Chapter 25: Remorseful

Maxwell’s POV

Clay stepped into the room, and it hit him immediately—a thick, almost stifling tension filled the space, weighing down on every corner.

His brows furrowed as he tried to make sense of the strange atmosphere.

“What… what happened here?” he asked, voice edged with confusion. His gaze wandered slowly around the room, taking in the fragments of what he didn’t yet understand. Then, as if a realization dawned on him, he looked up. “Where’s Scarlett?”

I noticed Lucian’s eyes flick in my direction, a silent cue that did little to comfort me. So, with a sigh, I confessed.

“I told her to rest in your room,” I said, almost bracing for his reaction. I fully expected him to object, maybe even demand an explanation, but he didn’t. Instead, his response was different—unexpected, even.

“It’s about time,” he murmured, and his words tugged at something deep within me, filling me with a pang of shame I hadn’t anticipated. He didn’t know the things I knew, the secrets that had slowly poisoned my thoughts. Yet, he continued to love her, with a kind of purity and strength that made my own love feel small, like a flickering candle beside a blazing fire. His heart was wide and boundless; mine, in comparison, seemed selfish and flawed.

“So why the gloom?” Clay finally asked, a gentle attempt to break the silence. His eyes moved between Lucian and me, searching for answers we hadn’t offered yet. Lucian, rigid and unyielding beside me, remained silent, the weight of his pride and anger sealing his lips. I knew he wasn’t going to speak, so I decided to bear the burden of explaining.

“Lucian brought Stasia to live with him,” I began, my voice barely above a whisper, as if each word might shatter the fragile air around us. “And I suggested he take the other room. But he refused… said he’d rather put Scarlett through torment than give up his stubborn pride. I told him he had to make a choice, that if he was going to be with Stasia, he should let Scarlett go.” My voice faltered, remembering Scarlett’s pained request. “She asked both of us—me and Lucian—to reject her. She wanted that freedom, yesterday.”

Clay’s eyes widened, shock spilling across his features as he took it all in. “She asked for that?” he repeated softly, as if the words tasted bitter on his tongue. I nodded, feeling a lump in my throat. It was hard to see Clay’s reaction, knowing how much Scarlett meant to him.

“Guess I missed more than I thought,” he admitted, glancing down as he tried to piece together what he’d just learned. I nodded again, feeling the weight of it all pressing on my shoulders.

Lucian, who had remained silent so far, finally spoke, his voice laced with bitterness. “He fought me… for that… whore,” he spat, unable to hold back his contempt. I turned to him, meeting his glare with a calm I barely felt.

“You charged at me first,” I reminded him, refusing to let his anger colour the truth. “And I’ve asked you—stop calling her that.” My tone was firm, almost pleading, but I knew Lucian was too far gone in his resentment to listen.

Before things could escalate further, Clay raised his hands, his calm voice cutting through the tension like a balm. “I get it,” he said, his gaze flicking between us, a silent plea for peace.

“Why didn’t you just reject her, Lucian?” Clay’s voice was firm, his gaze steady as he waited for an answer. But Lucian couldn’t bring himself to respond. He just stood there, his silence louder than any words could have been.

I spoke up, unable to hide my frustration any longer. “He has cruel intentions, Clay. He plans to claim her… and then reject her. All so he can end up with Stasia.” The shock and disbelief that flashed across Clay’s face made Lucian flinch, but he still couldn’t bring himself to deny it.

Clay’s voice, low and laced with anger, cut through the thick silence. “You’re willing to condemn yourself for a grudge against Nikolay? You’d actually go that far? For all we know, Nikolay is long gone or reincarnated somewhere, and yet you’re prepared to ruin yourself just to settle this vendetta? This will haunt you for the rest of your life, Lucian.”

Lucian turned his gaze away, unable to meet Clay’s intense stare. There was a heaviness in the air, a tension that left each of us feeling on edge and unsettled.

