Chapter 22: Jake's Choice
POV: Sheriff Jake Morrison
My phone rang at midnight with Eleanor's name on the screen.
I almost didn't answer it. I was sitting in my patrol car outside town, trying to figure out how to help Maya and Riley without starting a fight. But something told me Eleanor wouldn't call unless it was important.
"Hello, Eleanor."
"Jake, we need to talk. Right now."
"About what?"
"About the choice you need to make. Maya Chen's life depends on it."
My blood went cold. "What are you talking about?"
"Meet me at the old pier in ten minutes. Come alone. And Jake? Bring your handcuffs."
She hung up before I could ask any questions.
I knew it was a trick, but I had to go. If Eleanor had Maya and Riley, this might be my only chance to save them.
The pier was dark and empty when I arrived. Fog rolled in from the ocean, making it hard to see more than a few feet ahead. I kept my hand on my gun as I walked toward the end of the pier.
Eleanor stepped out of the darkness with two armed men behind her.
"Hello, Jake. Thank you for coming."
"Where are Maya and Riley?"
"Safe for now. But their safety relies on what you decide to do next."
"What do you want?"
Eleanor smiled that cold smile I'd learned to hate. "I want you to arrest Maya Chen for the murder of Tommy Rodriguez."
"Maya didn't kill Tommy. You did."
"The evidence says otherwise. And tomorrow morning, you're going to find that proof in what's left of Maya's burned apartment."
I looked at her. "You burned down her building?"
"A important step. Maya was getting too close to information that could hurt our group."
"You mean information that could expose your trafficking ring."
Eleanor's face didn't change. "I have no idea what you mean."
"Cut the act, Eleanor. I know about the boats. I know about the missing kids. I know you killed Lisa Chen because she was asking questions."
"Be very careful, Jake. You're starting to sound like Maya. And look what happened to her."
My heart jumped. "What happened to Maya?"
"Nothing yet. But in about fifteen minutes, my men are going to storm the lighthouse where she and Riley are hidden. Unless you make the right choice."
I felt sick. Maya and Riley were trapped, and Eleanor was using them to force me to destroy Maya's image.
"What choice?"
Eleanor pulled out a folder full of papers. "You can arrest Maya for Tommy's death. The proof is all here. Blood on her clothes, her fingerprints on the murder weapon, witness accounts saying she threatened Tommy."
"All fake evidence."
"The court won't know that. Maya will go to prison for life, but she'll be living. Riley will be adopted by a nice family far away from here. And you can go back to being Millbrook Bay's respected sheriff."
She held out a second folder.
"Or you can choose this folder. It contains pictures of your secret investigation into my business. Recordings of you talking about trafficking. Evidence that you've been planning to betray the people who pay your salary."
I looked at the second folder with fear. If those photos got out, everyone in town would think I'd been scheming against them. I'd lose my job, my home, maybe even my life. " If you don't arrest Maya, this folder goes public tomorrow. Everyone will know you've been spying on the families that keep this town going. Your own friends will hate you."
My hands were shaking. Eleanor had trapped me perfectly. Either way, my life in Millbrook Bay was over.
"You have two minutes to decide, Jake. Arrest Maya and save your job. Or try to save her and lose everything."
I looked out at the dark water and thought about Maya. She'd only been in town for a few days, but she'd changed everything for me. She made me remember why I became a sheriff in the first place – to protect harmless people from criminals like Eleanor.
"Jake, time's up," Eleanor said. "What's your choice?"
I took out my phone and started calling.
"Who are you calling?" Eleanor asked.
"The FBI."
Eleanor's men raised their guns, but I kept calling.
"Jake, hang up that phone right now or Maya Chen dies tonight."
"Go ahead and kill her," I said, even though it broke my heart to say it. "The FBI will just add her murder to your list of crimes."
"You're bluffing."
The FBI dispatcher answered. "This is Agent Martinez. How can I help you?"
"This is Sheriff Jake Morrison in Millbrook Bay, California. I'm reporting a human trafficking operation and multiple killings. I need quick backup."
Eleanor screamed at her men. "Stop him!"
But I was already running back toward my car, still talking to the FBI.
"The suspects are Eleanor Blackwood and her friends. They're holding two prisoners at the old lighthouse. They've killed at least three people that I know of."
"We're sending helicopters immediately," Agent Martinez said. "Can you get to the hostages?"
"I'm going to try."
I jumped in my police car and raced toward the lighthouse. In my rearview mirror, I could see Eleanor's guys chasing me in their black SUVs.
My radio buzzed. It was Captain Rodriguez.
"Jake, what the hell are you doing? Eleanor says you've lost your mind."
"Rodriguez, Eleanor's been running a trafficking ring. She killed Tommy Rodriguez and Lisa Chen. She's holding Maya and Riley hostage."
"Jake, you need to come back to the station. We need to talk about this."
I realized Rodriguez was working for Eleanor too. How many people in my own department were dirty?
"Sorry, Captain. I can't do that."
I turned off my radio and kept going.
As I got closer to the lighthouse, I could see orange flames rising up into the night sky. The building was on fire.
I called Maya's number, hoping she would answer.
"Jake, thank God," she said when she picked up.
"Maya, where are you?" "Trapped in the tower. Eleanor's men set it on fire. We can't get out."
"I'm two minutes away. The FBI is coming too."
"Jake, there's something you need to know. We found proof that my sister Lisa was held here before Eleanor killed her. This is where she died."
My heart broke for Maya. She was stuck in the same place where her sister had been murdered.
"Maya, you need to get to the highest part of the tower. Stay above the smoke until I can get to you."
"We're trying, but the fire is spreading fast."
I could see the lighthouse ahead of me now. Eleanor's cars were circling it, and armed men were everywhere.
"Maya, I need you to know something in case I don't make it."
"What?"
"I love you. I've only known you for a few days, but I love you."
"Jake, don't talk like that. You're going to make it. We both are."
"I hope so."
I hung up and pushed the gas pedal. My police car smashed through Eleanor's roadblock and kept going toward the lighthouse.
That's when I saw Maya and Riley rappelling down the side of the burning building on a rope.
And Eleanor standing below them with a gun pointed up at the rope.
I had three seconds to save the woman I loved, and only one bullet left in my gun.
But as I raised my weapon to shoot Eleanor, I saw something that made me freeze.
Riley wasn't on the rope anymore.
She was falling through the air toward the rocks below.