Chapter 16
Sophia's POV
The silence in my room was deafening, broken only by the steady tick of my bedside clock and the sound of my own ragged breathing. I sat there on my bed, staring at my phone, David's name still displayed on the screen from my last unanswered call.
Think, Sophia. Think.
I forced myself to replay yesterday's events methodically, searching for clues I might have missed. The conversation at the coffee shop. My desperate pleas to Vito. His seemingly understanding response.
"You have someone you care about. This is indeed something that needs to be carefully considered."
The memory of his words sent ice through my veins. At the time, I'd thought he was being compassionate, understanding my reluctance to marry him because of my feelings for another man. But now...
Now I wondered if those words had been a threat.
My mind raced back to the drive home from the café, the paranoid feeling of being watched, the black sedan in the gas station parking lot. I'd dismissed it as stress-induced paranoia, but what if it hadn't been my imagination?
What if they'd been following me?
The phone call with David played in my memory with startling clarity. I'd been so focused on my own problems that I hadn't thought about who might be listening, who might be watching. If Vito's people had been tailing me, they would have seen me make that call. They would have noted the license plate, followed me to the gas station, listened to my conversation.
"I love you. I've loved you for five years."
David's confession echoed in my head, and suddenly the pieces fell into place with terrifying clarity.
I'd told Vito I had someone I cared about, someone I loved. Hours later, I'd been followed to a gas station where I'd had an intimate phone conversation with a man who'd declared his love for me. It wouldn't take a genius to connect those dots.
They must have identified David as the person I was in love with.
And now David was gone.
My hands started shaking as the full scope of what might have happened crashed down on me. This wasn't some random disappearance, some coincidental timing. This was deliberate. Calculated.
"You'll go to him willingly," my father had said with such certainty. "Vito was quite confident that you would change your mind."
Of course he was confident. He'd created leverage I couldn't ignore.
I jumped up from my bed, pacing frantically around my room as the implications sank in. Vito Romano had essentially taken a hostage to ensure my compliance. The man who'd sat in that café yesterday, pretending to be understanding and compassionate, had orchestrated David's disappearance to force my hand.
I have to find out what happened to David.
The thought galvanized me into action. I grabbed my purse and keys, my mind already racing ahead to what I needed to do. If David had been taken, there might be witnesses, security cameras, some trace of what had happened.
I had to start at the hospital.
New York Presbyterian was bustling with its usual controlled chaos when I arrived. Doctors in scrubs hurried between departments, nurses checked charts, and the constant background hum of medical equipment filled the corridors. I'd spent enough time here during Alfonso's hospitalization to know my way around, but today the familiar environment felt alien and threatening.
I found Dr. Martinez in the emergency department, his face drawn with the exhaustion that came from pulling a double shift.
"Sophia," he said when he saw me, his expression softening with concern. "I heard you called earlier about David. I'm sorry I couldn't be more helpful."
"Dr. Martinez, I need to know exactly what happened. When was David supposed to be here? When did you realize he wasn't coming?"
He glanced around the busy emergency room, then gestured for me to follow him to a quieter corner.
"David was scheduled for a seven AM shift," he said quietly. "When he didn't show up by seven-thirty, I tried calling him. His phone went straight to voicemail. By eight, I knew something was wrong—David's never late, never misses work without calling."
"Did you contact anyone? Security? The police?"
Dr. Martinez shook his head. "It's only been one day, Sophia. Adult missing person cases require forty-eight hours unless there's evidence of foul play. I did call his apartment building's super, but he hadn't seen David since yesterday evening."
"Yesterday evening?" My pulse quickened. "What time yesterday evening?"
"Around nine PM, according to the super. David came home from work, went up to his apartment, and that's the last anyone saw of him."
Nine PM. That was roughly an hour after my phone call with him, an hour after I'd poured out my troubles and he'd confessed his love. The timing was too precise to be coincidental.
"Dr. Martinez, has David mentioned any problems lately? Any conflicts with patients, threats, anything that might explain this?"
The older doctor's brow furrowed. "David? No, never. He's one of the most well-liked doctors here. His patients adore him, his colleagues respect him. I can't think of anyone who would want to hurt him."
I can, I thought grimly. I can think of exactly one person who would see David as a threat.
I spent the next hour making discreet inquiries around the hospital, talking to nurses who knew David, security guards who might have seen something unusual. Everyone painted the same picture—David was conscientious, reliable, kind. His absence was completely out of character.
What made it even more suspicious was how little trace he'd left behind. No one had seen him leave his apartment building. His car was still in the parking garage. His credit cards hadn't been used. It was as if he'd simply vanished into thin air.
This isn't normal, I realized with growing dread. This is too clean, too professional.
Someone had taken him. Someone with the resources and expertise to make a person disappear without leaving any obvious trail.
Someone like Vito Romano.
"You have someone you care about. This is indeed something that needs to be carefully considered."
He'd been warning me that my feelings for David would have consequences.
And now those consequences had come to pass.
With trembling hands, I pulled out my phone and scrolled through my contacts until I found the number I'd never thought I'd use. The main line for Romano Industries, the legitimate front for Vito's less savory operations.
The phone rang twice before a crisp, professional voice answered.
"Romano Industries. How may I direct your call?"
"I need to speak with Vito Romano," I said, trying to keep my voice steady.
"Mr. Romano is currently unavailable. May I take a message or direct you to someone else who can assist you?"
"No, I need to speak with him personally. It's urgent."
"I'm sorry, but Mr. Romano's schedule is completely booked. He's not accepting any new appointments at this time. If you'd like to leave your name and contact information—"
"I'm not looking for an appointment," I interrupted, "I need to speak with him today. Right now."
"Ma'am, I understand your urgency, but I'm afraid that's simply not possible. Mr. Romano's calendar is full, and he's given specific instructions not to accept any unsolicited—"
"I'm his fiancée."
The words tumbled out of my mouth before I could stop them, driven by pure desperation and the knowledge that David's life might depend on this conversation.
Silence stretched across the phone line, so long I wondered if the call had been disconnected.
"I'm sorry," the voice said finally, sounding genuinely confused. "Could you please repeat that?"
"I said I'm Vito Romano's fiancée," I repeated, my voice stronger this time. "Isabella Cohen. And I need to speak with him immediately."