Chapter 16: CHAPTER SIXTEEN

BRIELLE

The problem with dinners like that?

They never really end at the dinner table.

Not when someone like Freya Sorrentino is involved.

I made it exactly twenty minutes after dessert—an overpriced crème brûlée I was too tense to enjoy—before I excused myself to the kitchen. Not because I needed anything, really. Just air. A break. Maybe the illusion of peace in a house that smelled like power and roses and far too many centuries of tradition.

The kitchen was massive. More modern than the rest of the mansion, all sleek marble countertops and brushed gold finishes, but it still carried that museum-level stillness. No cooks in sight, just the lingering scent of roasted duck and money.

I leaned against the counter, letting out a breath I hadn’t realized I’d been holding all evening. My heels were digging into my feet. My earrings were heavier than necessary. My face hurt from smiling.

A door creaked behind me, and before I could turn around, I already knew who it was.

“Interesting performance,” Freya’s voice rang out, crisp and amused. “For a girl who doesn’t come from our world, you certainly know how to fake your way through it.”

I turned slowly, keeping my expression neutral. “Is this the part where you tell me to watch my back?”

“Oh no.” She smiled, but it didn’t reach her eyes. Again. “That would imply you’re a threat. This—” she gestured between us with a twirl of her manicured fingers “—this is just a courtesy.”

“Courtesy,” I echoed, crossing my arms.

“Yes. A polite warning, if you will.”

“To get out while I can?”

She laughed lightly, stepping closer. “Oh, Brielle. You’re already in too deep. But I figured I’d at least give you a glimpse of what’s ahead. You may have Damien wrapped around your little finger for now, but that doesn’t mean the rest of us are buying it.”

“Right,” I said, tilting my head. “And what exactly do you think I’m trying to sell?”

She shrugged. “That you belong here. That you’re more than just some passing distraction with a pretty face and a carefully curated sob story.”

I blinked. “A sob story?”

She smiled. “Writers are dramatic by nature. I’m sure you’ve already turned this dinner into a dozen poetic metaphors. Struggling heroine, icy mother-in-law, scheming ex...”

“Scheming?” I cut in. “So you admit you’re the villain in this little fairytale?”

Freya stepped closer, just enough that I could smell the sharp floral perfume that clung to her like armor. “Sweetheart, I’m not the villain. I’m the reality check.”

I let out a breathy laugh. “You know what’s funny? Damien didn’t mention you once. Not in passing. Not in memory. Nothing. So whatever fantasy you’ve built in your head—it’s not mutual.”

Her eyes flared, but only for a second. “He and I go way back. You’re just a detour.”

“Then why are you so pressed?” I asked. “If I’m just a detour, why are you standing here in a five-thousand-dollar dress trying to convince me I’m not worth the road trip?”

She opened her mouth, but I beat her to it.

“Let me guess. Because deep down, you know the truth. That no matter how much old money your family sits on, or how perfectly you play the part—Damien didn’t choose you.”

Freya’s face went still. No anger. No scoff. Just... stillness.

A beat passed.

Then another.

And then—she smiled.

“You think this is about love?” Freya’s voice dropped into something lower, almost tender. Almost. “That boy doesn’t love anyone. Not really. Not fully. He’s fire, Brielle. Beautiful, consuming, and dangerous.”

Her heels clicked forward until the distance between us shrank by half. Her perfume hit me again.

“You’ll burn before you even realize you’re on fire.”

I didn’t reply.

So she continued, circling slowly like she was studying a subject under glass.

“You think you’ve done something special. That just because he didn’t flinch when you talk back, or because he lets you live in the penthouse like a bird in a gilded cage, you’re different.” She gave a light laugh. “Newsflash? You’re not.”

“Pretty confident for someone who spent dinner trying to prove she still matters.”

Her lips twitched. “Oh, sweetheart. I don’t have to prove anything. Especially not to you.”

“Then why are you in the kitchen? Cornering me in a house that doesn’t even belong to you?”

“Because I wanted to see you without Damien playing guard dog. See what’s behind the performance. The messy little writer who somehow stumbled into a life she has no business surviving in.”

I raised an eyebrow. “You’re really invested in someone else’s survival arc.”

“Please.” She scoffed, folding her arms across her chest.

“I think you need to get better material,” I said coolly. “Because this ‘bitter ex with a blowout and a trust fund’ thing? It’s been done. Repeatedly.”

Her smile tightened. “You’re so sure of yourself.”

“No,” I said, voice low. “I’m sure of him.”

That flicker in her eyes again. She hated that.

“You know what scares you?” I asked, tilting my head. “It’s not that I don’t belong. It’s that I do. That despite everything—your history, your family, your head start—he still didn’t choose you.”

