Chapter 11: 11-Resentment-1

Is it possible to want something badly yet know that it could wreak havoc in your life? By allowing Noah to take me home with him, surely I was opening the door to hell. So why wasn't that stopping me? Why did every pore in my body tingle as he held my hand? Why was my mind constantly going back to how wonderful it had felt to be in his arms? These questions needed to be answered but I wasn't the one who could answer them. We stopped in front of an achingly familiar building. A row of similar-looking Brooklyn houses with doors painted the same mahogany brown. This place used to be like a home away from home. Whenever I'd get tired of the world of the Upper East Siders, I'd come here; it was my refuge. Things had changed drastically though because now what lay behind those doors was scaring the living daylights out of me. How could I face Noah's mom, a woman who considered me no less of a daughter than Lexie? How was I going to face Noah's dad, the person who taught me everything I knew about sports, who became much more of a father to me than my own had been? Lexie... I didn't even want to go there. She hated me, of course she hated me, why wouldn't she? To her I was the bitch who'd so mercilessly broken her brother's heart. I had reached a point beyond redemption but for now it didn't seem to matter. All I cared about was making this boy standing right next to me realize that I'd never hurt him on purpose. Noah unlocked his door and led us inside. My heart thumped painfully in my chest as I took in my surroundings. It was still the same, everything was still the same. Compared to the bare minimal style of Zach's house, Noah's showed it was truly a home. We walked across the living room and as I looked around I realized how much I'd missed this place. A cozy fire was lit in the fireplace with worn-out rugs strewn all over the carpeted floor. A large couch sat in the middle of the room which sagged in the middle from being used too much. The big-screen TV was the most extravagant thing they owned or actually wanted to own. Noah's parents were both doctors and were well off but wanted to stay grounded. They could've moved out of this house ages ago but chose to raise their children in the place where they themselves had grown up. "Ari, are you coming?" Noah asked as he stood halfway up the stairs. I hadn't realized that I'd stopped midway and had been staring like an idiot at the inanimate objects around me. I nodded my head and quickly wiped away the tears and allowed Noah to lead me upstairs. It was strange, I thought to myself as I walked behind him, how we were acting like nothing was wrong. In the several times I'd conjured up this scenario, a lot of screaming and shouting had been involved. It irked me to see how calm he was, when I was literally falling apart at the seams. Did he know? If he did then he was being uncharacteristically calm and if he didn't know then I was in for one hell of a confrontation. The door to his room opened and I stood at the threshold, barely daring to step in. The rest I could handle but his room... There were too many memories and they were a constant reminder of how badly things had gone wrong. He entered the room and immediately my mind began recollecting all the times when a similar picture had formed before my eyes. Noah and I doing homework together, Noah bringing me to meet his parents for the first time, Noah and I getting drunk and stumbling in together, spending nights at his house, waking up to see his gorgeous face inches from mine. It tore at me how I had made such a hasty decision without sparing a second thought to this guy who had loved me with all his heart. "Ari..." Noah said softly and I snapped out of memory lane. He was looking at me expectantly as I stood foolishly outside his room. I walked in quickly but felt oddly out of place. I resisted the urge to run because he deserved better. A feeling of dread and anxiousness settled in the pit of my stomach. Did he know? Did he not know? How would he react...? I sat down on the old couch in the corner of his room, a spot almost alien to me. I usually made myself at home in his bed and pushed him out. I'd never felt so, so awkward being with him and the feeling wasn't one I liked. When Noah realized I wasn't going to join him in my usual spot he sighed and got up to move closer to me, sitting cross-legged on the floor in front of me. He took my hand in his but I quickly pulled it away. He seemed surprised and hurt by my reaction and once again I was flooded with guilt. "What happened at the wedding?" he asked gently and I lowered my head in shame. He didn't know; I was going to have to tell him and I wasn't going to like it one bit. Things just got from bad to worse. I stayed quiet, trying to piece together my answer. I wanted the words to sound just right, I wanted them to justify what I had done but no matter how hard I tried nothing sounded right. The truth would be the truth no matter what way it was phrased. I decided however to take it slow. Without looking at him I said, "What do you think happened?" He looked slightly annoyed but the expression passed as soon as it came. He was going to go along with whatever I did or said and I was glad for once. "You disappeared... I had no idea where you were, I didn't know how to find you. I was losing my mind, Ari. Your parents said you'd left for a while because you and Olivia had a fight. I can't believe they expected me to believe that crap," he said bitterly and looked at me as if he expected me to acknowledge what he'd said and tell him a more reasonable explanation, one that would make everything alright. How do I tell him that anything I say would be ten times worse than what he'd heard? "Something happened that day... I don't know how to tell you this and I'd rather you not know what happened." I felt my voice cracking. I couldn't believe that I was already breaking down. There was a long way to go and I had to will myself to be strong.