Chapter 43
Chapter Title: Fake
Kathy
The salt air stung my cheeks as we walked the four blocks to Cars R Us, the rental agency near Ocean City’s bus terminal. My body still hummed from Archer’s touch, a reckless heat I couldn’t shake, but I shoved it down, focusing on the pavement under my loafers. Kimberly was the mission—her abduction the only thing that mattered. Not Archer’s teasing grin. Not Ace’s possessive grip or the cryptic threats I’d overheard. I brushed against Ace’s arm as we walked, the contact sending a jolt through me. Get it together, Kathy, I told myself, but the words seemed futile.
I mentally mapped out the hotel suite, already planning to barricade myself in the bedroom tonight. Ace and Archer could fight over the couch and floor. I needed space to think, to breathe, to untangle the mess of this case—and my own head. I couldn't give in to the call of flesh, even if every nerve in my body screamed for release.
The agency was a squat, faded building, its neon sign flickering like a dwindling rhythm. Inside, it smelled of cheap air freshener and motor oil. A bald-headed man whose dark skin glowed under the harsh fluorescent lights, his moustache trimmed to perfection, stood behind the counter, his Cars R Us polo stretched tight over his broad chest. His name tag read Carter in bold letters. He glanced up from his phone, sizing us up with a practiced eye.
I stepped forward, flashing my FBI badge. “Agent Hastings. We need records for an SUV involved in a kidnapping.” I nodded to Ace, who rattled off the license plate number from memory, his voice clipped and professional.
Carter’s fingers danced over his keyboard, his moustache twitching as he frowned at the screen. "Car was due back yesterday. Flagged as stolen once it wasn’t returned,” he said, matter-of-fact. “We put holds on late returns, sure. We also report vehicles if they don’t show in a day or two. Cops came by last week about a different car.” He jabbed at another line. “Renter’s name: Kelly Lawrence. Address: 114—Main Street, Norfolk, Virginia. Driver’s license attached.”
My brow creased, my heart stuttering at the name. It couldn't be. Kelly Lawrence?
He hit print, and the ancient printer behind him wheezed to life. He handed me the papers, and as my eyes skimmed the page, her name leapt out—Kelly Lawrence. My breath hitched. Kelly. My sister’s name. Dead for years, yet now entwined in the threads of Kimberly’s abduction.
This couldn't be a coincidence.
I scanned the copied DL. The photo was a woman with a hairline I didn’t know, eyes set in a face I’d never seen. Not Kelly or Kimberly. Not even close. Little things flicked through my chest like warning lights: the way the name matched nothing I knew about my sister; the Virginia address that might or might not exist; fake ID, real enough to pass muster. I could verify the address later, but it was a lead—a thread to pull.
I glanced at the CCTV camera mounted in the corner, its red light blinking lazily. "We’ll need the surveillance from the day this vehicle was rented, along with any GPS tracking data associated with it.’
Carter leaned back, scratching his jaw. “Footage and tracking? Gotta clear that with my supervisor. She’s not in ’til later today, but still, that's gonna take some time. Come back tomorrow around nine.”
Tomorrow. The word landed like a brick in my gut. I wanted everything now—the footage of the woman who drove off with the SUV, the slow gait of her walk, the way she checked the passenger side, whether she carried a bag with a ribbon on it, anything at all to connect her to Kimberly. But the bureaucratic clock ticked its own way and Carter’s smile was impermeable.
I nodded, tamping down my frustration—it was a delay, nothing more. Sliding my card across the counter, I kept my tone clipped. "If you can expedite that information, Carter, call me directly. Otherwise, we’ll be here at opening. And make sure your supervisor is available—I’ll expect to speak with them when I return for the requested records."
It was nearly noon when we stepped back into the sunlight, the boardwalk’s noise swelling around us—kids laughing, arcade machines chiming, the ocean’s restless churn. Archer pointed across the street to a steakhouse with a faded sign promising “Best Mashed Potatoes in Town.”
“I’m starving,” he said, already moving. “Gravy’s calling my name.”
I nodded absently, my mind still on Kelly Lawrence. The name wasn’t a coincidence—it couldn’t be. I needed her case file, needed to dig into why someone would use her name for this. My sister’s ghost was haunting this case, and I wasn’t sure if it was a taunt or a clue.
At the steakhouse, we slid into a booth, the vinyl sticky under my thighs. The place smelled of charred meat and fried onions, and the waitress, a tired woman with a smoker’s rasp, took our orders with barely a glance. I picked at my potato wedges, my appetite gone, while Archer drowned his mashed potatoes in gravy and Ace cut into his steak with surgical precision. They were trying to act normal, but the tension between us was a live wire. Archer’s foot nudged mine under the table, playful but deliberate, and I shot him a warning look. Ace caught it, his eyes narrowing, but he said nothing.
I kept my head down, my eyes focused on my plate, but my mind was cataloguing details: the rental agent’s hesitation at a certain timestamp on the rental sheet, the slight smudge on the signature line, the way Carter glanced toward the camera above the counter when the word “footage” was used.
“Kelly Lawrence,” Archer said between bites, tearing at bread. “Common name. Could be anybody.”
“Not helpful,” I shot back.
“We need a break,” Ace said suddenly, leaning back in his chair. “This case is eating us alive. After lunch, let’s do something… normal. Tourist stuff. Boardwalk, maybe some shopping. Get you some fun clothes, Hastings.” His smile was almost boyish, but there was an edge to it, like he was daring me to argue.
Archer grinned, wiping gravy from his chin. “Hell yeah. Let’s paint the town red. Get Kathy out of those FBI slacks and into something… looser.”
I rolled my eyes, but the idea of a distraction was tempting. My head was a tangle of Kelly’s name, Kimberly’s abduction, and the dangerous pull of the two men across from me. “Fine,” I said, forcing a smile. “But no clubs. I’m not dancing with either of you.”
Archer laughed, and even Ace’s lips twitched. For a moment, we were just three people in a diner, not a trio caught in a web of secrets and violence. But as we paid the bill and stepped back onto the boardwalk, the weight of the case settled over me again. Kelly Lawrence. A fake ID. A crushed SUV. And Ace’s words from the balcony echoing in my head: Betray me, and you’ll regret it.
I glanced at him, his profile sharp against the bright afternoon sun. He was keeping secrets—maybe from me, maybe from Archer. And Archer… his touch still burned in my memory, reckless and hungry. I was caught between them, pulled by desire and duty, chasing a truth that might destroy us all.
As we wandered toward the boardwalk’s arcades, the neon lights flashing promises of escape, I made a silent vow. Tonight, I’d lock myself in that bedroom. Tomorrow, I’d get that footage and track that SUV. And somehow, I’d unravel the mystery of Kelly Lawrence—before it unraveled me.