Silence.

The air between us froze, thick and unmoving.

Her jaw clenched, just slightly.

And then she blinked, slow and deliberate, as if wiping the emotion off her face like makeup before a gala.

“Cute,” she murmured. “But naïve.”

She stepped back, brushing invisible lint off her sleeve.

“You must be really dumb if you think this is about hearts and flowers and getting picked?” she continued. “Damien doesn’t fall in love, Brielle. He collects storms. He dances on the edge of chaos until it swallows the people around him. He’ll admire your spark until it threatens his flame and then he’ll smother you.”

I held her gaze. “And yet you still want him.”

Her mask slipped for the briefest moment.

“Loyalty is a rare thing in our world,” she said instead. “But so is realism. Enjoy your illusion while it lasts.”

She turned, slowly, ready to leave, but paused at the threshold of the doorway, the light from the hallway catching on the edge of her diamond earring like a camera flash.

“Oh,” she added, glancing back. “And just between us girls? That dress you wore tonight? Damien’s mother picked it. Told the stylist it needed to be less Brielle and more tolerable. You were wearing Claire Moretti’s approval like a costume. Don’t get too comfortable in it.”

Then she was gone.

After a few more minutes of standing alone in that glittering kitchen—gold fixtures, marble countertops, and words I wished I hadn’t let burrow so deep—I made my way back to the main hallway. My smile was back on by the time I rejoined Damien, but I didn’t need a mirror to know it didn’t reach my eyes.

Damien hit me with a  “Ready to get out of here?”

I nodded, and that was all it took.

Despite his mother’s pointed insistence that we spend the night, Damien declined with effortless charm. A few polite nods, a cool smile, and somehow we were in his sleek black car, driving away from the mansion and every heavy gaze still lingering behind.

The moment we were alone, I let my shoulders drop an inch.

The engine purred quietly beneath us. Outside the window, the Hamptons blurred past like a watercolor.  I stared out the window, one hand pressed against my temple, the other clenched uselessly on my lap. Damien drove like he did everything else—smooth, fast, and with an air of superiority I wanted to shove into the glove compartment.

Neither of us said a word for the first ten minutes.

“You’ve been quiet,” Damien said finally, not looking at me.

I didn’t answer.

He shot me a glance. “Brielle.”

“What?” I snapped, louder than I meant to. “I’m not allowed to be quiet now?”

“Did I say that?”

“No, but you’re thinking it.”

He exhaled, sharp and impatient. “Christ. You’re exhausting.”

“Then maybe you shouldn’t drag me to your family’s haunted castle of judgment next time.”

“They were being civil.”

“Civil?” I let out a dry laugh. “Is that what you call your mother glaring at me like I crawled out of a sewer and Freya cornering me like a mean girl in a high school locker room?”

Damien’s knuckles flexed on the steering wheel. “Freya cornered you?”

I shook my head, leaning back into the seat. “Forget it.”

“No.” His tone shifted—less bored CEO, more sharp edge. “What did she say?”

I stared ahead. Silence.

“Brielle.”

“She said—” I broke off, then turned to him sharply. “She said the dress I wore tonight wasn’t even mine. That your mother picked it. Told the stylist it had to be ‘less Brielle and more tolerable.’”

Damien blinked.

“What?”

His confusion was real enough to sting.

I folded my arms. “So it’s true, then?”

“No,” he said immediately. “That’s not—Freya told you that? It’s a lie. All of it. My mother didn’t pick the dress. You know how Claire operates—if she wanted something, she’d say it to my face, not whisper it to a stylist. And as for Freya?”

He exhaled sharply, shaking his head. “Freya’s all bark and ego. She’s a master of deflection. If she couldn’t win me, she’ll try to chip away at you. She aimed for the weak spot. That’s what Freya does. But she’s wrong about you.”

I looked out the window. “Maybe I shouldn’t have come tonight.”

“No,” he said. “I shouldn’t have brought you. That’s on me.”

“Damien—”

“I mean it.” His voice was low but unwavering. “I knew it would be uncomfortable. I told myself you could handle it and you did, brilliantly, but that’s not the point. You shouldn’t have to handle it.”

My throat tightened.

He leaned in slightly. “I’m sorry for tonight, Brielle. I won’t ever put you in a position like that again.”

I nodded slowly, blinking back the sting behind my eyes.

“Thank you

We didn’t talk for the rest of the ride. Not about Freya. Not about the dress. Not about how sharp everything felt inside that house, like every smile was cut from glass.

And when we finally reached the penthouse, I got out first. Didn’t wait for him. Didn’t glance back.

Because no matter how many rooms I walked through in heels and forced smiles…

I was still the outsider.