Chapter 153: Unresolved 1

Scarlett’s POV

“Honestly, I could understand Clay and Maxwell’s pain,” I said, my voice cold and steady as I folded the napkin and placed it on the table. “They’ve always wanted me. But you…” I trailed off, locking eyes with him, ensuring my words hit their mark. “You settled for me. So don’t tell me anything you think I don’t already know.”

I stood, my chair scraping softly against the floor as I moved to leave. But Lucian was faster. He stepped in front of me, his body a barrier, his presence heavy with desperation.

“Out of my way, Lucian,” I said, my tone calm but resolute.

Instead of moving, he took a step closer. His chest rose and fell rapidly, the tension radiating from him palpable. His swollen eyes betrayed the weight he carried, and for once, I could see all his emotions laid bare. He had learned the pain of silence, the consequence of his own choices.

“Please don’t,” he finally whispered, his voice hoarse and trembling. It was almost inaudible, but the raw anguish in his words was impossible to miss.

“Please, Scarlett, don’t,” he repeated, his hand reaching out to grasp mine. His touch was hesitant, trembling with fear, and I could smell it—his fear, his hopelessness. He was laying everything on the line, a man stripped of all his armor.

“Words can never describe how sorry I am,” he said, his voice cracking under the weight of his guilt. “And I don’t expect you to just forgive me, but please, Scarlett, don’t do this.” His grip on my hand tightened, not enough to hurt, but enough to convey how much he was clinging to this moment, to me.

“Stasia was a mistake,” he admitted, his voice thick with regret. “I shouldn’t have brought her up. I shouldn’t have believed Bianca. I shouldn’t have put the law above you. I was foolish, blind, and wrong. But please, Scarlett…” His voice broke completely as he leaned closer, his eyes glistening with unshed tears. “You are my life. If you leave me…” He choked on the words, unable to finish the sentence. “There will be nothing more to live for.”

He held on tightly, his body trembling with the weight of everything he was confessing. This was Lucian, stripped of his pride, his defenses, his excuses. He stood before me not as a leader, not as a warrior, but as a broken man who had run out of weapons to fight with—except his heart.

I stared at him, his face strained and his pain etched in every line. He wore his suffering openly, unable to mask it, unable to pretend anymore. For a moment, the world seemed to pause, the weight of his words pressing down on both of us.

“I’ve made countless promises to you, Scarlett,” he said softly, his voice steadier now, though still raw. “And I’ve failed you in every way that matters. I won’t add to that pile of empty words. What I can offer you now is justice. I’ll find those who’ve hurt you, and I’ll make them pay.” His grip on my hand faltered slightly, but he held on, as if afraid I’d slip away.

“And as for me…” He paused, his gaze locking onto mine, pleading, vulnerable. “All I can ask is that you forgive what I’ve done. And give me the chance to rebuild. To rebuild myself, to rebuild us.”

Lucian’s voice cracked as he spoke, his words raw, unfiltered, and dripping with desperation. Tears slid down his face, unguarded and vulnerable.

“The thought of you leaving… it’s unbearable,” he admitted, his voice trembling as if the confession itself took every ounce of strength he had left. “I hope you’ve given Clay and Maxwell this by choosing to stay—it’s everything to them. But please, Scarlett, don’t leave me out. I promise to cherish you, protect you, and honour you all the days of my life. Without you, I have nothing. I am nothing.”

The sight of him—this strong, resolute man reduced to raw emotion—broke my heart. I thought of how fiercely he had faced Garland, how unwavering he had been in his duties, and I realized he was this vulnerable now because of me. Only I got to see this side of him, this fragile part he hid so well from the world. Only I would ever see him like this. But was it enough?

“Lucian…” I began, my voice soft yet firm, and his gaze shot to mine, filled with expectation and hope.

“I am not severing our bond,” I said, and the relief that flooded his face was immediate and overwhelming. For a moment, he was completely still, his breath catching as the words sank in.

“I can’t… not when I still want you,” I continued, my voice trembling slightly. “And I can’t hide that from you—you know it. Tiger knows it. But I can’t promise that I’ll just get over the pain. I can’t because it’s a deep wound, Lucian. One that’s left a scar, and I’m still trying to heal from it. But…” I hesitated, taking a steadying breath, “I am willing to try again.”

Before I could say another word, Lucian pulled me into his arms and kissed me. It wasn’t gentle or restrained—it was desperate, a raw expression of everything he couldn’t put into words. The kiss was fierce, filled with longing and regret, a testament to how deeply he felt for me. I could feel his heart bleeding through every movement, his hands trembling as they held me.

