Chapter 46

She furiously threw another stone into the water, the urge to scream out loud was still fighting to spew out of her. She curled her hands into a fist as she walked back and forth.

Why was she angry?

It was obviously because of Ethan. Who else would she literally be upset about? Not Hunter, that’s for sure. He was her least problems now. He wasn’t even a problem at the beginning. And the last time she saw him was when she ran into him at the gates while he was waiting for her father. It was as if telling her the truth about him made him want to ghost her now that she always wanted to run into him.

Maybe this was one of the things she could consider Hunter a problem—she wanted to see him, if not every day but eight times a week. If that’s even possible.

She kicked a rock and it went right into the water.

“Quit throwing things in there, you’re making the clear water not so clear anymore.”

Elise rolled her eyes before she even turned to see the owner of the voice. “Why are you here?” She asked.

Kayla shoulder-shrugged and handed her the phone. “Because Max wants to speak to you,” she told her and Elise briskly glanced at her. She hesitantly collected the phone from Kayla and placed it on her ear.

There were so many reasons she didn’t want to talk to him now. He was going to ask her how things were and she can’t lie to him because he is Max and he can read through her even when he’s not there. Her voice always gives her away.

Her second reason was if she tells him the truth, he was going to give her the I told you so lecture and how he was right about everything.

“Hey,” she mouthed and blows out a trembling breath.

“Elise… I’ve been calling for the past two days but Kayla told me you didn’t want to talk to me.” Elise glanced over at Kayla and glared at her. Kayla knew what that meant. She shrugs it off like it was nothing. “She literally told you that I didn’t want to talk to you?”

Kayla waved her off and hurriedly walked out of the cave. She shakes her head as she heaved a sigh of frustration. She sometimes finds it annoying how Kayla could be literal sometimes. She told her she didn’t want to speak with Max—she didn’t literally tell her to say that to him but Kayla being herself, she told him the truth.

“Yes, I was avoiding you. Because you were right about everything,” she said it as though she didn’t want to admit. Of course, she didn’t want to tell him how he was right about everything and she should stop being stubborn about everything he tells her to do.

“What happened?” he asked worriedly. His voice lowered like he didn’t want to let the next person hear him say that. It was the weekend and he was at home—alone.

“It’s Ethan…” her voice falters when she mentioned the name. It’s been literally three days since she last called that name out loud. It’s been four days since she last saw his face. “He was supposed to join us for dinner three days ago to meet my parents, but he… he didn’t show up.” Her voice cracked and she was already on the verge to tear up. She hates talking about her situation because she always ends up crying.

“That son of a btch…” Max said faintly. The anger was already rising within him. “What an asshole.”

Elise’s shoulders slumped, as if Max was there in front of her. She massaged her temple with her free hand—she hates the ache she feels whenever she wanted to fight her tears from falling.

“You were right… about everything. About him and about trusting him,” she mumbled, her voice trembling.

“No, no don’t cry because of that jerk. You have had enough and you have been through enough,” he affirmed and it made her to chuckle as she raised her head, and blink back the tears.

“You’re right. You’re right. I’ve had enough. He is not worth my tears.” She kept repeating that to herself.

“Yes, he is not worth it. And you are going to be fine without him…”

“NO! No, I won’t…” A great sob escaped her lips as her knees buckled, meeting the hard rock. “I want to let go, I want to. I just… I can’t…”

“It is not going to be easy. The first heartbreak is always the worst but you have to stop searching for why at some point and let it go…” He knew Elise to be the most stubborn person when it comes to something she wanted. And Ethan being her first love, it would be difficult to rip her off him. Not with the way she’s so obsessed with him even after the countless times he has messed up.

“He may still love you. He probably does. He probably doesn’t know what he wants. He probably still thinks about you all the time. But that isn’t what matters. What matters is what he’s doing about it is nothing. And if he’s doing nothing, you most certainly shouldn’t do anything also. You need someone who goes out of their way to make it obvious that they want you in their life,” Max spoke wisely. He hopes she’d consider his words and actually use it.

She nods her head, wiping the tears away as though he was there. The agony was still there—an ache covered her chest as if she was in surreal hell. “I just sometimes feel like it’s too early to give up after what we’ve been through. Maybe something is bothering him and it’s the reason that’s pushing him away from me. Maybe if I try harder,” she said, out of hope. She believes that she’s made to love him. It’s the only explanation for something that comes so naturally to her, and it doesn’t matter if he’s avoiding her or hiding from her—in the chaos or in the calm, he still feels like home to her.

She hears him sigh tiredly. It was obvious he was tired of trying to convince her but she routinely gives another reason not to be convinced.

“Look, Elise, sometimes you have to be strong for yourself. You have to know that you’re a good person and a good friend. What’s meant to be will end up good and what isn’t, wont. Relationships are worth fighting for, but sometimes you can’t be the only one fighting. At times, people need to fight for you. If they don’t, you must just move on and realize great things when they come around and don’t lose something real. But if you still feel like you want to fight for him after what he has put you through, you should, Elise. This choice is up to you not me or your father or anyone.”

She took in a short breath and exhaled. She closed her eyes, letting his words sip in. As much as she didn’t want to admit, Max was right. But when he said it was her choice, she still feels like she has to fight a little harder and push it on.

If she runs to him again and he doesn’t at least walk back to her—she might give up for good.

She had pounced over the thought of calling it off and also thought of giving him another trying for so many times that she was jumbled—even after speaking to Max now. Maybe was getting ahead of herself and needs to relax a bit.

They ended the call after that and Elise was back to her usual—thoughts of Ethan and how she’d make things work.

She breathes out air from her mouth and tried not to cry again. It’s now a part of her—crying all the time for the slightest thought of him. If he wasn’t the one, she couldn’t be crying this much. She wouldn’t be worried about him and their relationship this much.

When she turned around, her heart jumps into her throat when she sees him standing a few feet in front of her. “Oh God, you scared me.” She placed a hand on her chest to stop it from escaping its place.