Chapter 14: Tangled Hearts and Old Wounds

ANNABEL

Yeah, I was gonna accept his proposal. As fucked up as it sounded, I knew Damon wasn’t gonna keep this shit going forever. I needed something real, even though I craved him, wanted to keep drowning in his touch. But I couldn’t. We were just fucking around, pleasing each other, and it was gonna end one day, sure as hell.

“So, you gonna accept me? Did you give it a thought over the weekend?” Michael asked, his eyes hopeful. Yeah, all weekend I’d been holed up in my room, ironically dodging Damon like a damn ghost. Fuck, our escapades weren’t real.

“Yes, Michael, I’m gonna be your girlfriend,” I said, and trust me, I saw the excitement explode on his face, like he’d hit the fucking lottery. For a second, Damon’s face flashed in my head, dark and hungry, but I shoved it away, hard.

Right now, I had a boyfriend. I was dating one of the richest, hottest guys in school, and I couldn’t ask for more. Suddenly, he yanked me to his chest, hugging me tight as fuck. I froze, shocked, then remembered—he’s my boyfriend, he’s got every damn right to be this excited. I hugged him back, feeling his warmth.

“Thank you so fucking much, Anna. I swear I’ll make you the happiest woman on earth. Tell me what you need, and I’ll get it,” he said, voice full of promise. I smiled, giving his chest a playful punch.

“Hey, I’m good, still thinking of a cute name for you,” I said, and his smile—oh my fucking gosh—was divine. Have I said Michael’s the finest guy I’ve ever seen? His blonde hair glowed in the sun, high-maintenance as hell, and his face, like some Korean celebrity, all sharp and perfect.

“So, where we headed?” I asked as we walked through the hallway, students staring, some whispering. Honestly, I didn’t give a single fuck.

“We got English,” he said.

“We got a new student in class, and we’re all gonna welcome her, make her feel comfortable,” the English teacher said. I smiled, awkwardly hyped for whoever this new girl was. Maybe I’d make a friend, help her settle in.

A young woman stepped in, head high, and her eyes locked on mine. I froze, eyes wide with shock, surprise, and fucking fear. Hell fucking no, I’m not making friends.

It lasted seconds, then her gaze slid away. “What the fuck is she doing here?” I whispered, Michael clueless to the tension choking the room.

“Hello, girl, introduce yourself,” the teacher said.

“My name’s Janet, and trust me, I’m a charm,” she said, winking at the class. They erupted in screams, shouts, but I caught her smirk, aimed right at me, sharp as a blade.

“You look like the blood drained from your face. You alright?” Michael asked, concern all over his pretty face.

“That fucking brat, what the fuck’s she doing here? Why this school, of all places? She was in San Francisco, what’s she doing in my fucking school?” I hissed, low, just for Michael.

“What, you know her?” he asked, eyes widening.

I turned, my face cold as ice. I’d recognize my ex-best friend who fucked my ex-boyfriend Mark anywhere, anytime. She hadn’t changed—blonde hair styled like a damn mermaid, clothes so short and tight they screamed for attention.

“Yeah, she was my ex-best friend,” I whispered, and Michael’s eyes got bigger.

Who’d think I was friends with a backstabber like her?

“Annabel, got something to say?” the lecturer snapped.

I shook my head. “Good, now shut it. Pleasantries ended a minute ago,” Miss Rachel said. I nodded.

As I stormed out of class, Michael followed. It was lunchtime, but I wanted to be far from her. I hated her fucking guts, hated the images of her riding Mark’s cock like she wanted me to watch.

“Hey, Anna, stop running so fast, okay? Don’t tell me she’s making you uncomfortable?” Michael asked, and I rolled my eyes.

“No, I’m not uncomfortable, Michael. I just don’t wanna see her fucking face,” I said, grabbing fries, turkey, a huge cup of ice cream, and a canned drink.

“You really gonna eat all this?” Michael said, helping with my tray. I grinned.

“You don’t like your woman eating well?” I teased, extra sass in my voice. His smile was hot, and I grinned wider. I had an effect on him, but… he didn’t have that effect on me. Only one man did. I shook my head, shoving Damon back into the dark corners of my mind. Today was about being a girlfriend, and every day from now on.

“What’d she do? What made you both break…” he started.

“She fucked my ex-boyfriend. I caught her riding his cock, him moaning like a damn pervert. That’s what happened, and she didn’t regret it. Want me to go on?” I snapped, shoving ice cream in my mouth. He shook his head, shocked at my outburst.

“That’s a lot,” he said, munching chips.

“Can I join you guys? Seems like two empty chairs,” a voice said. No, her voice, that annoying, sultry, creepy-ass voice. I didn’t look up, didn’t want her to see the anger and hurt burning in me.

I glanced at Michael, caught in a dilemma. I didn’t wanna put him in that spot. “No, miss, the seats are taken, and we’d like to be alone,” I said, avoiding her name.

“Ooh, really, so you wanna be with your boyfriend,” she said, and fuck, I wanted to rip those words from her mouth.

Finally, I looked up, staring her down. “Yes, I wanna be alone with my boyfriend. Thanks for noticing,” I said, voice sharp.

She smiled, eyes sliding to Michael. “Didn’t know you could make someone like him yours. He seems too good for you,” she said, turning to leave. My eyes burned red, itching to yank her curly hair, make her regret ever crossing me.

“Hey, hun, don’t let her mess with your head. She wants to get to you,” Michael said, his hand on mine. A smile broke through my rage.

Maybe, just maybe, this could work.

“Okay, you just called me hun?” I asked, smiling so hard it hurt.

“Well, you want me calling you Cupcake? Though I wanna keep that special for when we make out,” he said, and I froze. My face must’ve looked fucked up because he shook me, almost violently, till I snapped back.

“Don’t call me Cupcake, please. Call me anything else, just not that,” I said, voice clear, firm, cutting through.

“Umm, yes, Anna, I won’t,” he said, taken aback at my reaction.