Chapter 101: TYLER
The living room light flicked on just as I eased the door shut behind me, trying to keep the hinges from betraying us.
Mom stood there in her robe, arms folded. Dad was a step behind her, fully dressed, which somehow made everything worse.
Harper froze beside me, snow still clinging to the ends of her hair.
“Good morning,” mom said.
It did not feel like a greeting.
Dad glanced at the clock on the wall. “Six a.m. Care to explain?”
Harper immediately stepped forward. “It was my fault—”
“Don’t,” mom interrupted gently, though her eyes never left me. “Tyler took you out. Tyler is responsible.”
The words landed squarely where they were meant to.
“I’m sorry,” I said, my voice rough from the cold. “The car broke down.”
Harper’s head snapped toward me, but she stayed quiet.
“It was late,” I continued. “I didn’t want to wake you with calls. I thought we could just wait it out and call someone in the morning.”
“You waited it out where?” dad asked.
“In the truck.”
Mom’s expression shifted from anger to disbelief. “All night?”
“Yes, ma’am.”
She pressed her lips together, clearly fighting the urge to panic. “Do you understand how dangerous that was? You weren’t parked in our driveway. Anyone could have walked up to that car.”
“I know.”
“You’re injured,” she added sharply, her gaze flicking to my shoulder. “And you had Harper with you.”
Guilt pricked hard at that.
“We’re fine,” I said quickly. “Nothing happened.”
“That’s not the point,” Dad replied calmly. “Go upstairs. Warm up. You and I are going to have a talk after.”
Mom stepped aside. “I’m making hot cocoa. You both look frozen.”
We murmured quick thank-yous and slipped past them.
The house felt almost too warm after the night we’d had. Heat wrapped around us, thick and comforting. My fingers stung as blood rushed back into them. Harper stayed half a step behind me as we climbed the stairs, quiet in a way that felt heavier than before.
Only the hum of the heater and ticking clock downstairs filled the space around us. I didn’t know if it was guilt or exhaustion, but something between us had shifted, I just couldn't place what it was.
When I pushed my bedroom door open and let her step inside first, the silence followed us in.
She hovered near the door for a moment, as if unsure whether she belonged there anymore.
“Can I shower first?” she asked softly. “And maybe borrow something to wear?”
“Yeah. Of course.”
I grabbed a hoodie and sweatpants from my dresser and handed them to her. She took them carefully, our fingers brushing for half a second before she pulled away.
“Thanks.”
She disappeared into the bathroom, shutting the door softly behind her.
The quiet that followed felt awkward and suffocating.
I stood there for a moment staring at the closed door, replaying the night in fragments. The snow. Her tears. The way she had looked at me like I was both the safest place in the world and the worst mistake she’d ever made.
The shower turned on. Water rushed through the pipes. I sat down on the edge of my bed and pressed my hands over my face.
What were we now?
Not strangers. Not just friends. Not anything we could name without hurting someone.
Steam began to seep faintly under the bathroom door. I imagined her standing under the hot water, letting it thaw the cold from her bones. Letting it rinse away whatever she was feeling about last night.
I hoped it wasn’t regret.
When the shower shut off, I stood automatically. I didn’t know why. Nerves, maybe. Anticipation.
She stepped out a few minutes later wearing my hoodie and sweatpants, her damp hair hanging loose around her shoulders. The sleeves swallowed her hands. The hoodie reached almost mid-thigh.
She looked smaller somehow. Softer.
And devastatingly beautiful.
Her eyes lifted briefly before dropping again.
“Your bathroom is warmer than my entire house,” she said quietly, attempting something light.
I gave a faint smile. “Occupational hazard of living with my mother.”
She nodded, then moved to sit on the far corner of my bed, leaving a careful distance between us. The space felt intentional. Protective.
I leaned back against my desk, crossing my arms loosely.
“We don’t have to pretend like last night didn’t happen,” I said gently.
Her shoulders tensed.
“I’m not pretending,” she replied. “I just don’t know what to say.”
“That’s fair.”
Silence settled again, but this one felt different. Not frozen. Just uncertain.
I pushed off the desk and moved closer, sitting across from her on the bed but leaving enough space so she wouldn’t feel cornered.
“Harper.”
She looked up.
“I meant everything I said in the car.”
Her throat moved as she swallowed.
“I know,” she whispered.
“I’m not taking it back. I’m not embarrassed. I’m not wishing I’d done anything differently.” I held her gaze so she could see that I wasn’t wavering. “I meant it when I said I’ll wait.”
