Chapter 18: Chapter Seventeen
On Sunday morning I had no trouble finding street parking. I grabbed my purse and headed toward Genetic Test Services, the lab where we’d submitted our DNA samples. Though the sky overhead was blue and the sun was shining, the weather had shifted. A chill breeze had sprung up—a sudden change from yesterday’s warmth—and the smell of snow was in the air.
When Aisha phoned the night before, I thought she was calling to give me the DNA results, but she said no, they were still completing the tests. She said she had a few questions, though, that she’d like to discuss face-to-face, and asked if I could meet with her today.
I wondered why she wanted a face-to-face meeting—I’d thought they said the results would be made available online. And I didn’t know why she’d want to see me on a Sunday. But if she needed anything from me to speed up the process, I was eager to provide it.
The low-rise office building was locked, but she had told me to knock on the door and she’d let me in. This would be my first time meeting her in person; she hadn’t been there when we came to submit our samples. She turned out to be a smallish, slim woman with dark hair pulled back in a ponytail, wearing a pair of loose cream-colored pants and a blue top.
She unlocked the door to let me in, locking it again once I was inside. She smiled politely and held out her hand in greeting. “Susan, I’m Aisha. Thank you for coming in this morning.” She had a soft voice but a confident manner.
We were in the building’s lobby, passing an empty security desk in front of a bank of elevators. “If you don’t mind, we’ll take the stairs,” she said. “It’s just one floor up.” The stairway was utilitarian—unadorned cement—but the corridor upstairs was carpeted, and the walls were a quiet gray. She led me down a hall to a small meeting room furnished with a round table, four plastic chairs, and a whiteboard. The window overlooked a parking lot.
We each took a chair. Aisha didn’t offer me any refreshment, though I would have welcomed something; I should have picked up a coffee on my way. She had no papers or files with her, which surprised me. After a moment’s silence, I decided to get things rolling. “You said you don’t have the results yet—so why did you want to see me?”
She appeared to hesitate. “You’re Abel’s friend, so I thought I should talk to you about this in person.”
I raised my eyebrows, and she continued. “We haven’t fully finished the analysis, but we do have a conclusion about the comparison between you and Madison.”
I brightened. “Great!” This would resolve the whole dispute with Daniel right now.
Aisha frowned. “I should review a few basics first, about how DNA testing works.”
I waited. Okay.
She sat back. “We inherit our DNA from our parents—half from our mother and half from our father. We can’t predict exactly which genes will be passed down to a child from each parent. And the combination from a given pair of parents is different for each of their offspring.”
I nodded. Nothing new here.
She continued. “As humans, all of us share nearly identical DNA. But there are specific genetic markers where individual differences appear. Those are what we examine in relationship testing.”
I smiled. “Yes, I get that.”
Aisha carried on. “What we look for at those markers are correspondences between two individuals. There should be high correspondences between a parent and a child.”
“Right.”
“Well.” I could see her drawing in her breath, and she stared directly at me. “When we compare your DNA with Madison’s, we...don’t see the level of correspondence we’d expect between mother and daughter. In fact...the test excludes that possibility.”
I thought I must have misheard. I shook my head as if to empty my ears.
“What did you say?” My chest and shoulders suddenly clenched tight.
Aisha cleared her throat. “The test shows that...you can’t be Madison’s biological mother.”
I stared at her blankly, blood pounding at my temples. “That makes no sense. I am her mother.”
She simply stared at me, her hands clasped in front of her.
“That test is wrong,” I insisted.
She shook her head. “We’ve double-checked the result.”
My disbelief suddenly turned to indignation. I jumped from my chair, knocking it over behind me, and leaned over the table. “That’s not possible! You must have mixed up the samples—”
“No.” Aisha stared at me, shaking her head. “We took care to record each person’s identity when we collected the samples, and we have followed chain-of-custody protocols throughout. We have not mixed up the samples. The test is accurate.”
I swallowed, my mouth dry and my heart pounding. My back to the window, I glared at her. Finally I drew in a deep breath and returned to my chair. I had to make clear to her—this was unquestionably a mistake.
“Listen,” I said, doing my best to speak calmly, “there is no possibility that that result is accurate. I gave birth to Maddy, right here at the Civic Hospital. I have all the records to prove it.”
She said nothing, her expression unchanged.
I glowered. “There’s simply no question. She’s my child and always has been!”
Aisha leaned forward. “Susan. All I can say is your DNA and Madison’s do not show that you are her mother. You do share some correspondences, but not enough to show parentage.”
With great effort, I kept myself from shrieking. I was shattered. This was completely impossible. “So what does the test show about Daniel? Please tell me it at least proves him wrong?”
Aisha shook her head. “We haven’t made that determination yet.”
“What?” I was aghast.
“It’s harder to draw conclusions when we only have DNA from one grandparent. When we are trying to determine correspondences with a child two generations down, testing is more difficult. It can be inconclusive.”
I gritted my teeth. “I can’t believe this. You’re telling me that this testing could end up concluding that Daniel Kazan is Maddy’s grandfather?”
“We haven’t yet ruled that out.”
I glared at her. “So what happens now?”
“Nothing at the moment. We’ll complete our report in a couple of days. Then we’ll send you and Mr. Kazan a notice to access your reports online. How the two of you proceed with the results will be up to you.”
