Chapter 34

The silence between Julian and me is unbearable.

The weight of everything that’s happened—everything I now know—presses against me like a vice. My breath is uneven, my fingers trembling at my sides, but I don’t move.

Julian doesn’t either.

He’s standing near the fireplace, his body tense, his gray eyes heavy with something unreadable.

Not guilt.

Not regret.

Something worse.

Resignation.

Like he already knows there’s nothing he can say to fix this.

And maybe there isn’t.

I remember now.

I remember Cassian.

I remember who really turned me.

And I remember Julian wasn’t the villain.

He was the sacrifice.

And yet, it doesn’t change the betrayal.

It doesn’t erase the fact that he let me hate him rather than tell me the truth.

"I’m so sorry," he had whispered.

And maybe he was.

But that didn’t make it okay.

I take a shaky breath, forcing myself to speak. “You should have told me.”

Julian exhales slowly, his shoulders tight. “I know.”

I clench my jaw. “Then why didn’t you?”

He drags a hand through his hair, looking away. “Because I didn’t want you to remember like this.”

A bitter laugh escapes me. “Like what? Finding out that I spent all this time hating the wrong person? That I let the real monster slip through my fingers while I put all my rage on you?”

Julian’s throat bobs.

“I didn’t want you to carry that.” His voice is quiet, wrecked.

I shake my head. “That wasn’t your decision to make.”

His eyes darken. “It was the only choice I had.”

And that—that makes me snap.

“No!” I step forward, my breath coming in sharp, broken bursts. “You always act like you had no choice. Like everything was decided for you. But it wasn’t. You made a choice. You chose to take my memories, to let me believe a lie.”

Julian doesn’t deny it.

Because he can’t.

His fingers twitch at his sides, his lips pressing into a thin line. He looks at me like he wants to say something—like he wants to explain, to justify.

But I don’t let him.

I shake my head. “You can say whatever you want, Julian, but at the end of the day, you stole something from me. You took away my pain, my anger, my truth.” My voice shakes. “And you took away my chance to grieve.”

Julian’s breath catches.

For the first time, I see it.

The moment he realizes how deeply he’s hurt me.

Not just by lying.

But by taking away the parts of me that should have been mine to carry.

I close my eyes for half a second, trying to steady myself.

I need air.

I need space.

And I need to get away from Julian before I break completely.

I step back, my hands trembling.

Julian doesn’t stop me.

Because he knows he can’t.

I don’t say another word as I turn.

I just walk away.

And for the second time, Julian lets me go.

**Celeste Finds Me**

I don’t know where I’m going.

I just walk.

The halls of Julian’s mansion are dimly lit, the chandeliers above casting long, golden shadows along the walls. The air is too thick, too suffocating.

I need to leave.

I need to get away before I—

“Well, that was dramatic.”

I stop.

Celeste leans against a marble column at the end of the hallway, her deep red lips curled into something half-amused, half-knowing.

Her violet eyes glitter in the candlelight.

She tilts her head. “So? Did he cry?”

I exhale sharply, shaking my head. “Not in the mood, Celeste.”

She hums, pushing off the column, stepping toward me. “I’ll take that as a yes.”

I clench my jaw, swallowing the lump in my throat. “Did you need something?”

Celeste studies me.

Not with mockery this time.

But with curiosity.

Like she’s searching for something beneath my anger.

Then—her smirk fades.

And her voice drops.

"Do you love him?"

I flinch.

Because it’s the first time someone has asked me that since I remembered.

I open my mouth—then close it.

Because I don’t know the answer anymore.

Or maybe, I do.

Maybe I just don’t know if love is enough.

Celeste sighs, crossing her arms. “Love isn’t always soft, sweetheart.”

I look up, meeting her gaze.

Her expression is unreadable.

But her next words aren’t.

"Sometimes, it’s survival."

My breath catches.

Because suddenly—I understand.

Julian’s love for me wasn’t gentle.

It wasn’t pure.

It was messy, desperate, full of mistakes.

But it was still love.

His version of it, anyway.

The only way he knew how to hold on.

And for a moment—**a horrible, painful moment—**I wonder if I had been in his place…

Would I have done the same?

Would I have taken the truth away from him to protect him?

Would I have erased his memories, rewritten his past, if I thought it would save him?

The answer terrifies me.

Because I don’t know if I would have been strong enough to do anything differently.

Celeste watches my face carefully, like she sees the war happening inside me.

Then, she sighs.

"You should rest," she says lightly. "You look like hell."

I don’t argue.

Because I do feel like hell.

And my mind is too tangled to unravel anything else tonight.

I turn, walking toward my room.

But before I leave, Celeste speaks one last time.

"You can hate him all you want, Ana. But it won’t change the fact that he gave up everything for you."

I freeze.

But I don’t turn around.

I don’t answer.

I just keep walking.

Because I already know she’s right.

And I don’t know if that makes me love him more…

Or hate him more.