Chapter 15: Connor Wallace

Even though I was a bartender, and I had access to obscene amounts of alcohol, I really wasn’t a heavy drinker—except for tonight. Getting drunk served a double purpose tonight: to numb the shock of seeing Vanessa, and to numb the pain of my aching tooth. So far, it was working brilliantly. I finished my fourth beer and reached for a fifth. How could I have been so stupid? I should’ve known that Vanessa would come for Jessica’s wedding. Maybe deep down I had known and had chosen to ignore it. Either way, I was a complete dipshit.

Seeing Vanessa again was bittersweet. She was just as beautiful as ever with her long, silky, black hair; piercing, ice-blue eyes; and naturally tanned skin. Three years ago, I’d spent a night with Vanessa. It’d been the best night of my life, and the worst. She’d told me she’d had a crush on me for almost five years. It was something I’d fantasized about hearing. And what did I do? Did I tell her I’d felt the same way? That I loved her, and she was the only woman I’d ever want a future with? Nope. I tucked my dick between my legs and took off like the pussy I was. It was the single biggest regret of my life.

As if my own guilt wasn’t punishment enough, I now had the pleasure of watching her flirt with Steven. I controlled my urge to punch him in the face. Vanessa was fair game, and the sooner I accepted that fact the easier it would be on all of us. But Steven? The resorts self-proclaimed playboy? The guy who openly slept with men and women? Sometimes at the same time? Vanessa wasn’t into that stuff. Was she?

“Well, it’s been fun,” Jessica said, standing. “But unlike the rest of you, I have to get up for work in the morning.”

Vanessa gave Jessica a hug. “Congrats, Jess,” she said. “I’ll stop by and see you tomorrow, okay?”

Jessica nodded, then gave me a hug. “Thanks, Connor. Make sure Vanessa gets back to her bungalow safely, please?” she whispered at my ear. That was just like my sister, worrying about everyone else when she should be focusing on herself. Tonight was supposed to be about her and Travis.

“Sure thing,” I said. If I had my way, I’d make sure she made it into her bed safely, too.

“So now what?” Vanessa looked at Steven as if she was waiting for him to ask her to hang out longer.

I gritted my teeth. There was no way in hell I was going to let Vanessa get mixed up with someone like Steven. “Don’t you have to help Craig and Madison close up?” I said to him.

He gave me a dirty look. “I’m sure they can handle it tonight.”

“They’re bartenders, Steve. Not club managers,” I reminded him. What did I have to say for him to get the hint that I wanted him to leave?

Steven gave Vanessa a hug—a lingering hug that resulted in his hands landing on her lower back, almost touching her ass. I clenched my hands into fists and reminded myself that I had no claim to Vanessa whatsoever. Still, the mere sight of another man’s hands on her was enough to make me see red. He whispered something I couldn’t hear, and she laughed. That solved it. Steven’s face was going to become very well acquainted with my fist. Christ, what was wrong with me? I hadn’t seen or spoken to Vanessa in years, and now I was acting like she belonged to me. I had to get a grip.

Finally, Steven released her. He narrowed his eyes at me for a second, then sauntered out of the room. I turned to Vanessa and smiled. “Would you like me to give you the grand tour of the island?”

“Thanks, but I’m kind of tired. I think I’ll just head back to my bungalow,” she said.

“I’ll walk with you.” I set my beer bottle on the table and glanced around. The room wasn’t trashed, so I didn’t feel guilty leaving it for the staff to clean up.

“That’s not necessary, Connor.”

“I’m going the same way. We’re neighbors remember?” I’d have to remember to get Jessica an extra special wedding present for putting Vanessa in the bungalow next to me.

“Right.”

I loved it when she blushed like that. I escorted her out of the club through the back door, and we walked in silence for a few moments. “I’m glad you made it for Jess’s wedding,” I said.

“Like I’d miss it,” she said. “I’m just really glad she’s finally over Mark.”

“Me too.” I shoved my hands into my pockets so I wouldn’t be tempted to touch her. The last thing I wanted to talk about was my sister, but at least we were talking, and it wasn’t awkward. “Travis is a great guy.”

“He seems like it.”

We were silent again, and I started to wonder if she’d ever thought about that night. Probably not. Hell, she probably didn’t even remember it ever happened. Why would she? For me, the sex had been unlike anything I’d ever experienced before or since. It probably wasn’t the same for her though. I’m such a fuck head. My self-loathing was at an all-time high as we came to a stop in front of her bungalow.

“Here we are,” she said.

My heart dropped, and I swallowed hard. I didn’t want to say good-bye just yet, but I was out of options on what to say or do to get her to spend more time with me. “It was really great seeing you again, Vanessa.”

“You too, Connor. Goodnight.”

She turned to walk up the steps to her bungalow when I gently grabbed her wrist. Her skin was like silk beneath my fingers. A wave of heat consumed me, and it took all I had not to yank her into my arms and fuck her right here. “I don’t even get a hug?” That’s the best I could come up with? I certainly wasn’t going to win her over with my witty banter.

Vanessa chuckled. “A hug?”

I nodded and held my breath, waiting. I fully expected her to turn me down, but instead, she put her arms around my waist. Holding her to me, I buried my face in her neck and closed my eyes. I’d forgotten how perfectly she fit me. It was like her body had been built for mine.

I gently nuzzled her neck before I kissed it. She tilted her head to the side—just barely, but it was enough to give me more access. Her rapid pulse punched against my lips, and I lightly grazed my teeth over it, causing her to shiver against me. My cock jerked with need, and I groaned softly. Outwardly, she could act as cold as she wanted, but now I knew she was still affected by my touch.

“Connor,” she whispered.

“Hmm?” I said as I continued to kiss her neck. Fuck, I needed to get her inside and naked.

“God that feels good.”

I smiled against her neck. Oh yeah, she wasn’t immune to me, and that meant I stood a chance at having her again. Maybe I could even make things right between us. “I’ve missed you, Vanessa.”

“Okay,” she said, placing her palms on my chest and pushing me away. “That’s enough. Stop.”

I took a step back and looked at her, stunned. Hadn’t she just told me it felt good? Why was she telling me to stop? “I’m sorry,” I said lamely. “I’m not sure—”

“This isn’t going to happen between us again, Connor.” She crossed her arms and pursed her lips in defiance.

Again? I bit back a smile. So, she had thought about that night. Looked like I was going to have my work cut out for me because she was wrong—it would happen again and when it did, I wouldn’t fuck it up like I had last time. “Okay,” I said. “I didn’t mean to cross the line.”

Vanessa sighed. “Let’s just focus on Jess’s wedding okay?”

“Of course.” I nodded.

“Good.” She smiled. “Thanks for walking with me.”

I watched her disappear into her bungalow, and once the door closed, I grinned. Whatever connection we’d had three years ago was still there—bubbling just under the surface, waiting to be released. All I had to do was convince Vanessa to give me another chance.