Chapter 7: Tutoring Session
Being early was responsible.
It also gave me time to sit alone in the study room and pretend I wasn’t here.
One sentence had been replaying in my head since yesterday like a threat with excellent timing.
“You shouldn’t be walking alone anymore.”
The room was too quiet for that kind of line. Square table. Tall shelves.
Afternoon light cutting across polished wood like even the sunlight at Fletcher had standards.
I set down my bag, pulled out my notes, and stared at the same page long enough to qualify as concerned.
This was tutoring. That was all.
Not a continuation of yesterday’s hallway disaster. Not a private sequel to Isaac Fletcher saying something alarming and then walking away like I was supposed to decode it for homework.
Maybe he meant Farrah. Maybe he meant the rumors.
Maybe he meant Fletcher in general, which honestly felt less like a school and more like a beautifully landscaped warning label.
Or maybe—and this was the option I refused to examine too closely—he meant himself.
I checked the clock.
Two minutes early. Stable. Academics. Fine.
The silence in the room pressed in weirdly, making every little sound feel suspicious.
My pen tapping. Paper shifting. My own breathing.
Study rooms at Fletcher were apparently designed to support learning and emotional collapse in equal measure.
I straightened in my chair and looked down at my notebook.
This was tutoring just tutoring.
The door opened. I looked up too fast.
Isaac stepped inside exactly on time, closed the door behind him, and stopped.
No greeting. No apology. No normal human signal that this was a normal human interaction.
He just stood there, watching me.
He wore his uniform like rules had been suggested, not enforced. Sleeves pushed back slightly. Tie loose. Dark hair falling over his forehead in that deeply unnecessary way that made me want to file a complaint with genetics.
His gaze moved over the table, the books, my notes, then back to me.
“Did you plan on saying something,” I asked, “or were you going to stand there and be unsettling for free?”
“I’m here, aren’t I?”
“That is not a greeting.”
“It seemed unnecessary.”
Of course it did.
He crossed the room and sat across from me, and the air changed in that quiet way it always seemed to around him. Just enough to make my spine go rigid.
I turned one of the pages toward him.
“We’re starting with yesterday’s material because your notes were basically an act of violence.”
His eyes dropped to the page. “You looked at my notes?”
“I had to. We’re doing the same project, and I needed to confirm whether you were actually enrolled here.”
That got the smallest shift in his mouth. I ignored it and kept going.
“If you miss the foundation, the rest of the argument falls apart. So this section matters.”
I started explaining the concept, pointing to the structure, the logic, the way each point built on the next. My voice steadied the way it always did when I was talking about something I understood.
This part made sense. Facts behaved. Academic things stayed where you put them.
People did not. A few seconds in, I realized Isaac was looking at me, not the notes.
I kept talking anyway. Maybe I was imagining it.
I shifted the paper. “This is the part your professor is going to care about most.”
Silence. I looked up.
He was still watching me with the kind of focus that was somehow worse than distraction.
I narrowed my eyes. “Are you even paying attention?”
“I am.” I set my pen down.
“To what?” His gaze held mine.
“You.” That was actively unhelpful.
My brain went blank for one humiliating second while my pulse did something reckless against my ribs. I stared at him.
“That is not a subject.”
“It is right now.” Absolutely not.
I leaned back a little, because suddenly the distance between us felt academically unsafe.
“You do realize the point of tutoring is that you learn something.”
“Maybe I am.”
That landed worse than it should have. Because he didn’t sound playful.
He sounded certain. Calm. Like he wasn’t teasing me for fun. Like he was observing something and already deciding what to do with it.
Like the lesson had never really been the point.
And the worst part was, some traitorous part of me had already known that.
He reached for the paper at the same time I did.
Our fingers brushed. It was barely a touch. Nothing, technically.
Just skin against skin for half a second.
Which was apparently enough to make my entire body react like I’d been electrocuted by academic misconduct.
I pulled my hand back first.
“This part,” I said, a little too quickly, tapping the paragraph with my pen, “is where your argument gets weak.”
Isaac glanced down at the page, then back at me. “Weak?”
“Yes,” I said. “Painfully.”
One eyebrow lifted. I should have backed off. Chosen survival. Preserved my dignity.
Instead, I kept going, because if he was going to sit there acting like the laws of concentration did not apply to him, then I was going to win on the one field I actually understood.
“You keep making statements without supporting them,” I said. “That only works if people are already willing to believe you.”
“And if they are?”
“Then they’re lazy.”
That almost-smile appeared again. Small. Brief. Worse than a full one, honestly.
I leaned forward and slid the paper closer to him. “Read that line again. Properly this time.”
For once, he looked at the page.
Good. I took that tiny victory and held onto it with both hands.
“I’m not afraid of failing you, by the way,” I added before I could stop myself. “If you submit bad work, I’m not attaching my name to it just because you’re Isaac Fletcher.”
Silence. Then his eyes lifted to mine, slower this time. The room felt smaller.
“That so?” he asked quietly.
“Yes.” It came out steadier than I felt, which I considered a personal achievement.
For a second, neither of us moved.
Then he stood. My breath caught.
He came around the side of the table, unhurried, like he had all the time in the world and fully intended to use it against me.
He stopped beside my chair, close enough that I had to tilt my head back to look at him.
This was not an appropriate academic distance. I gripped my pen harder.
“What are you doing?” His gaze dropped to my hand, then to my face.
“Deciding,” he said. That did not help.
It also did terrible things to my ability to think in complete sentences.
He leaned down slightly, one hand resting on the table beside me, close enough now that I could feel the shift in the air, the heat of him, the deliberate stillness.
“Maybe you’re not afraid of me,” he said softly.
My pulse stumbled.
Then his eyes held mine and his voice dropped lower.
“But you should be.”