Chapter 29
“It was so weird. You just stood there and let us hit you. You didn’t
move or try to get out of the way or nothing. Afterwards, I wondered if it
was just shock that made you stand there, but Jamie swore you were
trying to kill yourself. In the end, it didn’t really matter what the reasons
were, because you didn’t move and we hit you. You were gone before I
got the car stopped.” He paused, too emotional to continue. Jeffrey took
another deep breath before plunging them back into the story.
“We all got out of the car and ran back to help you. I don’t know
what we thought we’d be able to do for you,” he snorted angrily. We
were just four drunk, dumb kids who didn’t know their butts from a hole
in the ground, but we ran to you thinking were gonna save you or
something, but it was no use. You were dead and there wasn’t any
changing that.”
“We all stood there for what felt like forever, trying to decide what
to do. Some of us wanted to call the police but Jamie talked us out of it.
He said the police would arrest us all for underage drinking. He
convinced us that Brian would fry for being the driver. He said I’d
probably get it bad too because it was my car. He convinced us that both
he and Kevin would be brought up on manslaughter charges. He scared
us to death standing there in the dark, in the middle of the night with
stories about prison and electric chairs and junk.” His voice was hard and
resentful now. The story was coming out quickly, almost too fast for
Shayne to completely comprehend.
“Poor Kevin just kept standing there wringing his hands and saying,
‘Why didn’t she move?’ over and over. It was like he was in shock or
hysterics or something. He just kept shaking his head and saying if you
had moved we might not have actually killed you. Jamie was screaming
at him to shut up and at one point he even punched him. Of course Kevin
is a big guy, and he didn’t take that lying down. I jumped in, then Brian.
So here we all are rolling around scrapping next to your corpse.” Jeffrey
coughed a weird chuckle. “It would have been funny if it weren’t all so
horrible.”
Shayne sat frozen, lost in the story. Pictures of the night rolled
through her head, paralyzing her. She was disgusted and sad and sorry all
at the same time. Jeffrey realized she wasn’t in any shape to speak so he
continued.
“Now I’m not sure at what point in the night it happened, but
somewhere between the fighting and the panic, Jamie managed to get
into our heads. He kept hollering you were suicidal and meant to get
yourself killed. He insisted that it wasn’t murder if you were going to off
yourself anyway. Maybe it was the alcohol or maybe it was the panic but
he managed to half convince us all, that we were innocent.”
“I don’t guess I ever gave that boy enough credit. He is a smooth
talker. It wasn’t long before he got us all to swear to keeping it a secret.
We pushed my car into the lake and went back to gravel beach. We
passed out right before dawn, I guess. Anyway, we all got up the next
morning and reported my car stolen. We were most likely still out cold
when someone found your body. No one suspected us though. I reckon
the police rolled by just after sunrise and seen us all passed out on the
rocks. The police chief figured we had been there all night and let it go.”
Shayne stared out across the restaurant as he finished his story. A
single tear clung to her cheek. She was too stunned to speak, but instead
reached down and squeezed Jeffrey’s hand. He waited for her reaction.
He expected her to be mad, but instead she looked at him, her eyes full
of pity and remorse. She squeezed his hand again and shook her head.
Jeffrey looked at Shayne, his face full of disgust. “Don’t” he
whispered hoarsely. “Don’t tell me you forgive me. Yell at me. Scream,
cry, or just tell me you hate me, if that’s what you need to do. But please
Shayne; don’t tell me you forgive me.”
Shayne caught a sob in her throat. “Jeffrey, I don‘t hate you,” she
whispered. “I can see what carrying this secret has done to you. Just let it
go. I’m alive and we’re together. For once in your life just forgive
yourself.”
Jeffrey pulled his hand from under hers and looked away. How
could he ever hope to explain what killing her had actually done to him.
He could already see she was taking responsibility for his bad decision
on herself and it bugged him. He knew there were other consequences of
that night she would never be told. He watched her expression in
annoyance. “This wasn’t your fault. You didn’t do anything wrong. This
is my responsibility not yours,” he fumed.
Shayne shook her head and cleared her throat. “It was an accident,
Jeffrey.”
She couldn’t have been honest. It had all been an accident. Not just
the part where Jeffrey and his friends ran her down but her entire life, the
death of her parents, her death, and even her rebirth. Everything that
made her had been coincidental, nothing planned, and nothing prepared.
Yet as she looked forgivingly into the eyes of the man she loved, she
knew that this part could never be an accident.