Chapter 36: CHAPTER 36
"I don't like this," Theodore concluded. He witnessed me give Cross his jersey, his gaze flickering between the shirt and me as though these two things should not go together.
"He just lent it to me yesterday after dumping water on me," I said flatly. I shoved the shirt onto Cross's chest with more force than necessary.
"Nope. Nope." Theodore shook his head, as if my explanation further proved his point. "This already sounds like a toxic relationship. Stay away from her, you manwhore. We all agreed Clara was off limits." Theodore wrapped a protective arm around my shoulder.
"You agreed on what?" I squeaked. I wasn't aware of any secret agreement between them.
"We already talked about this." Cross regarded him in a way that said this conversation was over.
"And I said no!"
"I told you out of courtesy, not for permission."
"When's the last time you screwed someone?" Theodore demanded, grilling him like he was the dirtiest scum of the earth.
David laughed. "That's not a game you want to play right now, Theo."
"Longer than you," Cross clipped. "Keep going and I’ll tell Clara about the two girls you slept with last week"
Theodore's grip on my shoulder tightened. His eyes flashed with horror before he crushed me to his chest, effectively hiding my face as he mouthed something to Cross behind my head.
"Hey! I wanna know!" I cried, trying to wriggle free. Theodore kept me in place, my cries falling on deaf ears. He didn't move when I hit him and only pulled back after whatever agreement they made.
"Fine. This is a tentative allowance!" he negotiated. "One chance! You do even the shade, the smudge of a thing, and I’m cutting it off!"
"Why can't I know who you slept with? I feel left out!" I cried.
Theodore looked to the sky, the rays of light falling upon the reluctant crease on his forehead. "Because I already know what you're going to say, and you'll be disappointed in me..."
I paused. There was only one vice of his that really ticked me off. "Please tell me you didn't sleep with one of Cross's obsessed lovers."
Theodore closed his eyes, like not seeing me would make it go away. He had a weird kink for sleeping with girls still heartbroken over another guy.
According to him, he loved the passionate and angry sex. It was exhilarating for him, and he could leave in peace knowing he wasn't the one who caused the hurt in the first place.
"Tell me the name of at least one of them!" I insisted.
"One of them gave me the cookie and now wants to close the jar," he deflected, looking quite upset.
"Can you blame her? She was with that one, and look where it landed her." Cross's posture went rigid, clearly not liking where this conversation was going. "I’m glad she did something marvelous called learning from your mistakes. You guys should try that every once in a while."
"It's not fair. I was fine being the rebound guy."
Theodore's expression softened with the glow of a sweet memory. "She would cry her little heart out and I would listen. Then we had great sex. Now she wants to do the full-on relationship stuff." His lips curled with aversion. You would think he was offered expired food with that face.
Teddy was a different kind of danger from Cross. Girls were drawn to Cross because he was a challenge, detached and flirtatious. Did he like you, or did he not?
The push and pull made him irresistible, a conundrum they wanted to solve. He made you feel special, then disappeared. The moment he pulled away, they tried harder to prove they were worthy of his attention, only driving him further out of reach.
A toxic mess, really.
Theodore, on the other hand, was very romantic. Often times this kink of his would backfire and in the end they fixated on him instead. I hated it. It only compounded these girls' pain, even if they were wrong for using him as rebound in the first place.
"You might as well date her then," I teased. "You talk to her everyday, listen to her problems, and have sex. Sounds like a relationship to me."
"I couldn't agree more," David said. "And while you're at it just propose and get married. Like CJ said, you're already doing half the work."
Theodore turned green, bowling over as though the idea itself were enough to induce vomit. The three of us laughed at his expense.
"I couldn't picture getting married before, but I can now," Cross said thoughtfully.
I gave him a look. "Since when?"
He winked. "Since you."
I rolled my eyes while Theodore shivered in disgust. "Why aren't you helping me stop this?!" he fumed at David.
David shrugged. "It's inevitable. She left me yesterday to be his partner."
"No, tell the whole story!" I protested. "I did it for Kelly, not to be with him."
"I’m sure you did."
"I just don't understand why you're picking him," Theodore whined, drawing my attention back to him. "Don't you love me?"
"That's enough for hugs today." Cross interjected. He tried to drag me away from Theodore's embrace, but the honey-eyed boy held tightly. I felt stuck in a game of tug-a-war.
"Tell him you love me," Cross demanded.
I groaned. Here we go again. They've played this game before-competing for affection when really it was about outdoing each other. Usually it was a joke, but today they seemed more serious.
"Of course I love you," I said, rubbing his cheek. "You're the friend that never stops being annoying."
Cross's expression went flat. Theodore childishly stuck his tongue out, then pouted, giving me his honeyed puppy eyes. "CJ, tell him you love me."
"Teddy, you know I love you," I said, ruffling his hair. He leaned down and I kissed his nose. "You're like an adorable little brother who never listens and always gets into trouble."
At this Cross smiled victoriously. "It's easier to escape the friend-zone than it is the brother-zone."
And then we all laughed. It was worse when they fake-fought over girls who had no idea they were being toyed with girls who believed both of them were serious, only to be crushed when the boys "miraculously" became best friends again. Then came the script: no girl could ever come between their years of brotherhood. Bros first.