She blinked.
“You don’t owe me a decision today. Or tomorrow. If you decide you need to end things with Mark before anything can happen between us, then that’s what you do. And if you decide you want to stay with him…” My voice nearly faltered, but I kept it even. “Then I’ll deal with that too.”
Her fingers twisted in the fabric of my hoodie.
“You make it sound so simple.”
“It’s not,” I admitted. “It’s the hardest thing I’ve ever done. But I’d rather do it right than rush you into something that’ll hurt you.”
Her eyes finally met mine fully.
“There’s nothing to feel awkward about,” I continued. “Last night didn’t make you desperate. It didn’t make you weak. It made you honest.”
Color crept into her cheeks.
“And for the record,” I added, allowing a softer note into my voice, “I’ve never been so tempted in my life.”
That got her attention. Her lips parted slightly.
“You may not be my first kiss,” I said carefully, “but you’re the best one I’ve ever had. By a long shot.”
Her face flushed deeper, and she looked down quickly, hiding a small, shy smile that tugged at the corner of her mouth.
“Yeah, right” she murmured.
“I’m serious.”
“I can’t even look at you right now.”
“That’s unfortunate,” I replied lightly. “Because I’ve been looking at you all morning.”
She laughed under her breath, the sound soft and embarrassed. Her shoulders eased a little
.
“I don’t deserve you,” she said after a moment.
“That’s not how this works,” I answered
immediately. “This isn’t a moral scoreboard. We both messed up. We both feel something. The only difference is I’m single.”
She exhaled slowly.
“I don’t want to hurt him.”
“I know.”
“And I don’t want to lose you.”
The words landed heavier than anything else she’d said.
“You won’t,” I said. “Even if this takes time. Even if it’s messy. I’m not disappearing.”
Her eyes shimmered slightly, but she blinked it back. “I should go downstairs before your mom thinks we’re up to no good again.”
“Probably a good idea.”
She stood, adjusting the sleeves of the hoodie, and hesitated for a second before stepping closer.
“Thank you,” she said quietly. “For stopping me. For not letting me make it worse.”
I reached out and brushed a strand of damp hair away from her face.
“I’ll always stop you if it means protecting you from yourself.”
Her breath caught.
Then she nodded once and slipped past me, leaving the faint scent of my soap behind. When the door closed, I released the breath I hadn’t realized I was holding.
I grabbed my phone and stepped out onto the balcony, the early morning air biting against my skin. The sky was pale gray, the world still quiet.
Peter answered on the third ring.
“Why’re you calling me at six in the morning?” he groaned.
“You’re awake.”
“Barely. What happened?”
I leaned against the railing. “We slept in the truck.”
Silence.
Then a sharp laugh. “You what?”
“The car didn’t actually break down,” I admitted. “I just told my parents that.”
“Oh my God. You two finally did it and got stranded?”
“No.”
He paused. “No?”
“No.”
Another beat of silence, longer this time.
“Tyler,” he said slowly, “you’re telling me you had her alone in a car all night, after everything that’s been going on, and you didn’t…”
“No.”
He let out a disbelieving whistle. “I never knew you had that kind of self control. Should I start calling you Saint Tyler?”
“Shut up.”
“I’m serious. I thought you were one emotional confession away from losing your mind.”
“I almost did,” I muttered.
That quieted him.
“So what happened?”
I stared out at the frost clinging to the rooftops across the street.
“She tried to convince herself she wanted it,” I said finally. “I could tell. And I couldn’t let her wake up hating herself. Or me.”
Peter didn’t joke this time.
“Damn,” he said softly.
“Yeah.”
He was quiet for a moment before asking, “Are you sure that was a smart move?”
“It was the right move.”
“That’s not what I asked.”
I closed my eyes briefly.
“If I had let it happen, she would’ve spiraled. And then she would’ve run straight back to Mark to fix the guilt. I’m not risking that.”
“And now?”
I hesitated.
Peter’s voice dropped. “Aren’t you scared she might still choose him? They're literally already in a relationship.”
The question hit deeper than I'd like to admit. Was I scared?
Of course I was.
Mark was stable. Present. Safe. He had shown up when I hadn’t. He had said all the right things.
And I had waited too long
.
My fingers tightened around my phone.
“More than you’ll ever know,” I admitted quietly.
The words hung there between us, heavier than the cold air.
Peter didn’t laugh this time.
“Then I guess you’d better hope she sees what you did last night for what it was.”
“I’m not doing it so she’ll choose me.”
“I know,” he said. “That’s the problem.”