Chapter 67: 45| Pain-2

A few seconds later, the lock jingled behind the door and it was opened no more than an inch. "Can I help you?" came a man's voice, low and gravely, certainly an elderly person. "Mr. Antonio?" I asked hesitantly. I got no response so I tried again. "Antonio… Moretti?" A startled gasp escaped me as the door slammed shut in our faces and I took a small step back in surprise, staring at the door in disbelief. I turned to Tristan. "Did he just…" A frustrated huff left me before I rang the doorbell again, three times. When no one answered, five more until Tristan took my wrist and held my hand down. "Amara," he whispered quietly in a hiss. "Stop." "He knows who I am!" I argued quietly. "He won't answer!" "Then that's his choice," Tristan said calmly, "we have to respect it. He isn't going to answer if you act like this." I opened my mouth to argue but he beat me to it. "Let me try," he said quickly to appease me. Lifting a hand, he knocked on the door precisely three times. "Mr. Moretti?" he called out. "If you're listening, we would just like to talk! We only have a few questions and promise not to bother you for long! It won't take much time…" he paused and his jaw ticked as he reluctantly yelled out, "Please!" "Mr. Moretti!" I tried. I was desperate at this point. All I wanted was some answers. All these years, that's all I've ever wanted from someone. This was the first and quite possibly the last chance I had of getting any. I wasn't letting it slip away so easily. "Could you please just give us a chance?" I asked, stepping closer to the door. "Just once?" I persisted. "Don't you think I deserve some answers?" I caught Tristan staring at me. "Don't you think they deserve justice?" Tristan's gaze softened. "Mr. Moretti, please, I'm begging you!" Tristan caught my hand. "We should leave, Amara." I freed myself. "I'm not going anywhere without answers, Tristan." "We didn't come here to beg." "I'll beg if I have to," I ground out. I lifted my hand to knock again. "Mr. Moretti-" I cut myself off as the door swung open violently to reveal an old man standing behind it. He held a cane in one hand and evidently had a limp in one leg with his balance tilted to one side. He was dressed in pajamas already with his grays neatly combed back. "Mio Dio. Sei ancora così testardo," he huffed in agitation. 'My God. You're still so stubborn.' I barely had any memories of the man standing before me but he clearly knew who I was. "Ciao," I said hesitantly, "sapete chi sono?" 'Do you know who I am?' A small chuckle poured out of him. "Come potrei dimenticarti…" 'How could I forget you…' "Amara," he breathed out, "you grew up well." "Mr. Moretti," I said hesitantly. His expression returned to its stoic self as he said, "You always called me Antonio." I took in a small breath, not knowing what to say. "Then that's… awfully rude of me, I'm sorry," I mumbled cluelessly. He thought for a few seconds before shaking his head. "I told Mr. Milano not to send you. I told him never to contact me again." "Mr. Moretti, please?" I tried one last time. "This is my last chance. You're the only hope I have left. Please. Please, don't let me down." His eyes finally shifted to Tristan. "Chi è?" he questioned. 'Who is he?' "Il mio…" I paused, "ragazzo." 'My… boyfriend.' Then he suddenly asked, "Fiancé?" "No," I mumbled as Tristan said, "Not yet." I turned to him with a blank look as he offered me a small shrug, picking my hand up in his again. He sighed in defeat, his head dropping forward. After an entire minute of debating with himself, he finally stepped back. "Come in." "Thank you," I exhaled, stepping into the home with Tristan right behind me. A few seconds later, a woman, Mr. Moretti's wife walked into the room, bringing two glasses of water. Pausing in front of me, she smiled and lifted a hand to stroke my hair. "You've grown up to be more beautiful than I ever imagined, Amara," she grinned. "I'm sure you don't remember me," she added with a small, forced chuckle. "I…" I stammered, not knowing what to tell her. "Both of you, please have a seat in the living room," she said, leading the way. We trailed behind, following the couple to the couches where we all settled, the two of them taking the two lounge chairs on either side of the couch. "You have questions," Mr. Moretti stated. It wasn't a question. "Dad said-" I cut myself short, wondering if Mr. Moretti knew that I'd come to call the man he only knew as 'Mr. Milano' Dad. I continued anyway, "He said that you knew. That you saw what happened that night. You saw the fire and you saw who did it. You're the one who called for help, the one who called him… aren't you?" "I am," he admitted. "It was the right thing to do." "Was it him?" Tristan asked. "Was it Michael Ivan?" I stared at him in surprise. I didn't expect Tristan to bring his uncle up this soon, didn't even expect him to be okay with it. Mr. Moretti hesitated to answer the question. "What did he do to you?" Tristan pressed further, stopping when I squeezed his hand. I shook my head lightly. He exhaled softly then said, "Mr. Moretti, you don't have to tell us if you don't-" Mr. Moretti