust myself not to say something stupid. But the thing about being drunk is that your head feels free, and everything seems like the right thing to do, even when it’s the worst idea in the world.

“You didn’t have to do that,” I blurted out once we reached the house but hadn’t gotten out of the car yet.

“Do what?”

“You know, try to play savior. What if I wanted to kiss Tobias?”

“Did you want to kiss Tobias?” he countered.

“I mean, I was up for being wild and all. You’re supposed to encourage all the bad decisions I didn’t get to make as a teenager—which is partly your fault, by the way. Instead, you’re just being a cockblocker.”

“A cockblocker?” His face was stamped with disbelief.

“Yes, Aiden. Exactly what I said.”

He scoffed. “You’re not his type anyway. He likes them bigger at the back—and the front.”

I scoffed right back. “What! No! I just wanted to kiss him, not sleep with him. And he’s not even my type. I like them with a little less salt and pepper in the hair and beard.”

With that, I got out of the car and slammed the door angrily before storming into the house. Aiden was fast on my heels.

“What are you so angry about? Sorry for trying to help you make better decisions.”

“No one asked you to do that, Aiden! I’ve never played Truth or Dare in my life. I never got invited to parties in high school or college because Marty convinced me they were evil.” I stopped, not wanting to get into that debacle about Marty. “I finally get the chance to kiss someone in a Truth or Dare game, not just hear about it from the girls in the dorms, and also prove to Anika that I’m not a prude.”

My voice rose as I vented. By the time I finished, I was out of breath, my chest heaving as I stared at Aiden’s unreadable face.

“But you know what? It’s fine. You’d never understand, and I don’t expect you to. Goodnight, Aiden.”

I turned to leave, but before I could take a step, Aiden’s hands snaked around my waist, spinning me to face him.

“I just dared myself to kiss you, and I think I’m going to do it.”

I didn’t get a chance to respond before his lips smashed into mine, taking me by surprise. The kiss shattered my resolve, turning me into something mushy in his arms. His lips tasted like liquor, sweet and sour at the same time, and I was willing to devour them.

The kiss started slow and soft, and just when I thought it would deepen, my 4 a.m. alarm rang out. I pulled away in shock, rushing to turn it off. That’s when I noticed a thousand missed calls from Damon Bass—and realized I never sent that text to cancel on him.

“Oh shit!”