When he pulled back, he rested his forehead against mine, his breathing uneven as he inhaled my scent like it was the only thing keeping him grounded. “Thank you, Scarlett,” he whispered, his voice thick with emotion.

I stepped back, putting a little distance between us. His gaze followed me, attentive, hanging onto my every word like a lifeline. I studied him for a moment, trying to gauge the sincerity behind his actions. Finally, I spoke, my voice quiet but resolute.

“I just have one question for you, Lucian,” I said, and he straightened, his focus entirely on me. The way he looked at me reminded me of a puppy desperate to please—Maxwell’s self-description suddenly made perfect sense.

“Why didn’t any of you check on me while I was locked up?” I asked, my voice steady but tinged with the hurt I’d carried for so long. “Why didn’t you come to see me? To make sure I was being treated fairly? To ensure that your orders were being carried out properly?”

Lucian’s shoulders slumped, and he exhaled deeply, the weight of the question visibly bearing down on him. His jaw tightened for a moment before he spoke.

“We weren’t here,” he said quietly, the guilt in his voice unmistakable. “We were on a desperate search, crossing town after town, trying to find Geoffrey Olsen. We even went into the West without Keith’s permission, risking everything to clear your name. For two months, Scarlett. Two months, we searched endlessly, and all we had were phone reports—‘She’s fine.’ That’s all they told us. We relied on those reports because we thought… we thought we were doing the right thing.”

His voice cracked again as his hands clenched at his sides. “But we failed you. I failed you. I should have come to see you myself. I should have made sure. And I’ll regret that for the rest of my life.”

His head dropped slightly, his shoulders sagging under the weight of his admission. “I thought finding Geoffrey would fix everything, would clear your name and bring you peace. But in doing that, I didn’t give you the support you needed while you were suffering. And for that, I am so, so sorry.”

His words hung in the air, heavy with sincerity and remorse. For the first time, I saw just how much the guilt had eaten away at him, how deeply his choices had cut him as well.

“Clay was going to see you the night you tried to escape,” Lucian said, his voice trembling. He paused, taking a shaky breath, his head bowing as if the weight of his next words was too much to bear. “But… we drank the water, too.”

The admission hung in the air, heavy and raw, cutting through any lingering defenses I might have had. His hands clenched at his sides as he forced himself to continue, the shame in his posture evident.

“I should have insisted on more direct contact,” he went on, his voice hoarse. “I should have demanded they bring you to the phone or let me speak to you. But I was so focused on clearing your name legally, on fighting the system that condemned you, that I failed to see how wrong it was to leave you in that place, alone and abandoned.” His voice cracked, and he exhaled shakily, as if the confession itself was tearing him apart.

“And the truth is, Scarlett,” he said, his tone dropping to barely above a whisper, “for a moment, I believed Bianca. I regret it with all my heart. I should never have placed her word—or anyone’s word—above yours.”

He lifted a hand to his face, wiping at the tears streaming down his cheeks. He looked utterly shattered, his eyes swollen and red. “Even if you forgive me, I won’t forgive myself,” he admitted, his voice cracking. “Maxwell and Clay doubted Bianca from the start. They believed in you. But me? I failed you. I betrayed you, Scarlett. And that’s something I will carry with me forever.”

As he spoke, the weight of his guilt was clear in every word, every glance, every tremble in his voice. It wasn’t just that he had wronged me—it was the realization that he had failed in ways that would haunt him for the rest of his life. Even if I stayed, I knew this guilt would linger in him, a wound that might never fully heal. Would it fester? Would it consume us?

Lucian stepped forward, his movements slow and deliberate. His face was solemn, his features etched with regret so raw it was almost difficult to meet his gaze.

“I should have sent Stasia away,” he admitted, his voice steady but soft. “I should have stood up to the people of Redcape. I should have made it clear where my heart truly lay. But I didn’t. I was weak, Scarlett.” His voice broke again, his shoulders sagging under the weight of his admission. “Of all the Valkin Alphas, I feel like a joke—a poor excuse for a leader, for a man. I don’t feel worthy of you, of your love.”

He took a deep breath, as if trying to gather the last scraps of strength he had left. “But if you’ll give me a chance,” he said, his voice full of resolve, “I’ll do whatever it takes to become the mate and husband you deserve. Just tell me what you need, Scarlett, and I will do it.”