“So he’ll get the report as well?”
“Yes, you specified that on the order, that the results would be reported to each adult participant.”
Back out on the street, the sun was still shining, but to me the day had closed in. I stumbled toward the spot where I’d parked my car but stopped before I reached it. I couldn’t possibly drive—I was too distraught.
I continued down the sidewalk, passing a small coffee shop. Turning abruptly, I pushed open the door. A young couple was sitting at a far table, but no one was ahead of me at the counter, so I ordered a latte. I had to fumble for my wallet. I found an empty table in a corner by a window and sat down, wrapping my hands around the cup.
What could this mean?
A mood of despair fell over me. Daniel threatened to disrupt our lives—the life that Maddy and I had together—but I’d been sure that the DNA test would destroy his ridiculous claim.
Instead, it was about to make things worse.
If Daniel saw a test result that said I wasn’t Maddy’s mother, there was no way he would stay away from us. He’d be sure to proclaim the test result. He’d tell Maddy I wasn’t her mother. I had to prepare her.
Though heaven knew what I’d tell her, or how I could explain it.
****
Maddy watched her mom in the driver’s seat beside her as they pulled onto their street. They had taken Emma with them to the museum for the afternoon and had now dropped her off. She and Emma thought they lived close together, since their houses were just across the park from each other and they could run it in two minutes. But the driving route was farther, around several blocks.
When they got to their house, her mom stopped the car but didn’t get out. “Let’s sit here and talk for a minute,” she said. Maddy glanced at her, wondering what was going on. Her mom had seemed distracted all afternoon, and now she looked tense, staring out the window. “I was downtown this morning and got a preview of the results of our DNA test.”
Maddy hadn’t thought much about the test since they gave the samples. Her mom had wanted the test and said it would solve their problems with Daniel.
Her mom fiddled with her key chain. “Well, there’s a part of the test that’s quite upsetting. I don’t understand it. But I have to tell you about it.” Maddy could see her mom draw in her breath, as if she had to force herself to talk.
Maddy’s stomach tightened. Something about this was making her nervous. “What is it?” she asked.
Her mom’s voice sounded hoarse. “The test doesn’t make sense. But what it supposedly says is...your DNA and my DNA don’t match up.”
Maddy was puzzled. “What do you mean?”
“Somehow, the test says that we aren’t mother and daughter.”
Maddy’s eyes widened. “How can that be?”
Mom frowned and bit her lip. “It’s impossible. You were my very own baby. As you know!”
Maddy stared at her mom. “But now DNA says I’m not?”
“Apparently.”
Maddy blinked back sudden tears. “So what happened? Am I not your child?” She often thought her mom was a pain, but she hadn’t expected anything like this.
Her mom’s eyes flashed. “Yes, you are! The test is wrong! You’re my child, no question.”
Maddy shivered. “Maybe babies got mixed up in the hospital. I saw a movie where that happened.”
Mom stared. “I didn’t even think of that. But there’s no way. I had ‘rooming in.’ You stayed with me in my room the entire time in the hospital. You never left my side.”
“Unless...maybe someone switched me when you were asleep.”
Her mom snorted. “Do you think I wouldn’t have noticed a different baby? I had your face memorized from the minute you were born. You were my miracle. Nobody switched you.”
Maddy rubbed her hand across her face; an empty feeling was filling her chest. She didn’t know what to make of all this. “What about Daniel? What does his test say?”
“We don’t know yet. They didn’t tell me. They say it’s more complicated testing for a possible grandfather.”
“But he’s not my grandfather.”
“Of course not. But he thinks he is. That’s what the test is supposed to disprove...though after these results, I’m not sure I’ll believe those either.”
Maddy closed her eyes and leaned her head against the car window. The cold glass felt good on her hot forehead.
****
Maddy went up to her room and threw herself on her bed, her thoughts swirling. How could a DNA test say she wasn’t her mom’s kid?
Other thoughts came creeping into her head. Thoughts she couldn’t say out loud. What if it wasn’t a mistake? Maybe the test was right?
All of this was hard to think about. How could she know for sure whether what her mom had always told her was right?
At school they were told to be critical thinkers. Start with the facts. Don’t make assumptions. Don’t just go along with what everyone thinks.
What facts do I know?
One. I’ve always lived with Mom. Since my earliest memories.
Two. I don’t remember back to when I was a baby. Does anyone?
She remembered an early birthday cake and being excited about getting a kitten. Oscar. That must have been her third birthday.
So what I know from before is only what someone’s told me.
Her real grandpa, her mom’s dad, had told her about visiting them both in the hospital when she was born.
Tears filled Maddy’s eyes. She could still feel the empty space his death had left in her life. I can’t ask him anything now.
Daniel said she was his granddaughter—his daughter’s baby, not Mom’s. That was pretty unbelievable. But could it be true?
Suddenly her legs were hot, not cold, and she tossed her duvet aside. Everything solid she normally counted on was up for question. Her stomach was churning. She was going to throw up. She leapt off the bed and stumbled down the dark hall to the bathroom and leaned over the toilet.
And waited. Finally, after nothing happened, she sat on the floor, arms around her knees and her back against the tub.
She couldn’t stop feeling like she suddenly had nothing to hold on to.