Chapter 36: Chapter Thirty-Five
Jenny arrived around four, rousing me from a fitful nap on the couch. “Get your coat on. I’m taking you out for an early dinner. We’ll be back in time to watch the suppertime news show.” When I hesitated, she pulled my red wool jacket from the hallway coat rack. “And brush your hair or something first, okay?”
I took the hint and made a quick stop in the washroom before slipping into my jacket. In the car, I asked, “Where are we going?”
She named a burger restaurant on Bank Street. “You need some protein.” In the restaurant, we took a booth and placed our orders—two burgers with the works. The waitress asked what I wanted to drink. “Water’s fine.” Jenny stuck with water too. We usually had beers to go with this kind of meal, but that didn’t seem right tonight.
She sipped her water. “I know how scary this is for you. And I do feel terrible that I took the girls to that movie.”
I waved her comment away. What was the point?
The waitress brought our burgers and placed them in front of us. Big, meaty patties with tomatoes and pickles, and fries on the side. I stared at mine, my throat thick. How could I eat? I cut the burger in two, picked up half in both hands, and leaned forward, letting juice drip onto the plate while I bit off one end. I forced myself to chew. Usually these burgers are delicious, but this time I couldn’t taste anything. I choked the bite down, following it with water. Looking at what was left on the plate, I pushed it away. “This was a good idea, but I just can’t manage it.”
Jenny cut off a quarter of the burger and put it on a side plate, added five french fries, and handed it to me. “Here, just try to get through this much.”
I sighed. “All right, I’ll try.” I picked up one of the fries and bit off half. “It already seems like Maddy’s been gone forever. I keep wondering what she’s doing, what’s happening to her. I’m almost afraid to think about it. I hope she’s eating…”
Jenny nodded. “I know. But starving yourself will not feed her.” She signaled the waiter for our bill and a to-go container. When he brought them, she gave him her credit card and packed the rest of my burger into the container. “We’ll take this home, and maybe you’ll feel like eating it later.”
I made a face, but she ignored me. We collected our coats and went out to her car.
We got back to my house and were settled in front of the TV in time for the local news at six. After a few short items, they moved to the “journal” section of the broadcast.
A still photo of Maddy came on screen, while an announcer introduced the segment. “Twelve-year-old Madison Koss was last seen at home in the Glebe area around 4:30 p.m. this past Monday, November sixth. She’s five feet two inches tall, weighs about ninety-five pounds, and has blue eyes and blonde hair that she wears in a ponytail. Ottawa Police released a bulletin on Tuesday asking for anyone with information to come forward. Today police held another press conference to step up appeals for help in finding her.”
The camera switched to Staff Sergeant Bailey from Missing Persons. He stood at a podium, with Maddy’s poster displayed on the front.
“This is a vulnerable twelve-year-old girl,” he was saying. “Every hour that passes makes us more concerned about her safety. We think she may be with someone, as we don’t believe she has the resources to be on her own for so long. Someone may think they’re helping her by harboring her.”
The broadcast switched to the video I’d recorded that morning. They froze the first frame while an announcer introduced it, then played the clip. I clutched Jenny’s hand; it was like watching a stranger. The program returned to Sergeant Bailey answering a few questions from reporters, and the segment was over.
We had barely turned the TV off when Amy phoned. “Tom and I just watched the news. Your video was very good.” She paused. “It must have been hard for you to record. And to watch.”
I blinked back tears. “I’m all right—Jenny’s here. I was glad to get it out there. I just hope it has some effect.”
“That clip would make anyone’s heart hurt.”
My heart was hurting, that was for sure. Along with the rest of me—I arched my shoulders against the dull ache seeping through my bones, and the dread that was filling my mind.
Amy added, “Abel called me this afternoon—he’s coming out tonight with some more friends. We’ll get a lot more posters put up.”
My stomach clenched. I can’t face leaving this couch.
She continued, “But you don’t need to come along this time—you must be exhausted. You should take a night off. We can handle it.”
She was telling me to stay home. But could I? Was I a bad mother if I didn’t force myself to go with them?
