Chapter 39: Chapter Thirty-Nine - Out Of Respect

Gabe

Our quiet night with movies and takeout didn’t go as we expected. The girls quickly convinced us to go to a nightclub, and it didn’t take much for them to persuade us. They always seem to get their way. We're at Anthony and Kaitlyn’s house because Peyton didn’t have an outfit suitable for clubbing, so she's borrowing something from Kaitlyn. While the girls are in the bedroom getting ready, we men are in the living room drinking beers and waiting. It's been a while since I last went to a club.

“Is anything going on between you and Peyton?”

I look directly at Anthony. “No.”

It's the truth, but Anthony furrows his brow at me, appearing doubtful. “Are you sure?”

“Yes, positive. Peyton is not in a good place right now. She has been through a lot. The last thing she needs is for me to try to win her back.”

I wouldn’t exploit the situation while she’s struggling. Anthony doesn’t have the chance to reply because the sound of heels on the tiled floor indicates the girls are returning.

The second Peyton appears, my breath catches in my throat. She wears a black, strapless, short dress that accentuates her flawless curves. Her tanned, toned legs are visible, supported by purple stiletto heels. She looks so good! So sexy! I grip the front of the sofa, trying to keep myself together the best I can because Peyton can read me like a book.

“Well, don’t you ladies look lovely," Anthony says with a smile, glancing at his wife with a smirk.

Kaitlyn winks at him. “Thanks, handsome.”

“I-I-I will book a cab.” God, could I be any more obvious?

Peyton tilts her head to the side. “Are you okay?”

I swear she's holding back a smirk, aware of what’s clearly wrong with me.

“Hmm, yes, I am fine,” I reply, then focus on my phone to book a cab.

Peyton giggles, quickly grabs my beer, and takes a sip. I look up at her, and she greedily licks her lips before returning the drink. What is she up to? She can’t be teasing me like this. I’m trying my best to stay composed. Nothing should happen between us—not yet. If this is her idea of fun for tonight, it’s going to be challenging. I should probably watch what I drink. I need to stay in control, and too much alcohol might ruin that.

I take it from her, laughing and shaking my head. “Cab will be here in ten minutes.”

We could walk, but with the girls in heels, it wouldn’t be ideal for them, and it's quite cold outside tonight. Taking a cab is a better choice. We double-check that we have everything and then head out to wait for our cab. The club is only about ten minutes away.

Kaitlyn and Anthony walk in front of us, whispering and flirting. I’m unsure of what to say, Peyton, fearing I might say something inappropriate if I speak.

“Gabe, why aren’t you talking to me? You won’t even look at me," Peyton sighs.

I focus my attention on her. “It isn’t that I am not talking to you. I worry I might say something I shouldn’t. I don’t want to make things weird.”

“Say something like, what?” she asks with curiosity, nibbling her lower lip.

“I think you know, Peyton. You noticed my reaction when my eyes fell on you. Do I really need to say?”

She bats her lashes and offers a sweet smile. "I don’t know what you mean.”

“Yes, you do. I won't be doing this with you tonight, gorgeous.”

Peyton rolls her eyes. “You used to be fun…”

She walks ahead of me while I groan softly, staying behind her. I can’t manage her right now. Peyton has no clue what thoughts are racing through my mind or how much I'm resisting each one, all out of respect for her.

“Hurry up, Gabe,” Kaitlyn calls out, laughing.

I hurriedly catch up with them as we head downstairs. The cab isn’t visible when we step outside; I check the app—it's scheduled to arrive in five minutes. I lean against the wall, fiddling with my cell to distract myself from how stunning Peyton looks. I sneak glances every now and then to avoid being caught. I manage this well for the first couple of times, but on the third, Peyton is already looking at me. She must have caught me staring. She walks over and stands beside me.

"You’re not very good at hiding that you’re staring,” she laughs.

I run my fingers through my hair and sigh. “I'm sorry, I can’t help it. You know what you do to me—you still have the same effect as five years ago.”

Peyton’s lips part to reply, but before she can, our cab pulls up. Couldn’t it have waited another minute? I want to hear what she was going to say. Now I probably never will, since Peyton likely won’t mention it again.

“I will go in the front,” I say.

The three of them get into the back, and I take the front seat. At least being here means Peyton isn’t right next to me, which should make things easier—at least until we reach the club. I plan to keep her close, as there are too many creeps around. I don’t think she’ll be interested in looking for a hookup or accepting flirtation from a stranger.

I look out the window, observing the city rush past as the others converse among themselves and with the driver. I have no clue how I'll respond when I see Peyton dance. She better not ask me to join, because I won’t be able to refuse, and having her so close to my body might be the thing that finally breaks me.

I regret going along with this! We should have stuck to our original plan, but it's already underway, and there's nothing I can do now. I'm sure Peyton is eager to vent after everything that's recently occurred. She has every right to do so. At the very least, it promises to be an interesting night.