Chapter 17: The Wrong Reaction
The night hung heavy and sharp, the cold biting through Aria’s coat as she stood at the end of Xander’s long, stone driveway. One hand rested over her stomach, protective and unsure, while the other clutched a white envelope, thin in weight but heavy with truth. The house before her loomed tall and dark, its windows unlit, except for one: the study. A soft gold glow spilled out, quiet and still.
She felt like that house—grand on the outside, but silent inside.
The word had been stuck in her mind for days, circling her thoughts like a storm she couldn’t escape.
Pregnant.
At first, it had felt unreal. Then terrifying. Now, it just hurts. The kind of ache that sits behind your ribs and doesn’t let go.
She wasn’t here for pity or help. She was here because he deserved to know.
Drawing in a breath that rattled in her chest, she walked up to the front door and knocked. The sound was soft, nearly drowned by the wind, but it echoed loudly in her ears.
The door opened seconds later. Xander stood there, his shirt sleeves rolled to the elbows, face unreadable. His eyes flicked over her, taking her in like she was a stranger.
"Aria," he said, his tone flat. "Is something wrong?"
She nodded slightly. “Can we talk? Outside.”
He didn’t argue. Just stepped onto the porch and let the door close behind him.
They stood beneath the porch light, the cold wind tugging at her coat. The silence between them wasn’t unfamiliar, but tonight it felt sharper, meaner.
“I won’t take long,” she said. Her voice felt steady, but her hands trembled as she held out the envelope.
Xander took it without a word and opened it. His eyes moved over the paper. Once. Then again, slower.
When he looked up, his face was unreadable. “You’re pregnant.”
It wasn’t a question.
“Yes,” she said. “And it’s yours.”
He said nothing. Just folded the paper neatly and slid it back into the envelope. His gaze drifted beyond her, to the dark trees lining the property.
“I’ll take care of it,” he said. “Medical costs. A place to stay. Whatever you need.”
Aria flinched. Not visibly—but inside, something cracked.
“That’s not why I’m here, Xander.”
His brows drew slightly. “Then why?”
“I thought you might care.”
For a moment, just one, his expression shifted. Something flickered behind his eyes. But then it was gone.
He turned away, hands gripping the porch railing. “Aria, we agreed to keep things simple. Quiet. I never—”
She cut him off with a bitter laugh. “You never promised me anything. I know. But I still hoped.”
The tears pricked, but she refused to let them fall.
“I’m carrying your child,” she whispered. “And you’re standing there like it’s an inconvenience.”
Still, he said nothing.
She wrapped her arms around herself and took a step back, trying to hold in everything threatening to spill out.
“You don’t have to worry about anything,” she said, her voice barely above a breath. “I just thought you had the right to know.”
He turned toward her, something in his stance shifting. “Aria, wait—”
But she was already moving down the steps. Her back was straight. Her heart was crumbling.
She didn’t stop until she reached the old sycamore near the end of the path. There, under the reach of its branches, she finally let herself cry.
Not for him.
For the version of her that thought this would end differently.
For the love that had become a secret she could no longer carry.
For the child who deserved more than silence.
But underneath the ache, something else bloomed—a quiet fire. It didn’t burn hot. Not yet. But it was there.
She wouldn’t raise this child in shadows.
She wouldn’t be someone's hidden regret.
She would stand. She would rise.
And one day, Xander Stone would remember this night—not for what she said, but for everything she refused to become.
She wiped her cheeks, squared her shoulders, and walked into the night.
Not broken.
Just done.