Chapter 117: Chapter Ninety-Four
Vivienne & Emeline
It was always easier when no one else believed us.
When it was just the two of us against the silence, we could convince ourselves we were imagining it—that Edward lived only in our guilt, our dreams, our unfinished sentences. But tonight, when Marlowe’s face shifted, when the certainty drained from his eyes, we knew: he heard it too.
The scratch.
The pencil on the wall.
The sound Edward used to make late at night when the house was asleep, when sketches bloomed from his hand as though they had a will of their own. It is unbearable and intimate, that sound. Like hearing a ghost breathe.
Emeline clutched my arm. Her nails pressed crescents into my skin. “He’s here,” she whispered, as though Marlowe weren’t standing only feet away. Her voice trembled with something too sharp to be fear—hunger, almost. A hunger to be seen, to be proved right.
“No,” I said, though the denial tasted brittle in my mouth. “He isn’t here. It’s the building. Old wood, shifting air.”
“You don’t believe that.”
And I didn’t. God forgive me, I didn’t.
We drifted back toward the wall, the one where the sound had stopped. The plaster was smooth under my fingers, cool, but not lifeless. It felt—alive, somehow, as though beneath it something pulsed. I half expected the pencil to push through, the graphite to pierce the surface and leave Edward’s lines across my skin.
“Sometimes I think he’s waiting,” Emeline whispered. “Not to punish us. Not even to haunt us. Just to finish what he started.”
The words lodged deep in me, like a thorn.
Because what if she was right? What if this wasn’t haunting, wasn’t madness—but continuation? Edward’s hand, still drawing. His will, still pressing forward, refusing the grave.
Behind us, Marlowe shifted, heavy boots against the marble. The sound of a man who wanted to interrupt but couldn’t find the language. He had heard what we heard. He had joined us in the liminal space.
And now we were no longer two women unraveling. We were three.