Just then Jenny brought a blanket and tucked it over my knees. That simple gesture decided me. “Thanks, Amy. I think I will stay in—I don’t have any more energy tonight.”
Jenny, overhearing this, stared at me. “You weren’t considering going out again, were you?”
I sighed. “I feel like I should. How can I take a night off while Maddy’s still missing?”
“You need to conserve your energy. There’s nothing more you can do tonight.”
“The posters—”
“They’re important, but you have friends to work on that for you.”
****
Maddy finished putting away the things Daniel had bought her, and joined him in the kitchen. He’d set the table and was busy at the stove. She didn’t wait for him to tell her where to sit. She knew her spot by now, the one next to the window, facing the hallway.
They were having hot dogs for supper. She watched him spear them from the pot he’d heated them in; buns were already on the plates. Mustard, ketchup, and relish were on the table. He gave her two dogs along with some chips and poured milk into her glass.
They ate in silence. Then Daniel set aside his second hot dog and looked at her. His thumb was tapping against the table, but he didn’t seem aware of it. “I said we’d talk some more today about going out west.”
Maddy dropped the chip she was about to eat. He hadn’t mentioned the trip all day, and she’d hoped he’d forgotten about it.
He continued. “I was thinking we’d leave Saturday. We can pack up tomorrow. There’s not a lot we need to take.”
Maddy’s mouth fell open, and her stomach fluttered. She didn’t know what to say. She hadn’t thought he wanted to leave so soon.
He nodded. “There could be snow out west any time. We want to be home before winter hits, and you’ll be glad to get to the farm.”
He was acting like she remembered the farm—but she didn’t. She wasn’t convinced she was Hannah, but even if she was, Hannah was a baby when she disappeared. She wouldn’t remember anything.
After supper they played cards again. It was kind of fun—she was getting better at it, and she almost won twice. Daniel was being nice. But the idea of going on a trip with him made her uneasy.
Upstairs later, she took another look at the box of Superior Preference. Changing her hair color still felt like a drastic step, but maybe she’d think about it again in the morning.
Lying in bed, she watched the moon shining in through the bare trees.
His farm must be far away—he’d mentioned being “on the road” for several days. And he said Alberta, and out west. She knew Alberta was one of the prairie provinces, and it had mountains. She wasn’t really sure of much else, though.
She told herself a trip might be fun. She’d never been on a farm, and the animals sounded interesting. But the idea of leaving unsettled her.
Susan was the only mom Maddy had ever known. As long as they were in the same city, she could still feel the connection. Even if she was here with Daniel instead of at home—she was just taking a break.
Leaving the city seemed like a much bigger step.
Maddy swiped at the tears leaking down her cheek. She didn’t know what to think. Did she belong with Daniel, or with her mom?
If only they’d never had the DNA test. Everything was simpler before.
****
Jenny brought me a mug of tea, and I leaned back against a cushion, my feet curled underneath me on the couch. I tried to think positive thoughts, imagining sunny pictures of Maddy home again—comfortably ensconced in the kitchen, or petting Oscar, or...then a shadow flitted across my fantasy as a darker image filled my mind. It was Maddy, saying, “But that test said you’re not my mother.”
I gripped Jenny’s arm. “When Maddy gets back, I have to have an explanation for how that DNA test could be so wrong. I need a solution, an answer. Otherwise—”
She finished the sentence for me. “Otherwise, she might run away again.”
The blunt statement hurt, but it only put my fear into words. “I can’t...she needs to know she is my daughter.”
Jenny gave me another hug. We were still standing in the hallway. “Of course she does. And you need an answer too.”
“I’ve been leaving messages for Aisha—they must have made an error somewhere. But she seems to be avoiding me. She doesn’t want to hear me say they got it wrong.”
“So…” Jenny hesitated before continuing. “What if they didn’t get it wrong?”
I stared at her. “What do you mean?”
“Is there any way the test could be right?”
“Jenny, you said yourself—you were there when she was born. You know I’m her mother! How can a test that says I’m not her mother be right?”
