Chapter 16: Confronting the Shadows
POV: Theo Sinclair
Running had always been my solution. New York had suffocated me, so I ran. Away from my family, their expectations, and the mess Alex and Vanessa left in their wake. But no matter how far you go, some things cling to you, waiting for the perfect moment to resurface.
Today was one of those moments.
I stared at my laptop in the corner of Chapters & Brews, the email from my mother glaring at me like an accusation.
We need to talk, Theo. It’s time to come home.
A tightness gripped my chest as I thought about “home”—a place where love came second to legacy and betrayal lingered like smoke. My parents saw me as an extension of their empire, and Alex… well, Alex saw me as an inconvenience. I’d thought Vanessa had seen me for who I was, but I’d been wrong about her, too.
The image of them together—Alex’s hand brushing hers, her soft laugh turning cruel—still stung in a way I hated admitting.
“Okay,” Mia said, sliding into the chair across from me and interrupting my spiraling thoughts. “What’s going on with you?”
“Nothing,” I muttered, snapping the laptop shut.
“You’ve been sulking for days,” she said, crossing her arms. “And don’t give me that ‘everything’s fine’ crap. This is me you’re talking to.”
“It’s just family stuff,” I said, leaning back in my chair.
“Ah,” Mia said, her smirk fading. “The Sinclair circus strikes again?”
“Something like that.”
“Well,” she said, nudging my coffee toward me, “if you’re not ready to talk to me, maybe try someone else. Like Evelyn, for example?”
I shot her a warning look. “Drop it, Mia.”
She held up her hands. “Fine. But whatever this is, you need to deal with it, Theo. You can’t just bury everything forever.”
The library was quieter than usual when I walked in. The soft hum of the overhead lights and the faint sound of pages turning created a calm that didn’t quite reach me.
Evelyn was at her desk, her red curls falling loose around her shoulders as she flipped through a stack of papers. She didn’t notice me at first, her focus entirely on whatever she was working on.
“Long day?” I asked, leaning against the counter.
She looked up, startled, but her expression softened when she saw me. “Theo. What are you doing here?”
“Thought I’d check in,” I said, keeping my tone casual. “Make sure you weren’t drowning in paperwork.”
“Not yet,” she said, though the tired edge in her voice told a different story.
“Mind if I help?” I offered.
Evelyn blinked, clearly caught off guard. “Sure. If you’re not too busy.”
“Never too busy for you, librarian,” I said with a small grin.
She rolled her eyes but gestured for me to follow her to one of the larger work tables.
We sat surrounded by scattered notes and plans for the upcoming event. Evelyn was explaining her latest idea for the scavenger hunt, her voice animated as she sketched out a clue, but my mind kept drifting.
The email. The memory of Alex’s smug face. Vanessa’s biting laugh as she dismissed me like I was nothing.
“You’re quiet,” Evelyn said, pulling me back to the present.
“Just thinking,” I said, trying to sound nonchalant.
“About?”
I hesitated, the words sticking in my throat. Evelyn tilted her head, her gaze steady but gentle.
“Family,” I said finally, the weight of the word pressing down on me.
“Want to elaborate?” she asked softly.
“It’s complicated,” I said, leaning back in my chair.
Her lips curved into a faint smile. “Most things are.”
I let out a bitter laugh. “They want me to come back to New York. To the family business. They think I’m wasting my time here.”
Evelyn frowned, setting her pen down. “Wasting your time? Theo, you’ve built something incredible. Why would they think that?”
“Because it’s not their definition of success,” I said, my voice sharper than I intended. “To them, this place is just a distraction. They think I’ll wake up one day and realize I’ve made a mistake.”
Evelyn was quiet for a moment, her green and blue eyes studying me. “Do you think you’ve made a mistake?”
“No,” I said immediately.
“Then that’s all that matters,” she said firmly.
I looked at her, surprised by the steel in her voice. “You make it sound so easy.”
“It’s not,” she admitted. “But it’s worth it. You deserve to live your life on your terms, Theo. No one else’s.”
Her words settled over me like a balm, easing a tension I hadn’t realized I was carrying.
As the evening wore on, we fell into a rhythm. Evelyn’s voice filled the space as she refined the scavenger hunt clues, her sharp wit cutting through my lingering doubts.
“Okay,” she said, tapping her pen against her notebook. “Here’s one: ‘Hidden among the tales of old, a clue awaits the brave and bold.’”
“Not bad,” I said, nodding. “But I think it could use a little more flair.”
“Oh, really?” she said, raising an eyebrow. “Let’s hear your version, then.”
I leaned forward, smirking. “How about: ‘In the stories where heroes take their stand, you’ll find a clue that’s close at hand.’”
Evelyn pretended to consider it, tapping her chin thoughtfully. “Not bad. For a first draft.”
I laughed, the sound easing the weight on my chest.
As we packed up for the night, Evelyn glanced at her watch, a flicker of worry crossing her face.
“Everything okay?” I asked.
“It’s my grandmother,” she said, tucking her notebook into her bag. “She’s been feeling off this week. I promised to stop by and check on her tonight.”
“Do you need a ride?” I offered.
She hesitated, then shook her head. “No, but thanks. It’s not far.”
“Maybe next time,” I said, smiling.
Evelyn returned the smile, soft and genuine. “Maybe.”
The cool evening air hit me as I left the library, but it did little to clear my head.
Vanessa’s words echoed in my mind, from that day when everything fell apart. “You’re always running, Theo. Maybe you should ask yourself why.”
I wasn’t running anymore. Not really. But the question still lingered.
As much as I hated to admit it, Evelyn Harper made me wonder if staying—if letting someone in—was worth the risk.
And that thought terrified me more than any email from my mother ever could.