silenced him with the sharp tap of his cane against the floor. "That is what he did to me," he answered, lifting his cane lightly. "What's your name?" he questioned Tristan all of a sudden. "Tristan," he answered. "Tristan what?" "Harper." A ragged breath left Mr. Moretti. "My God. You're his nephew." His wife quickly rose to his feet. "Honey-" "Get out," Mr. Moretti snapped. Tristan remained still for a beat. "You. Just you," Mr. Moretti persisted, "get out of my house." "Mr. Moretti," I said, drawing his attention, "he won't. He won't do what you're suspecting him of." He paused, staring at me. "Out of all people, Amara," he sighed, "you chose-" "I chose him," I confirmed, "because I trust him. Because I love him. Please, trust us." "Believe me," Tristan added, "I despise my uncle more than you believe. I'm here to help." Mrs. Moretti slowly sat back down and gave a small, approving nod to her husband. "What did he do?" Tristan asked softly. "That night," he finally began, "he slipped past the gates. Security didn't see him and he managed to break into the property." Mr. Moretti's eyes lifted to mine. "I had already left to come home and I was off-duty by then. But I realized I had left my house keys in the car, so I went back to get them." His gaze shifted to Tristan. "That's when I caught your uncle. He was breaking into the house." Tristan's eyes dropped to the ground as his head fell forward while he rested his elbows on his knees. For the first time since I told Tristan the truth, he seemed… ashamed. Hearing Mr. Moretti, what we dreaded was confirmed. It really was Michael. "Your father," he said to me, "knew. He heard Michael at some point. He was terrified before the trip that something would go wrong. He was terrified Michael would follow your family and hurt you and your mother. That was exactly what happened and he couldn't do anything about it but he really did try, Amara. He put up a fight." My jaw ticked as I ground my teeth, tears burning in my eyes. "Your father answered the door before Michael made it inside. Michael was armed but your father wasn't. They argued for a long time at the door before Michael barged in. He forced your father back at… gunpoint. I rushed to the door but it was locked. I was trying to unlock the windows when things began escalating. "Your mother came downstairs. She shouldn't have. She should have grabbed you and ran any way she could have. Your father yelled at her to get out but she refused to leave him there, alone. She stayed with him, fighting for him." My head fell forward as a shaky breath shuddered through me, Tristan's hand tightening around mine. "Suddenly, he…" Mr. Moretti hesitated, "he shot your mother. She was trying to intervene and he lost it. He was maniacal, pulling the trigger blindly at everything in front of him. Your father was shot in the leg but your mother… The bullet went through her heart. She was bleeding out quickly and your father began to panic. He ran to her but Michael wouldn't let him. He shot him in the back." The tears fell freely from my eyes at that point. "They were both alive. Bleeding heavily but alive. He didn't have any more bullets, all he had was a flask in his pocket. He was drunk and stumbling around the living room for several minutes. He wasn't panicking, he was… laughing, showing the monster he truly is." Mr. Moretti paused to take a breath and brace himself, sighing as if recalling the memory caused him physical pain. "He poured out the alcohol. All around the house and over your parents, over their wounds. They must have screamed, I couldn't hear everything very well. He had a lighter and lighting it up, he tossed it on the carpet. It caught up in flames immediately and he ran out the back. I realized security had been shot before I got there. I kept trying to get through the window but the fire got too big and burned… everything. I could hear their screams then and they still haunt me today." Just like they haunt me. "I called Mr. Milano, I called the police, the fire department, everyone but perhaps I should have called them sooner. A few days later, I was coming back from work, after dropping you and Mr. Milano at his residence in the city when I got attacked. A few hired men jumped me and beat me up to the point of unconsciousness. I woke up in… some sort of an abandoned place. Michael was there. I was- I was tortured there," he said, breathing shakily, "for several hours. My leg was shattered and shot. "And then he just left me there, warning me to keep my mouth shut if I even survived. I was very lucky that two men found me and called for help but if I hadn't been found that night, I wouldn't be here today." I wiped my face and lifted my gaze to meet his. "I'm very sorry," I whispered softly, "I'm sorry that happened to you." He let out a small exhale and shook his head slowly. "I'm sorry, Amara," he said, "I'm sorry I couldn't help them. I'm sorry I couldn't save you." All this pain, everything that I lost was all because of one man, because of one wretched monster: Michael Ivan. And I decided then and there if I hadn't already known it; I would fucking kill him. . . . . . Chapter 45