“I don’t know...but what if there’s some actual explanation?”
That same question had briefly popped into my mind after I’d sat with the results for a bit, but I’d pushed it aside as nonsensical. Now on an impulse, I got up and went into my little office, coming back with my laptop.
“Okay. Let’s see what the internet has to say on that question.” How stupid of me, that I hadn’t done this sooner! But I’d been focused first on telling Maddy and then on dealing with her disappearance. Research had not been at the top of my mind.
I googled “mother’s DNA doesn’t match child.”
And dozens of entries popped up.
The first one led me to a woman in the state of Washington. In 2002 she applied for enforcement of child support payments from her ex-husband for their three children. DNA tests of the whole family were required to prove his paternity. The test showed that he was indeed their father—but that she was not their mother. She was accused of fraudulently receiving welfare payments for someone else’s children, or of running a surrogacy scam. She almost had her children removed by child welfare authorities. Nobody believed her, because everyone involved considered DNA tests to be infallible. When she was taken to court, she had trouble finding a lawyer, because no lawyer wanted to challenge the accuracy of a DNA test.
Finally a lawyer stepped forward to take her case. He knew about another woman, this one in Boston, who had had a similar experience. She needed a kidney donor; her children were tested to see if they could be donors, and in the process she was told that a DNA comparison showed she was not their mother.
Other entries led me further through these women’s stories, and to other articles on a similar theme. And the sources seemed reliable.
By now Jenny had refilled our tea and was reading along with me. I could well understand the shock these women had experienced on receiving those test results—the same shock I’d been dealing with. Or not dealing with.
We read further. There was an explanation—a strange one, but an explanation. Maybe the same could be true for me. If—when!—we got Maddy home, this might cut through the confusion.
I turned to Jenny. “I think I’d better double-check these sources.” She nodded. But further exploration appeared to substantiate the reports.
“Now I definitely have to talk to Aisha.” I reached for my cellphone and dialed her number. This time, amazingly, she answered. I launched into my spiel. “Aisha, it’s Susan. I’ve been doing some research. I may have found an explanation for how your test could say that I’m not Maddy’s mother, when I know for sure that I am.”
She sighed. “Susan, I told you, I’ve reviewed the procedures that were followed in your case. There was no error in handling your samples, and we stand by our results.”
I squared my shoulders. Jenny was leaning forward, encouraging me. “I know that. But there’s a possible explanation. There are at least two well-known cases of women who were found to have different DNA from their children.”
Aisha made a scoffing sound. “Where did you find this? On the internet?”
I wasn’t intimidated. “I started with a Google search, yes. But that led me to some reports in medical journals and also in the New York Times and the Independent, which don’t normally carry stories without fact checking.”
“So what did they say?”
I recounted what I had found. After a short hesitation, she agreed to check it out.
Later that evening, she called me back. “Susan, what you’re talking about is a rare occurrence; it’s far-fetched to think it could apply in your case. But if you’re willing to pay for retesting, we’ll do it. Come in tomorrow, and we’ll take some more samples.”
I sighed in relief. “Fine. I’ll be in early in the morning.”
****
My feeling of relief didn’t last long. As I brushed my teeth and got ready for bed, I was overcome by the dread I’d been fighting since Maddy disappeared. It was now over three days that she’d been gone.
I couldn’t imagine what she was going through. I pushed away the flickering thoughts—I couldn’t stand the idea of Maddy in pain, or injured. Or abused. I refused to think about it.
But that didn’t mean she was okay.
On impulse, I went down the hall to her room and leaned in, scanning the shadows cast by the hallway light. I was suddenly struck by how different the room looked from the way Maddy usually kept it.
My frantic cleaning efforts had imposed order—but it was my order. Not hers.
I’d thought I was tidying the room for her benefit, but maybe I was wrong. Maybe this was like a lot of the things Maddy and I fought about, when she’d want to do things one way and I insisted on a different way. My way.
Had I been quashing her efforts to find a way of her own?
Swallowing a sob, I crawled into her bed and pulled her comforter over me.