Chapter 32: The Same Taste

The afternoon sun streamed through the windows, illuminating Frederick Michelini's face as he sat in the living room with his daughters, Alexia and Analú, ready to enjoy the movie The Great Deception. On the table lay sodas and a large tray of popcorn, filling the air with a salty aroma.

Halfway through the movie, Alexia turned to her father with a mischievous smile.

—Daddy, it’s been a while since we’ve had pizza. Could we make an exception today? —she asked, her eyes sparkling with mischief.

Frederick looked at her with a knowing smile. He could already feel himself giving in.

—Sounds delicious, but just this once. You know those kinds of foods aren’t the best for us —he replied, his tone more playful than serious.

—Perfect! —Alexia exclaimed, victorious—. What flavor would you like?

Analú, looking uninterested, shrugged.

—Doesn’t matter to me —she said nonchalantly, already knowing she wouldn’t eat it unless it came with her guava spread.

Half an hour later, a steaming chicken and mushroom pizza arrived. The aroma filled the room, making it impossible for anyone to resist. Alexia opened the box, and the escaping heat heightened everyone’s appetite.

Frederick laughed nostalgically as he looked at the pizza.

—It’s been years since I’ve had pizza —he said, his voice tinged with memories.

Alexia raised an eyebrow, surprised.

—That’s true, Dad. I don’t think I’ve ever seen you eat something like this. Is this your first pizza?

Before Frederick could respond, Alexia turned to Analú, noticing she wasn’t as enthusiastic as expected.

—Analú, don’t you like pizza? I can order something else if you want —she offered, secretly planning to distract her long enough to take something from her bag unnoticed.

Analú gave a weak smile.

—It’s not that, Alexia. It’s just... —She stopped as Mrs. Lupe entered the room, carrying a bar of guava paste. Analú froze in shock as she watched Frederick take the guava and spread it over his pizza.

—Guava paste?! —Analú exclaimed, her eyes wide with disbelief—. I can’t believe it...

Alexia burst out laughing, suddenly remembering.

—Oh, now I get it! I remember when you made me eat pizza with guava at the hospital. That day was awful. I don’t understand how you enjoy it! —she said, looking at her father with a mix of disbelief and amusement—. I can’t believe you like it too, Dad!

Frederick chuckled, nodding at Analú.

—It seems we share a secret, don’t we, Analú? Amelia, Alexia’s mother, introduced me to this strange combination. The first time I tried it, I thought it was terrible, but over time... —He paused, lost in thought—. She always carried a guava bar in her bag whenever we went out for pizza. One day, out of sheer curiosity, I tried it, and since then, I’ve loved it. Maybe you should give it another try, Alexia. You never know when something odd might become your favorite.

—No way! —Alexia exclaimed, shaking her head—. Once was more than enough.

As the movie ended, Analú excused herself to use the bathroom. Frederick used the moment to call Thomas and arrange for Analú to be driven home, not wanting her parents to worry. The brief solitude was the perfect opportunity Alexia needed. Quickly, she rose from the couch, glanced toward the door to ensure no one was returning, and deftly rummaged through Analú’s bag, pulling out something small and slipping it into the empty pizza box.

—See you next week, Analú —Frederick said kindly as Analú left the mansion. Alexia also smiled at her, though inside, her nerves were building. She needed that item.

When Alexia returned to the living room, her heart sank as she saw the spotless table.

—Lupe! Lupe! —she shouted, panicked—. Where’s the pizza box?!

The housekeeper rushed in.

—Miss Alexia, I thought it was trash, so I threw it away... —She stopped as she noticed Alexia’s face turning pale—. The garbage truck hasn’t come yet, but...

Without waiting, Alexia bolted outside, grabbing gloves on her way. Standing before the large trash container, she began frantically searching through the bags, tossing them aside without care, her heartbeat thundering in her ears. Finally, she found the pizza box. But when she opened it... nothing was inside.

Her world froze.

Back inside, defeated and with her head hanging low, she was met by Mrs. Lupe holding something in her hands.

—Miss Alexia, I didn’t get a chance to tell you. I found this in the box and thought it might be important, so I kept it.

Alexia let out a trembling sigh of relief, taking the item gratefully.

In her room, under the dim light of her lamp, Alexia held the pendant between her fingers. It was identical to hers: a fist holding a heart. But this one lacked the engraved initials of her parents.

—How is this possible...? —she murmured, pulling out her own pendant from her nightstand to compare them.

Before the girls were swapped as babies, Michelini had two unique pendants crafted: a fist holding a heart, symbolizing the love and strength of their parents. Each pendant bore the initials of his name and his wife’s, representing the unbreakable bond of their family.

One of these pendants had been placed with baby Analú at birth. Years later, while Analú was hospitalized for her heart condition, she lost the pendant during an afternoon of tree climbing with her best friend, Nicolás. Her devastated cries echoed for hours, the pain of losing something so precious overwhelming her. Nicolás, moved by her grief, promised to get her another one when they were older.

The pendant Alexia now held was the fulfillment of that promise. But something was missing: the in

itials of her parents’ names. Alexia studied it closely, her heart pounding.