Chapter 16: CHAPTER SIXTEEN

ANTHONY’S POV

Nothing was okay!

My life was no longer mine. It was being highjacked by incessant thoughts of someone that was, in a sense, forbidden.

I had never had an earworm mess with my thinking abilities the way this forbidden attraction towards Blake had done so. I was constantly thinking of him – in the shower, at night while I was sleeping, when he was with Crystal having lunch, even while Mr. Cornell droned on about the American Civil War!

Today was just like every other torturous day in the universe where Blake and I existed in the same plane. We were having lunch in the cafeteria like we usually did, Dante telling a nasty joke, Luke’s face a permanent scowl, Blake looking like the sun god, while my very humble self tried not to drool over him, when something happened that reminded me of why Blake and I weren’t friends for three years.

Just like on the basketball court during practice when those two videos of Blake making out with my sister and I were released at once with everyone receiving the notification at the same time, the same thing occurred here. Only, Blake was the first to receive the video this time around, and I, being by his side, had watched it with him.

I was silent for a long time, the thing I dreaded the most finally looking at me straight in the face. Blake’s face turned to ash, and he looked sick. He was about to open his mouth, probably to deny all allegations, when the pings of the notification bars on other students’ phone began to echo through the densely packed hall. It didn’t take a soothsayer, especially by the audio of the video, to know that it was the same one Blake received.

“Damn, Lindell. I didn’t know you were such a player. How did you manage to get two hot girls to sleep with you without the other getting jealous?” All four of us on our table whipped our heads to the booming voice of someone at the edge of the hall. We couldn’t see their face, but their words started the loudest chatter-banter I have ever had to experience in a high school cafeteria.

“Anthony…” Blake started to say, but I cut him off. I didn’t want to listen to his lies. I already knew he was going to cook something up to deny it, just like he did three years ago, and my silly brain would believe him just because it was obsessed and pathetic. I was trying to find proof before, but now that I had what I wanted, I couldn’t even bear to look at it.

As if I was the one being cheated on, I gathered my things and left the table, the sound of Blake’s call to me being drowned by the praises and condemnation by the others. I was Crystal’s big brother, and by some law governing younger sister protection by their older brothers, I was supposed to get mad at Blake and land him a punch or two, beat the shit out of him until he learned not to mess with my or any one else’s younger sister, but I was so hurt by it, probably even more than the person being cheated on, that I couldn’t do anything that warranted me to face Blake without crying. I know, pathetic.

He managed to catch up to me in the empty hallway and grabbed my hand when calling my name didn’t seem to stop me. Angrily, I shrugged him off, finally stopping long enough to glare at him.

“The hell was that video, Lindell?” I spat. In all honesty, I was angrier at myself. I should have been the one to uncover that truth, not some random person who thought the best way to go about it was posting it on the school’s forum for all to see and my sister to get embarrassed.

“I swear to you, it’s not what it looks like.” I couldn’t help but scoff. His denial wasn’t even that solid. I thought he was going to say more but he didn’t, and it was only after I had stared at him long enough did I realize he wasn’t even looking at me – he was looking ahead of me.

“Crys…” The pronunciation of her full name died in his throat when he saw the pained look in her eyes. She had cried, or at least tried to not cry, and the evidence was all around her eyes.

“Please tell me it isn’t true,” she said, her voice shaky and desperate. Blake left me and I felt the emptiness wash over me like a cold wind blowing against my skin. He was by her side in record time, holding her hands and staring straight into her blue eyes, trying to manipulate her into believing him.

“I swear to you Crystal, it isn’t true. I like you way too much to try and mess it up by hooking up with Susan Bale or any other girl. I promise.” My sister looked like she so badly wanted to believe him, and she probably did believe him, but she had to make sure. She had to ask more questions.

“And the pregnancy? A lot of people are already saying…”

“I didn’t get her pregnant! I only knew about it because her mom and my mom are friends and they talk a lot and she mentioned it sometime during dinner with us. I didn’t mean for it to get out like this, but I didn’t get Susan pregnant and I most definitely didn’t text her to come over to my place or do anything else that would imply infidelity. I promise.”

Oh, he was good. He was so good that even I started to believe him. The way he looked into her eyes and held her hands, how his face looked so remorseful even though he had nothing to be sorry about. How he coerced her with that charming tongue and face of his. Blake Lindell was one sly bastard, alright.

“I like you a lot, Blake. In fact, I like you more than a lot. I can’t bear to think that you’d rather be with someone else than me, I just can’t.” She started crying, and Blake took this opportunity to seal the deal. In her vulnerable state, he said just the thing she was desperate to hear, even if she didn’t know it.

“I love you so much, Crys. I do and I wouldn’t do anything to jeopardize our relationship.”

My eyeballs bulged out of my sockets. Clearly, I heard wrong, right? He couldn’t possibly be ‘in love’ with her, right? He was only saying that to trick her and keep her in his clutches, like a true manipulator, making it almost impossible for her to let him go. He knew exactly how Crystal felt about him, and so he decided to use her feelings to his advantage. There was no absolute way that Blake Lindell was in love, not with my sister. Right?

Crystal looked like every single happiness in the world had been handed over to her in that moment. She was crying again, but this time it was tears of joy. She didn’t even bother to ask him again to confirm what he just said and replied with the same response.

“I love you too, Blake. And if you say it isn’t true, then I believe you.” Clearly the world was coming to an end. I was about to say something concerning this matter but stopped, a thought settling in my head.

Why did I believe a video I saw on the internet posted by some random stranger who probably wanted to ruin he and Crystal’s relationship? For all I know, he could actually be telling the truth.

But another thought seeped in, one that was still pained by what he did to me.

You believe it because it’s true, and you know that he is capable of this level of deception because he has done it before. Blake Lindell is a master of all arts and lying is most definitely one of his tricks.

They were now making out, and I felt so out of place and abandoned. Inasmuch as I was mad at him for possibly cheating on my sister with Susan Bale and then denying it, I was angrier at the fact that Crystal was blindsided by him and even forgave him immediately, knowing fully well that if I were in her shoes, I’d probably do the same thing. I wanted them to break up; I had expected that kind of response the moment my eyes saw the video and I heard what was being said. I wanted Blake to be single again, and maybe down the line, he and I could…

But no. Crystal had always liked Blake, so, she being in love with him only one month after they started going out was not that farfetched. It was understandable why she was eager to believe in the lies that he spoke. Why she wanted him to be her Knight in Shinny Amour no matter what accusation people threw at him. But just because she was okay with it didn’t mean I was. I was pissed and I didn’t know what to do with my anger. The conclusion I was hoping for did not come to pass and I felt even more foolish than ever to think that my being upset would somehow have any effect on him. All he needed to do was convince the girl he was dating that he was a saint in all this and everything would be fine. To hell with her brother who thought that he was a cheating scum.

Since I was already forgotten, and the happy couple were so engrossed with each other to even notice, I slipped out of the hallway and went to the parking lot, my mind a complete mess. I leaned on Anderson’s silver Prius and screamed and screamed until my lungs ached, until I needed air to survive and not just Blake’s love and attention, until I stopped hating my sister for being so ‘lucky.’

It was times like this I hated myself.

I hated that I was gay.

Always liking someone that was unattainable, that was the path I chose. That was what I was destined for. I was a terrible brother, a horrible friend and a despicable person.

Susan’s words from the video echoed in my ears and I felt the onset of tears build up in me.

“You can’t text me one morning that you’re horny and ask me to come over…”

But all I could think of in that moment was: “Why didn’t he text me instead? Why?”