Chapter 51: Stay With Him

All eyes were on our side as Miriam held her cheek so tight, as her fingers were digging into the skin like she was trying to hold her face together from the inside out. I could feel the tension grow thick and heavy in the air. It was so loud even in silence. Every eye was watching, but it was Norman’s eyes that were sharpest. I saw his lips move, and though I wasn’t standing right beside him, I saw how he leaned toward Ethan and whispered. Ethan’s brows tightened slightly. Whatever Norman said was brief, but it carried weight. I could only imagine it sounded like “take care of this,” judging from the way his eyes moved to Ethan’s face and then directly to mine like a knife. Something like, you shouldn't have done it.

But that look. That same expression was what I saw eleven years ago. Cold. Controlling. My stomach tightened.

I was fuming in anger. My hands clenched. The Malcovich family—the same ones who destroyed everything I ever loved—were still trying to crush what was left of my dignity, because I wanted to use his son to get my revenge?. And now Miriam, with her pretentious little act, was trying to pin all this on me? Because of what? Because she couldn’t stomach the fact that Ethan no longer looked at her the way he looked at me?

Miriam noticed Ethan approaching. Her demeanor shifted like the flick of a switch. The tears came too easily. They rolled down her cheeks with such false grace it almost looked practiced. She held onto Ethan like a wounded lover. Her hands clung to his arm like she belonged there, her face buried into his shoulder as she started trembling like someone who had just been attacked.

“Ethan…” she whispered, her voice shaky. “I didn’t want it to happen… she just slapped me for nothing. I swear… I was just trying to talk to her… just asking why she didn’t pick her calls… and she got mad. I was scared, I didn’t even know what to say.”

I didn’t move. I didn’t say a single word. My body was burning with anger, but my lips stayed sealed. I could feel it in my bones that if I opened my mouth, I might say something I couldn’t take back.

Ethan turned to look at me. His brows were furrowed, confused. Maybe a little hurt. He placed a soft but firm hand on Miriam’s shoulder as she clung tighter. “Norah?” he said calmly, trying to read my silence. “What happened?”

I just looked at him. My heart thudded. Not because I was guilty. But because I knew what this could turn into. He was trying to be neutral, but it didn’t feel neutral. It felt like doubt.

“Why were you both arguing in the first place?” he asked again. “Norah, talk to me.”

I still said nothing. I hated that I hadn’t answered Emily’s calls. That’s all I kept thinking about. Maybe something happened. Maybe something went wrong. But Miriam wouldn’t even let that space exist. She was running her mouth with lies and coating them with perfect sweetness.

“She was yelling at me,” Miriam continued, tears still pouring, “because I asked if everything was okay… She said I was trying to get involved with Ethan… and then she slapped me, Ethan. Right in front of everyone. I didn’t even know what I did wrong.”

“You’ve said enough,” I finally said, my voice low and controlled.

Ethan rubbed his temple like his mind was splitting into two sides. He didn’t speak harshly, but the confusion in his voice made me feel a sting.

“Norah,” he said gently, “I don’t understand why this happened. You could’ve told me if something was wrong. I don’t want this kind of thing… not between you two.”

Still, I stayed quiet. I didn’t need to explain myself to him in front of her. Let him think what he wanted.

After a moment, he pulled out his phone and made a call. I watched his fingers move across the screen. He muttered something, then hung up. Within moments, a car pulled up at the side of the grand hall.

“Come on,” Ethan said, while opening the door and guiding Miriam gently into the car. She hesitated, turning to him with her watery eyes.

“Are you coming with me?” she asked, almost like she was breaking.

Ethan’s face didn’t change. He just said to the driver, “Drive.”

The door shut.

He turned to me.

His hand held my waist as he walked me to his car quietly. “Wait here, Norah,” he said. His voice was soft, and warm this time.

I sat there, my back pressed into the seat, trying to keep my heart still. I looked around the car, trying to distract my mind from boiling. But it was hard. It was too loud in my head.

Then my earpiece buzzed softly. It cracked faintly. I leaned to the side, placing one hand against my ear.

It was Marcus.

His voice was low, fast. “Whatever you’re doing, stay with Ethan for the night.”

“What?” I whispered.

“Stay with him. I will tell you what to do when you get Ethan's house, Aria….. Stop asking questions.”

“Marcus, I can’t…”

I heard a beep.

He had hung up.