Chapter 99: HARPER

The tightness in my chest I had been trying to outrun all evening came rushing back the second Mark’s name flashed across my screen.

For a moment, everything Tyler had just said felt suspended in the air between us, unfinished and fragile. My chest ached as reality forced its way in. Nothing was simple just because he'd finally confessed to me. Not really.

I lifted the phone to eye level, angling it carefully so Tyler wouldn’t be in the frame when I answered.

Mark’s face filled the screen immediately. His lips were pressed into a thin line.

“Hey, babe.”

I forced a smile, even though guilt was already clawing at my ribs. “Hey.”

“How’re you feeling? I’m sorry I didn’t call sooner.” He paused, eyes narrowing. “Are you… outside?”

A nervous laugh slipped out before I could stop it. Shit. I should have taken the call in the car.

“Yeah. I felt a little better and thought it wouldn’t hurt to grab a mug.”

He went quiet, studying me in that way he did when he was trying to read between the lines. “Turn the phone around.”

My throat tightened. “Why?”

“I just want to make sure you’re alone.”

Out of the corner of my eye, I saw Tyler lift a hand in a small gesture before walking around the truck to climb inside the driver's seat and get out of view. I felt a strange flicker of relief that we had taken his dad’s new truck instead of his Audi. Mark would have recognized that immediately.

When I heard the door shut, I slowly spun in a circle, lifting the phone higher to show the empty parking lot.

“Happy?”

Mark sighed and ran a hand down his face. “I hope you don’t take this the wrong way. I just found out Tyler left the cabin, and then you…. I just thought maybe…”

“Hey, it’s okay,” I said quickly, though my heart felt like it was cracking under the weight of what I was hiding. “I understand.”

He nodded slowly.

“Besides,” I added. “I should be the one apologizing for not showing up at the hospital.”

“Oh yeah. That,” he said softly. “I guess there are still some things in the air we need to clear up.”

My gaze drifted to the truck where Tyler was waiting. “Yeah, I guess.”

“So you’re coming to the cabin tomorrow then?” Mark asked.

The question caught me off guard. I opened my mouth, scrambling for an answer that wouldn’t give away everything.

He chuckled suddenly. “What am I saying? You were sick. Of course asking you to come up here in this weather is a terrible idea.”

I swallowed. “Yeah. I would’ve loved to.”

“Don’t worry about it. I’ll just come over tomorrow instead. I’d rather spend the rest of winter with you than anyone else.”

“You don’t have to,” I said, panic flickering through me. “Driving back to town might be stressful, especially with everything that happened.”

“I’m fine.”

“I know, but you’ve already done so much for me. You deserve a break. We’ll talk when you’re back. In the meantime, I’ll just spend time with my cousin.”

“Oh right. Your cousin’s there.” He nodded. “Okay. Cool.”

I kept smiling even though my throat burned. “Yeah.”

“I’ll check up on you later.”

“Sure.”

I lowered the phone to end the call, but he stopped me.

“Harper.”

“Yeah?”

“You know I trust you, right?”

My chest tightened.

“I can tell you’re hiding something,” he continued quietly. “And maybe that’s why you didn’t come to see me. But I get it. Whenever you’re ready to talk, I’m here. Just be safe. And as much as I hate saying this, let Cap look after you until I’m back. I know he’s worried about you.”

I blinked rapidly, my vision blurring.

“I trust you enough to put your safety before my insecurities,” he said. “Okay?”

“Okay,” I whispered.

“I love you. See you soon.”

The screen went dark.

For a few seconds, I just stood there staring at my reflection in the glass. I felt hollow and heavy at the same time.

The truck door opened. I quickly turned away, wiping at my face before Tyler could see.

When I faced him again, he was already standing behind me, concern etched into his expression.

“‘You okay?” he asked gently, reaching for my shoulders.

I stepped back. “Yeah. I’m great.”

“Harper.”

“I’m fine, Tyler.”

He searched my face like he was trying to see through the lie. After a moment, he nodded once.

“It’s late. We should head back.”

He opened the passenger door, but I didn’t move.

“Tell your mom I’m sorry I couldn’t stay for dinner,” I said instead.

I leaned through the window to grab my gloves, but before I could pull away, Tyler caught my wrist.

“Can we talk about this when we get home?”

“We’ll talk over the phone.”

“Harper, Sam could still be at your place.”

A sob escaped before I could swallow it down. I covered my mouth quickly, embarrassed.

“I know,” I choked. “But what am I supposed to do?”

“You heard Mark,” Tyler said. “He told you to let me take care of you. Just come back with me. We’ll figure this out.”

I pulled my hand free.

“There’s nothing to figure out. I already crossed a line.”

“No, you didn’t. I brought you home because you needed help. Mark would understand.”

“Understand that I kissed you?” I shot back, tears spilling freely now. “Understand that I told you I have feelings for you? That I wanted you to have me in your room before Jacob knocked?”

“Harper,” Tyler said quietly, reaching toward my face, but I brushed him off.

“You don’t get it. You’re single. I’m not. Even if I started dating Mark for the wrong reasons, that doesn’t change the fact that I’m his girlfriend. He’s been there every time I needed someone. Even when it was you I wanted.”

Tyler’s jaw tightened.

“I should’ve at least been able to give him this much,” I continued. “Not get involved in a situationship.”

“A situationship?” he repeated, something wounded flashing in his eyes.

“I don’t know what to call it.”

“We both admitted we have feelings for each other.”

“And it’s too late,” I said. “I promised myself I’d commit to Mark, and now you decide to tell me you feel the same?”

“I’ve always felt the same.”

“Then you should’ve said something sooner!” I snapped.

He looked genuinely stunned.

“It’s like you wait until it’s convenient,” I went on, my voice shaking. “You could’ve told me anytime. You could’ve asked me out, and you know I would’ve said yes. But you didn’t. Now that I’m trying to move on and Mark’s away, you’re suddenly here confessing everything.”

The hurt in his eyes made me regret the words instantly.

“Tyler—” I breathed, trying to get a hold of my emotions. “I didn’t mean to say it like that.”

“But you did,” he said softly. “And you’re right. I had my chance.”

He cradled his injured arm unconsciously, as if it were still in a sling.

“It doesn’t change the fact that I love you,” he added, voice steady despite everything. “But knowing you feel the same and still can’t choose me? That’s worse. So maybe it’s better if we go back to how things were. Patient and temporary therapist.”

“No. I don’t want that—”

“I just need you to stay at our place tonight until we’re sure Sam is gone. I won’t be able to sleep if you walk back into that house because of me.”

I let out a broken laugh. “Fine.”

He held the door open again, and this time I got in.

The heater was running, but the warmth didn’t reach me.

We were going back to the beginning. Pretending again.

Before I could think, before fear could talk me out of it, I unbuckled my seatbelt and reached across the console. I turned the key in the ignition, cutting the engine off.

“Harper, what are you doing?”

I didn’t answer.

I leaned across the space between us and kissed him, my lips crashing into his. For a second he froze in shock before his good hand came up instinctively to cup my face.

I climbed onto his lap, the cold from outside still clinging to my coat, my hands gripping his jacket like I was afraid he’d disappear.

Because maybe he would.

Maybe this was the last time I’d let myself choose him.

But for tonight, I was done pretending.