Chapter 67: Matt

Later, the four of us lay in bed together, Renee tucked between me, Aaron, and Jake. She was sound asleep, still naked, her breasts rising and falling with each breath she took. Her head rested on Jake’s bare chest, her legs spread over mine, one hand holding Aaron’s as she slept. None of the rest of us were asleep, running on adrenaline alone, but it felt fucking good. Better than good.

Perfect.

“So,” Jake said quietly, stroking Renee’s hair. “How was that for you two?”

Aaron chuckled and I smiled. That had been our first real experience together, more than just sharing Renee, but sharing each other too. And while I always figured that would never happen, I wasn’t angry that it did. It was a bizarre experience, but more than that, it had been …well, not bad at all.

“I’d do it again,” I said with a shrug, and Aaron nodded in agreement. I wasn’t exactly an open person, but if I was going to admit something, it would be to my two best friends.

“I’m really glad Renee talked to us,” Jake said. “I never would have considered it myself.”

I still wasn’t sure how far I was willing to go with either of them, but the important part was that now we had Renee back. Truly. Hopefully, this meant that there would be no more jealousy issues among us. Once upon a time, we thought that maybe individualized time had been a better idea, but we’d been wrong. Hell, we could still spend quality time with her and be together at the same time. Would this really be the solution to our issues?

I stroked my thumb absentmindedly over Renee’s leg, meeting Jake’s gaze over her body. I couldn’t read his expression, but if he was thinking the same thing I had been thinking of recently, he would know that I still hadn’t told Renee about the kiss I’d shared with Tameka. And while I regretted it then and especially now, I knew I still had to tell her about the mistake. But I was terrified too, especially now that things were suddenly so good between the four of us. Would my admission ruin everything? What if she wanted to leave me? Kick me to the curb and love Jake and Aaron instead? I couldn’t even bear to think about it, and I was glad Jake didn’t mention it in front of Aaron. He’d probably flip the fuck out on me. And I wouldn’t even blame him.

I sighed and closed my eyes, leaning my head back against a stray pillow. Tameka hadn’t been on shift this morning, but I knew she would be tomorrow, and I still had no idea what to say to her. Could I even work with her anymore?

I rubbed my hands over my face, pushing those toxic thoughts aside. I would tell her, just not now. The next time we were alone, I swore I’d tell her.

As if feeling my stress, Renee’s eyes fluttered open and she stretched, arching her back like a cat and raising her arms above her head. Her gaze fell on me, and then on Jake and Aaron.

“I’m sorry,” she whispered with a small smile. “I didn’t mean to fall asleep.

“Why not, princess?” Jake asked. “That just means we did all right, no?”

Renee giggled. God, I fucking loved that giggle. “You three did all right,” she teased, running a hand through her fiery red hair. “Now, what kind of secrets were you telling while I was asleep?”

“Secrets?” Aaron gasped, feigning shock as he touched Renee’s chin with a smile. “We have no secrets from you, baby girl.”

Not all of us, anyway, I thought. My mind was drawn back to the present as Renee rested a hand on my arm, smiling at me as though I was one of the greatest things in the world. But I wasn’t. I had betrayed her.

“I don’t know about you guys,” she said, her hand slipping down my naked chest and towards my hardening cock. “But I could go for round two…”

She didn’t have to ask twice. I was on top of her in an instant, pushing her back onto the bed as Jake’s hand sneaked to his own hardening dick while he watched us. Grinning, Aaron shifted his body until he was hovering over Renee’s face, slipping his dick into her open mouth as I rammed myself deep into her, gasping in pleasure as stars of ecstasy flashed before my vision. She was being fucked from both ends, her hips thrusting up to meet mine as Aaron fucked her mouth, making her gag. I glanced at Jake, turned on to find him pleasing himself, his eyes trained wickedly on the three of us. As Aaron and I fucked her, Renee’s hand grappled out to find Jake, and her fingers slid down his shift, taking over. I withdrew my cock for an instant and reached my hand down to play with her clit, feeling the warmth of her juices flowing down her inner thigh. I slid down until my lips kissed her pussy, and Renee moaned, grabbing hold of my hair with her free hand.

“Do you want to be fucked?” I demanded, and Renee’s hips shot up, begging for me as Aaron came in her mouth, shuddering with a groan as his seed slid down her throat and she swallowed.

“Yes,” she whimpered. “Fuck me, please. Fuck me hard.”

I pulled Renee up and flipped her over, yanking her hips until her ass was in the air, pink pussy pulsating, sensitive, begging to be fucked. Aaron moved aside so Jake could take his place, and I watched as he tangled his hand in her hair, guiding her towards his stiff dick. This time Aaron watched as I pounded into her pussy from behind, grabbing her hair from Jake’s grasp and pulling her head back until she choked, all while Jake pumped in and out of her mouth, hands tightening around her neck.

“Harder,” she moaned, gasping for breath as Jake’s cock slipped out briefly. “Fuck me harder. Make it hurt.”

I did as she asked, pulling back and then slamming back into her, controlling my movements to give her the greatest boost of pleasure. I could see Jake nearing climax, so I yanked Renee’s head back again and replaced my hand with her mouth just as he shot his load with a groan into my hand. Grinning wickedly, I used his warm come for lube around her asshole, then gently slid my cock inside of her, starting slow and then getting faster. Renee gasped with surprise as I took her ass, burying her face in the pillow before Jake yanked her head up again to kiss her, searching her mouth, holding her captive to us. Aaron went to work on her pussy, rubbing her clit as he kissed her naked body, making Renee squirm beneath us.

When she came, she came hard, collapsing onto the bed with a grunt of exhaustion and ecstasy. Her legs trembled as fluid leaked between her thighs. I leaned down to lap some of it up, and Aaron and Jake did the same. She gasped for breath, cheeks hot and red, reaching out gently to touch each of our faces. She didn’t have to say anything. This was the best sex we’d had in years. And maybe it truly was because we were finally together.

Why hadn’t we thought of this earlier?