Trying to break the silence, Clay looked around, his tone softer but tinged with exhaustion. “So… where am I supposed to sleep now?”

I was just about to suggest a solution when the sound of a door opening drew our attention. Scarlett stepped out of the room, and I realised, with a sinking feeling, that she must have heard every word. Her face was calm, but there was a sadness in her eyes that made my heart ache.

“In your room, Alpha Clay,” she said gently. “I’ve made the bed for you.” Her words were polite, but I could sense the pain behind them. She had been resting, or so I thought. Instead, she’d been lying there, hearing every painful detail of the conversation that we had tried to keep from her. I wished, more than anything, that I could take back the words I’d said, could somehow shield her from the truth.

Lucian’s eyes burned with anger as he looked at me, suspicion clouding his gaze. I could feel the accusation there—that he believed I’d spilled his plans to hurt her. But I hadn’t meant for her to find out like this. None of us did.

Scarlett took a steadying breath, and when she spoke, her voice was barely above a whisper but filled with determination. “May I… take the spare room outside this apartment, please? Just for now. That way, Lucian and Stasia can be together in his room, and everyone can be… at peace.”

Her request was practical, even logical, but it felt wrong. I hated the idea of her being so far from us, and I knew Clay felt the same. Her suggestion was a compromise, a way to give everyone what they thought they wanted. But it felt like a surrender, a sacrifice none of us wanted her to make.

Lucian’s lips twisted into a reluctant smile, understanding the impact of her words. “Okay,” he said, his tone laced with satisfaction, knowing this decision was the last thing Clay or I wanted.

Scarlett moved with quiet resolve, gathering her few belongings and tucking them into a small bag. She clutched the blanket Clay had given her, her fingers trembling slightly, though she tried to hide it. Without another word, she stepped past us and out of the apartment, closing the door softly behind her.

“Now, you’ll see her true colors,” Lucian sneered, a twisted satisfaction in his tone. “I wonder what you’ll do when she starts sneaking men into that new room of hers.”

I felt a surge of frustration, exhausted by his petty spite. Lucian’s bitterness was tiring, a smokescreen of accusations to mask his own guilt. He acted as though he were innocent, a saint among sinners, but I knew the truth—neither of us were blameless. If anyone here was tainted, it was us, not her. And soon enough, his self-righteous facade would crumble. Thomas was on his way, and I couldn’t wait for him to arrive and set things straight.

“Just call Thomas and end this,” I said, my voice flat with fatigue. “Let’s see what he has to say.”

Lucian’s eyes flashed with anger, but he forced a smirk. “Fine, if that’s what you want. I’ll call Thomas tomorrow. Hate to pull him from his duties, but since you insist…” His tone was mocking, but I could sense his unease beneath it. I forced a smile and nodded, thanking him, though the sarcasm was lost on neither of us. He turned sharply and disappeared into his room, leaving me standing with Clay.

Clay studied me with a questioning look. “Why is Thomas coming?” he asked, clearly sensing there was more to it.

I sighed, reaching out to tap his shoulder. “You’ll see soon enough.” I started to walk away, but he grabbed my arm, concern etched deeply in his eyes.

“We can’t seriously leave Scarlett alone in that room,” he said, his voice barely a whisper. “You know she’s in a fragile place—she’s suicidal.”

My heart pounded with sudden urgency. He was right. I hadn’t thought it through, but Clay’s words cut through any lingering doubts. Without another word, I headed to the guest room, Clay close behind. Neither of us took a moment to rest or freshen up; there was no time for that now. We approached the door, knocking softly at first, not wanting to startle her. When there was no answer, I felt a rising dread. Clay and I exchanged worried glances, and I knocked harder, calling out her name.

Finally, the door opened, and Scarlett appeared in the doorway, her face pale, her eyes wide with worry. She looked at us, confused and a little scared.

The relief that washed over me was intense, but it was short-lived as I took in her expression.