Chapter 75: 52| Lost

┏━━━✦❘༻༺❘✦━━━┓ Lost ┗━━━✦❘༻༺❘✦━━━┛ Chapter 52: Lost (Tristan's POV) The silence between us the entire way home was worse than any torture. It felt like Amara didn't want to spend a moment longer near me, let alone speak to me or look me in the eye. It felt like I couldn't talk to her, no matter how desperately I wanted to. Everything unraveled so quickly that our conversation turned into a volatile argument. We were communicating, but we weren't listening to each other, we weren't understanding each other. I truly didn't know how to face her. She was rightfully upset. I did something knowing it would put her life in danger, and even though my intentions were right, I went about it the wrong way. I couldn't even bring myself to tell her because I knew what she would say, that it wasn't worth the risk I took. I turned my phone on, knowing it would probably lead Michael to us, but I had never felt so helpless before in my life. The two of us being alone could have been safe had I not turned my phone on, it was possible that Michael would never have found us if I hadn't, but the risks outweighed the safety measures we took. I had no choice but to call for help. I didn't want her to be any more upset than she already was, so I kept my mouth shut, waiting for the right time. We landed in New York, but that time never came. We sat in the same silence in the car as I drove her to her father's, and still, the time never came. I felt like a complete fucking fool for not being able to talk to her. She seemed so fragile at the moment. One word from me, and I thought she would break, and there was nothing in this world I hated more than seeing her cry. "You should go home," Amara finally said as I opened the trunk and brought out her suitcase. "Let me take you upstairs," I suggested. "I can go on my own." "I know, but I don't want you to," I replied, keeping a firm grip on her bag. She held my gaze, her jaw ticking. Exhaling softly, I closed the trunk and faced her completely. "Do you want me to leave, Amara?" A small sigh of defeat escaped her. "Tristan, I don't know how to talk to you when you're like this. You won't tell me why you did it, you're not listening to me-" "I am listening to you. I understand you, your concerns are valid. I get why you're mad at me." "I'm not mad at you," she replied softly. "But I need you to help me understand you. How can I not be bothered by what you've done?" "If it bothers you, then it bothers you. I won't tell you how you should or shouldn't feel." She paused, a light scoff escaping her. "You don't think we should talk about it? You don't think we should fix this?" "I think we should take some time apart." After a beat, she shrugged lightly. "Fine." I took the bag out of her grasp before she could drag it behind her. "I'm still taking you upstairs," I told her. Inhaling deeply, she turned away from me and led the way upstairs, ringing her father's doorbell. He answered not even a minute later, his arms wrapping around her almost immediately. "Lascia che ti guardi," he breathed out a sigh of relief, drawing back to look at her. "Stai bene?" 'Let me look at you. Are you okay?' "I'm okay," she said softly, brushing past her father to enter the house without another word or another glance at me. Mr. Milano eyed me for a beat as he took her suitcase from me. "Cos'è successo?" he questioned. 'What happened?' "È arrabbiata con me," I breathed out. 'She's mad at me.' He blinked in surprise. "You speak Italian?" "I'm learning." He paused for a minute, then folded his arms. "What did you do?" I glanced at the ground. "She found out I turned my phone on. She keeps asking why." "Why don't you tell her?" "What should I tell her?" I asked instead, lifting my gaze to it. "It'll only make her more upset." "You did what I told you to," he told me pointedly. "You realize it's not your fault, right? If anything, it's mine. I should tell her." "Please don't, Mr. Milano," I said, shaking my head slightly. "I don't want her to be more upset." He let his arms fall. "She hates not knowing a lot more than she hates hearing the truth, Tristan." "I don't know about that. I should head home. Will you please let me know if she goes to her apartment? I'll come by to see her here if that's okay." He nodded slowly. "That's okay… Are you okay?" he asked after a beat. "I'm okay," I replied, "why wouldn't I be?" Closing his eyes, he shook his head softly. "Don't. Don't act tough. You've been through hell just like she has. You've lost a lot, and you put up a damn good fight when the time came. Don't undermine yourself. If you're not okay, say you're not okay. If you want to cry and scream, then…" He shrugged lightly. "Cry and scream," he said. "If you feel something, just say it." I forced out a small chuckle, "Frankly, Mr. Milano, right now, I'm feeling rather lost. With no family of my own left and Amara slipping through my fingertips, I don't know what to do." Reaching out, he patted my shoulder, giving it a squeeze. "You'll be okay. Amara's here for you, even if it doesn't seem like it right now. Give her time. I'm here for you, son." Thanking him, I bid him goodbye and returned to my car, driving home. For the next few days, I thought I should give Amara the time she needed, and so I waited. Three days later, I called her. She didn't answer. With no other choice, I called Mr. Milano, wondering if it would be a good time for me to go see her, asking if she was even willing to see me. "Now…" There was a slight pause at his end over the phone. "I'm afraid now isn't the right time, son. She's not doing too well. She hardly comes out of the room to eat. Maybe in a few days." So I tried again a few days later, nearly a week had passed. But Amara still wasn't answering my calls, and even her father didn't know what to tell me. Resorting to my last option, I showed up at Mr. Milano's house unannounced one afternoon… only to find out that Amara wasn't home. "She's still staying here," he told me, "but she ran off to work this morning before I could ask her anything." I let out a breath and pulled my phone out of my pocket. "She's avoiding me," I mumbled, dialing her number yet again. She didn't answer that time either. One week of silence between us stretched into another. I started losing track of the days that went by without us talking. I didn't know if I should be angry with her for not taking my calls or angry with myself for the way things had turned out. "She's gone," Dante said, snapping me out of the daze I was in. A sharp clink echoed as his glass piece moved along the chessboard. I lifted my gaze to his. "What?" I asked. "She went to Chicago for the night. Anastasia went for some work and took Amara along in the chopper. I thought I should tell you before you ask her father." I felt his gaze on me as I continued the game, my glass of whiskey sitting untouched on the table. "What are you going to do?" he asked me after a beat. I shook my head slowly, letting out a breath as I ran my thumb along my bottom lip. "I don't know," I mumbled. "Talk to her, Tristan." "I can't exactly talk to her when she won't answer my calls and runs out before I can find her. I've been everywhere. Her father's house, her apartment, even her fucking office. I'm sure she tells her employees to tell me she's not there when she clearly is. Her car was in the parking lot." "Conversations like this aren't easy. You've both been through fucking hell. Why didn't you just tell her?" he exhaled. My jaw ticked as I glanced out the window. "It feels like I've lost her," I said quietly. He scoffed lightly in response. "There is nobody in this world better suited for you two than each other. She's not going anywhere, and neither are you. Just wait for her to get back." With no other choice, I heeded Dante's advice and waited for Amara to come back the next day. Until then, the same thought kept repeating itself in my head. How do I make it up to her? What can I do to fix this? I realized in her absence that perhaps the distance between us was making this seem bigger than it was. Amara was the kindest, smartest, and most warmhearted person I'd ever met. In fact, she was the one who wanted to talk things out, to work on this together at the right time, but I refused and let her down. I wouldn't repeat the same mistake twice. I would make it up to her, no matter what. . . . . . Chapter 52