Chapter 309: Olena - Conversation 2

Before I can pull away from Vasiliy’s arms and get up from my chair, Artemiy is already out the door, making my heart break a little.

I thought love was easy, but there’s nothing easy about caring for two people at the same time. It will only lead to the three of us getting hurt, and it’s all because of me.

“You like him too,” Vasiliy realizes as I let go of him.

I nod, not wanting to lie to him. My gaze lingers on the hallway where Artemiy disappeared only seconds ago because I’m now the one who can’t bear to look at Vasiliy. The thought of seeing the pain I caused him is enough to shatter what’s left of my heart.

“You must think I’m horrible,” I murmur. “How can I like him while having feelings for you too?”

“Olena, look at me,” he says softly.

Even if it will kill me to see his soul as crushed as mine, I do as he asks. It’s not pain or anger that reflects in his gaze, but understanding.

“There’s no shame in loving more than one person at a time,” he muses. Then he reminds me, “Isla is married to six men she loves fiercely, one of them being your son.”

A glimmer of hope flickers to life inside me.

“You think the three of us could have a similar relationship?”

He looks away for a moment.

I should have never asked that. Who knows what he must think of me now?

“I don’t know,” he replies truthfully. “I’m not a Lord, and I’ve never really given much thought to what it would be like to be in that kind of relationship. But what I do know is that I want to be with you in any way you’ll have me. I’ll continue to be your friend, your protector, because I don’t dare hope for more.”

My hands reach for his, and to my relief, he doesn’t pull away.

“I’m the one who doesn’t dare hope. I feel so… selfish for doing this to both of you.”

Vasiliy cups my left cheek.

“You are not selfish for feeling. After all, you didn’t promise anything to me, and judging by Artemiy’s reaction, I assume you didn’t promise anything to him either.”

“I feel this way because I don’t want to choose between either of you.”

Pain flashes in his eyes.

“Oh, Vasiliy. I’m so sorry.”

After everything my life has been, I shouldn’t even entertain the idea of having to choose between two good men. It should be easy. It should be...

Vasiliy presses his lips to my forehead before standing.

“There’s nothing to feel sorry about. Talk to Artemiy. See what he has to say about it. He... he’s a good man, and he deserves happiness.”

“Don’t you?” I retort.

“You are my happiness, sweetheart. If you’re happy, I’m happy.”

You are my happiness too.

After breakfast, I go to my room, and after thinking for a moment, I decide to call my daughter-in-law.

“Olena,” she chirps happily when she answers. “How are you and Vasiliy? I’ve been so busy lately, I haven’t had time to check up on you two.”

“What have you been busy with?” I ask, wanting to catch up before I tell her why I called.

It’s been about a month since I last saw her. Ever since she and her husbands moved in with her grandfather, life has been busy.

“I’m going back to school,” she replies enthusiastically. “I’m going to study archaeology.”

“I’m so happy for you, Isla. How about the others?”

Her tone turns softer.

“Ivan started a gardening business, and it’s been a massive hit, especially with the women, but I think that’s only because Kade is helping him. Dimitri and Andrey are going to be cover models for romance novels. The author is a friend of Dimitri’s. Uri spends most of his time with Zana and my grandfather, while Dominick has a huge project going on, and the comic he’s working on is going to be amazing. But at the end of the day, they all make time for me. I don’t think I’ve ever been happier.”

“I’m so glad for you, Isla. You deserve to be happy.”

There’s a brief pause before she asks, “And how have you been?”

“This is why I’m calling. I need your help,” I tell her before explaining everything about Vasiliy and Artemiy.

She listens carefully to everything I have to say before taking a moment to think.

“Why don’t you date both of them? Go out one day with one, the next with the other, and even the three of you together.”

“I can’t do that to either of them!” I exclaim, sounding just as horrified as I feel at the thought of putting Vasiliy and Artemiy in that position.

“Have you considered that maybe they’re both yours?”

“How can that even be?” I inquire.

“Olena, if I have six soulmates, who’s to say you can’t have two? Or more?”

The thought of a third man entering my life feels wrong. Vasiliy and Artemiy feel like the perfect balance.

“But...” I try to reason with her.

“Listen. You said Artemiy is a Lord. If he and Vasiliy are willing to become blood-brothers, then you don’t have to choose.”

“They’re cousins!” I remind her.

She lets out a soft breath. “There’s a group of Lords where two of the men are brothers and share the same Lady. And another with cousins. I met both groups not long ago, and they all get along very well.”

I hear Zana in the background, calling out to Isla.

“I need to go,” my daughter-in-law tells me. “You deserve happiness. So do Vasiliy and Artemiy.”

“But I feel so selfish for wanting two men at the same time.”

“You are not selfish for wanting to be loved. Ask me how I know.”

My brows draw together.

She continues, “Because I couldn’t give up any of my soulmates.”

Zana calls for Isla once more.

“I really need to go. I love you, Olena.”

And with that, she ends the phone call.

Artemiy returns home a couple of hours later and finds Vasiliy and me on the terrace, enjoying the last warm days of fall.

When his gaze finds mine, the first thing he says is, “Sorry for storming out like that. I needed some time to think.”

“There’s nothing to be sorry about,” I reassure him. “Could we talk? The three of us?”

They both agree, and Artemiy joins us at the table.

Vasiliy decides to open the conversation.

“Olena has feelings for me, but she also likes you. She doesn’t want to choose between the two of us, and she’s conflicted about it.”

Artemiy looks at his cousin, then at me.

“Then date both of us.”

“You… wouldn’t mind that?” I wonder, shocked.

He shrugs.

“I’m a Lord. It’s normal for many Lords to have blood-brothers and dedicate their lives to taking care of their Lady.”

“But you don’t have a blood-brother,” I point out.

“No,” he agrees. His attention returns to Vasiliy. “But I wouldn’t mind having one.”

Vasiliy shifts uncomfortably in his chair. “Let’s start with dating Olena and see how things progress from there.”

My eyes widen. “You want to date me while I’m dating Artemiy too?” I ask, wanting to be sure I understand him correctly.

He rubs the back of his neck. “I’d do anything for you, Olena.”

“So would I,” Artemiy says. “She deserves to be happy. And if she needs both of us in her life, then so be it.”

Vasiliy nods in approval, bringing tears to my eyes.

“I’m happy,” I reassure them.