Chapter 12: A Step Too Close
POV: Theo Sinclair
The late afternoon sunlight poured through the wide windows of Chapters & Brews, painting the café in warm, golden hues. Normally, I found this time of day soothing—a brief pause before the evening rush—but today, it felt like an itch I couldn’t scratch.
Mia was perched on her usual stool near the counter, casually flipping through a magazine while keeping half an eye on me. I was pretending to go through invoices, but my thoughts were far from business.
“You’ve been staring at that same page for ten minutes,” Mia said, her tone amused. “Want to tell me what’s going on, or should I guess?”
“I’m just thinking,” I said, not looking up.
“Uh-huh,” Mia said, closing the magazine and resting her chin on her hand. “Thinking about a certain librarian, maybe?”
I shot her a look, but she just grinned. “You’re not subtle, you know. You’ve been spending more time at that library than you do here.”
“She’s passionate about the event,” I said, keeping my tone neutral.
“And you’re passionate about… her?” Mia teased, raising an eyebrow.
I groaned, rubbing the back of my neck. “Why do I even talk to you?”
“Because I’m the only one who’ll tell you the truth,” she said, hopping off the stool. “Face it, Theo. You like her.”
“It’s not like that,” I said quickly, though even I didn’t believe it.
“Sure,” Mia said, smirking as she walked away. “Keep telling yourself that.”
The library was quiet when I arrived, the kind of quiet that made every footstep feel like an interruption. The familiar scent of old books and polished wood greeted me as I stepped inside, the late afternoon sun casting long shadows across the floor.
My eyes immediately found Evelyn. She was standing near the back of the room, carefully rearranging books on a high shelf. Her red curls were pulled into a loose bun, though a few stray strands framed her face. She wore a soft lavender cardigan that hugged her shoulders and a pencil skirt that accentuated the curve of her hips. Her figure was fuller, her curves commanding attention in a way that made it hard to look away.
Her green and blue eyes were focused on her work, her lips pursed slightly as she stood on tiptoe to reach the highest shelf.
I swallowed, suddenly feeling like an intruder in her quiet world. But I couldn’t stop staring. She wasn’t just beautiful—she was mesmerizing, in a way I didn’t think she realized.
Clearing my throat, I stepped forward. “You know, they make ladders for that.”
Evelyn yelped, clutching a book to her chest as she turned to glare at me. “Theo! Do you have to sneak up on people like that?”
“Not sneaking,” I said, grinning as I stepped closer. “You were just too focused to notice.”
She huffed, stepping down from the small stool and placing the book on the desk. “What are you doing here? Don’t you have a café to run?”
“Taking a break,” I said, leaning against the desk. “Thought I’d check on my favorite librarian.”
Her cheeks flushed, though she quickly looked away. “Flattery isn’t going to get you out of helping with these displays.”
“Who said I was trying to get out of anything?” I asked, picking up a stack of books.
Evelyn raised an eyebrow but didn’t argue. “Fine. You can start with these.”
As we worked side by side, the conversation flowed easily, each of us falling into a comfortable rhythm. Evelyn was surprisingly animated, her passion for the library shining through as she explained her vision for the event.
“I still think we need to make the scavenger hunt clues more challenging,” she said, placing a book carefully on the shelf.
“And I still think you’re underestimating how lazy people can be,” I countered, smirking. “If it’s too hard, they’ll give up.”
Evelyn rolled her eyes. “It’s not about making it easy. It’s about making it rewarding.”
“Spoken like a true librarian,” I teased.
“Spoken like someone who actually cares about engagement,” she shot back.
“Touché,” I said, holding up my hands in surrender. “But don’t come crying to me when people can’t figure it out.”
“Why would I cry to you?” Evelyn said, her tone dry.
“Because I’m the only one who can fix it,” I said, grinning.
She snorted, shaking her head. “You’re impossible.”
“And yet, here I am,” I said, stacking another book.
After a while, I noticed Evelyn’s energy seemed to wane. She grew quieter, her focus shifting inward.
“You okay?” I asked, glancing at her.
She hesitated, her fingers lingering on the edge of a book. “Just thinking.”
“About?”
Evelyn gave me a sidelong glance, her expression guarded. “The library. The event. Everything.”
“Ah,” I said, leaning against the shelf. “The weight of the world on your shoulders.”
“Something like that,” she said, her voice softer now.
For a moment, I didn’t know what to say. I understood that weight—more than I wanted to admit. But Evelyn wasn’t the kind of person who wanted pity.
“You don’t have to do it all alone, you know,” I said finally.
She looked at me, surprised. “What do you mean?”
“I mean you’ve got people who care about this place as much as you do,” I said, meeting her gaze. “You’ve got me.”
Evelyn blinked, her cheeks flushing slightly. “I… I know that. It’s just hard to let go, I guess.”
I nodded, understanding more than she probably realized.
As the sun dipped below the horizon, casting the library in a warm, golden glow, we found ourselves back at the work table. Evelyn was bent over her notebook, scribbling notes as she fine-tuned the scavenger hunt clues.
“Okay,” she said, sitting back and adjusting her glasses. “How’s this? ‘I hold the stories, old and new. Find me where the knowledge grew.’”
“Not bad,” I said, nodding in approval. “But it’s missing something.”
“What?”
“Me,” I said, smirking.
Evelyn groaned, tossing her pen at me. “You’re ridiculous.”
“Ridiculously helpful,” I said, catching the pen.
“Barely,” she muttered, though her lips twitched upward.
By the time we wrapped up, the library was bathed in the soft glow of its overhead lights.
“This might actually work,” Evelyn said, her voice tinged with cautious optimism.
“Told you,” I said, standing and stretching. “We make a good team.”
She rolled her eyes but didn’t argue.
As I gathered my things, I found myself lingering, not quite ready to leave. “Hey,” I said, meeting her gaze. “You’re doing a good job, Evelyn. Better than good.”
Her eyes widened slightly, and for a moment, I thought I saw a flicker of vulnerability there. Then she smiled—a small, genuine smile that made something tighten in my chest. “Thanks, Theo.”
As I stepped outside into the cool night air, I couldn’t stop thinking about that smile.
Evelyn Harper was getting under my skin in ways I wasn’t ready for.
And that scared me more than I wanted to admit.