Chapter 137: Emotional Turmoil 2

Scarlett’s POV

A silence settled between us again, but it felt different this time, as if something had shifted, a mutual understanding neither of us had expected.

“I’m sure we’ll manage, Scarlett,” Maxwell said, his tone steady yet weighted with resignation.

“None of us ever expected you would get your wolf, much less become a Valkin with magic. We never intended for you to face Garland for us. Going to the West was about asking Keith for aid and bringing you home. He’s sent us the help we need, and that’s enough. This mess is ours to fix, and we don’t want to drag you back into it.”

He paused, his voice softening. “Elsa will return tonight, and she’ll help sever the bond. I hope… I hope you find the happiness you deserve wherever you go.” There was a calm acceptance in his voice, a kind of peace he seemed to have made within himself.

I bit my lip, unable to ignore the ache in his words. “What about Clay? Is he… is he okay with it too?” I asked.

Maxwell sighed, nodding slowly. “He is. We all are, Scarlett. Let’s face it—we know you won’t be able to forgive what happened here. Asking you to simply let go… that would be too much. Not all losses can be salvaged, and I guess this is one of them.”

He searched my eyes, as though trying to capture some fragment of what we once had. Slowly, he reached out, his hand settling on my upper arm. I felt the familiar tingle of our bond, a spark of what had once been everything, but I suppressed it, keeping my face neutral.

“I didn’t start thinking of all the things I could have said or done differently until that night on the highway,” he said, his voice almost a whisper, as if speaking these words for the first time. “The night we found the spot where your scent disappeared, replaced by burnt rubber and ashes. That was when I realized you were truly gone from our lives, and there was a chance we’d never see you again. I prayed harder than I ever had, Scarlett. There was nothing I wouldn’t have given to have you back.”

Maxwell’s gaze turned distant, lost in the memories he was recounting. “The others felt the same. Clay made promises, offered anything and everything just to get the smallest lead. Lucian…” He paused, a hint of sorrow flashing in his eyes. “Lucian turned against his own people, drove them away without a second thought, all to try to find you. He lost it all for you.”

I could feel the weight of his words settling around us, heavy with regret and the pieces of a love broken beyond repair. Yet, standing there, hearing him lay everything bare, I felt a flicker of something different—a strange mix of sorrow, gratitude, and a tiny, reluctant forgiveness.

“Bottom line is… we were empty. You took everything with you, Scarlett,” Maxwell said, his voice hollow. He tried to smile, but it didn’t reach his eyes, and the sadness in his expression was deeper than any words could express.

“I wanted to see you again, to hold you and tell you all the things I’d kept bottled up. I wanted a second chance, a chance to get it right. I prayed so hard for it, but… I guess we don’t always get what we want.” He looked at me, a flicker of something soft in his gaze.

“Seeing you now, knowing you’re okay—that’s enough. Keith’s a good man, and he’ll make you happy. He’ll do right where we failed. That much I know. And I bear no grudge; in fact, I’m grateful that you even thought of helping us with Garland.”

He chuckled, but the sound was empty, tinged with pain. “A month ago, I told you to end us if that’s what it would take for us to leave you alone. I Realise now how selfish that was. It was wrong of me to ask you to carry that weight. We shouldn’t be your burden to bear, Scarlett.”

With that, he released my arm, his touch slipping away. There was a sense of finality in the gesture, as if he was drawing the line in the sand, telling me he’d accepted my departure. As if he was setting me free, even though I could see the conflict in his eyes, the unspoken ache. They were willing to let go, to give me the freedom they believed I wanted. And my heart… my heart wasn’t so willing. But I was still angry, and the thought of forgiving them, of moving forward, felt impossible.

And then there was Keith. I knew we had no true bond, and the idea of severing a connection I had with Maxwell, Clay, and Lucian—connections that ran deeper than I could put into words—felt just as painful as mourning a death. I knew what Keith had endured when his own mate was taken from him. Breaking this bond would be just as devastating, and somehow, even worse.

“I guess I’ll leave you to it, then,” Maxwell said, stepping back, his face calm, even serene. But I could feel the agony beneath that mask, feel his heart splintering as he tried to turn away, ready to walk out of my life.

Without thinking, I reached out, my hand finding his arm. He stopped and looked at me, and for a moment, there was a flicker of hope, tentative and raw, in his eyes.

I took a deep breath, letting go of the walls I’d built, allowing myself to be vulnerable, if only for a moment.

“I don’t want Keith. Not… not in that sense,” I confessed, the words slipping out quietly. It was my truth, a piece of my heart laid bare.

Maxwell’s gaze softened, but the resignation didn’t fade entirely. He looked at me as though he understood, but as if he also knew it didn’t undo the damage we’d all suffered.

The silence stretched between us, thick with unspoken words, but for the first time in a long time, it didn’t feel like a wall. It felt like a beginning—or at least, the smallest glimmer of possibility in the wreckage.

“So… you want to return to the South?” Maxwell asked, his voice soft but searching.

I didn’t answer right away because, in truth, the South had never really felt like home. It was a place of isolation, where I was kept like a secret, hidden and without connections or kin. No friends, no family—just a quiet bitterness and memories of being cast aside.

The only pull to the South was the promise of revenge. Revenge against David for everything he’d done. But as I stood there, the realization hit me: if I got David, if I satisfied that burning anger… then what? Would I spend the rest of my life alone, consumed by bitterness? Was my anger worth a lifetime of misery and emptiness?

I wasn’t that weak girl anymore. No one could hurt me the way they once had—I was stronger, sharper, and capable of defending myself. I wasn’t without choices, so why did I keep holding back? Why was I so afraid of getting hurt again, of giving up this shield of anger?

Maxwell waited, his gaze gentle but persistent, as if he was hoping I’d finally let him in. I opened my mouth, ready to speak, but a vision washed over me, gripping me like a cold hand.

The same figure on the pale horse appeared, riding closer, but this time, the scenery shifted. The warm vegetation of the South melted into something else entirely—eastern landscapes, stark and snow-covered. The rider left a path of destruction behind them, the ground scorched in their wake, yet as they neared the snow-covered terrain, something about them softened.

Still, their face remained a blur, unreadable, though I felt their gaze piercing through me, heavy with purpose. I couldn’t tell if they were male or female, but the feeling was unmistakable—they were coming for me.

I jolted, gasping for air as I blinked back into reality, the cold biting my skin. I was on the ground, half-buried in snow, with Maxwell kneeling over me, fear stark in his eyes.

“Scarlett, are you okay? Scarlett!” he called out, his voice laced with worry, but it sounded far away, muffled and distant.

My strength was slipping, ebbing away like water through my fingers. I felt Maxwell’s arms slip around me, lifting me with a gentleness I hadn’t felt in so long. And then, just as his warmth settled around me, everything went dark.