Chapter 40
Chapter Title: Cracks in the Facade
Kathy
I arrived thirty minutes early—perfect. Just enough time to scope out the Williamson Estate and get a read on how Divine Williamson orchestrated her empire.
And damn, the place was everything I imagined and more.
The mansion didn’t just occupy its beachfront plot; it commanded it. Ancient oaks, gnarled and heavy with time, stood sentinel along the perimeter, their roots clawing into the earth. Wrought-iron gates, embossed with a bold, curling W, guarded the entrance like a family crest. Beyond them, the Chesapeake Bay shimmered under the late-morning sun, its surface rippling like liquid gold. The stone driveway sliced through hedges so precisely manicured they looked like they’d been shaped with a scalpel.
This wasn’t just wealth. It was legacy—the kind of money that rewrote histories and buried inconvenient truths beneath marble columns and ancestral oil portraits.
As I stared at those gates, a memory surfaced unbidden: Kimberly and me as kids, building sandcastles on a crowded public beach, laughing as the waves erased our fragile kingdoms. She'd always dreamed of a life like this—grand, untouchable. Now, staring at the estate, I wondered if that dream had swallowed her whole. My chest tightened; I hadn't been there for her in years, too wrapped up in my own world. If I'd just picked up the damn phone more often...
I parked my rental across the street, just beyond the lazy sweep of the estate’s security cameras. From here, I had a clear view of the motorcade lined up out front: a sleek white Audi, a stately navy-blue Lincoln Continental, a black Mercedes-Benz, a hulking Cadillac Escalade, and a red Porsche 911 that gleamed like a fresh wound.
The Porsche didn’t fit. It was too loud, too brash. The kind of car a man like Hank might covet if he was compensating for something.
A sharp crack pierced the air. My body tensed, adrenaline surging, and I was out of the car in an instant. My hand snapped to the holster at my hip, fingers brushing the grip of my weapon, ready for action.
Another crack, duller this time, but unmistakable. My ears pricked. Not a backfiring car. Not fireworks. A shotgun.
“The Williamsons are clay shooting, dear,” a voice called from behind me.
I spun around, quickly hiding my weapon under my blazer, muscles taut.
An elderly man stood in his front yard, pruning a rosebush with the slow, deliberate precision of a ritual. His house, a weathered two-story brick draped in ivy, wore its age with dignity—unlike the Williamson estate’s polished immortality. He was stooped but steady, his hands gnarled from years of work, his eyes sharp beneath a frayed straw hat.
“They do it when guests are over or when the Senator’s in town,” he said, leaning on his clippers to squint through the gates. “That Cadillac’s here, so Henry’s back. Never stays long, though. A day or two, tops.”
I exhaled, the adrenaline ebbing but not gone. “You know the Williamsons well?”
He snorted, a sound caught between pride and scorn. “Who doesn’t? Divine’s father used to invite me to his parties. Fine whiskey, finer cigars. But once Divine took over, the invites dried up.” His mouth twisted. “She prefers a different crowd.”
“Do you know Kimberly?” I asked, testing the waters.
His eyes lit up, but faintly. “Hank’s fiancée? Sure. That white Audi’s hers.”
So he tracks the cars. Observant.
“And the Porsche?” I pressed, nodding to the red eyesore.
“That’s Benedict Reed’s. Folks call him Papa Benny.” He clipped a rose with a decisive snip, holding it up to the light like he was inspecting a clue. “Runs the town’s shadier dealings, or so the rumors go. Arrested more times than I can count, but the man’s got a knack for slipping charges. Odd to see him here this early, though. He was yelling at the gate earlier—sounded serious.”
My ears pricked. “Did you hear what it was about?”
“Something to do with Allison, his daughter. That’s all I caught.” His gaze sharpened, studying me. “And you? What brings you here, staring at that fortress like you’re casing it?”
I weighed my response. No need to overshare, but he was a potential ally. “I’m looking into my sister’s disappearance. Kimberly Hastings. I’m Kathy, her sister.”
His clippers froze mid-air. “Clyde,” he said at last, his voice softening. “And yes, I heard about Kimberly. Damn shame.” He hesitated, then leaned closer, voice dropping to a conspiratorial murmur. “If I’m being honest, I figured she ran off with somebody else."
That hit like a sucker punch. It clashed with what Janet Rivera, Kimberly’s lawyer, had told me—Kimberly felt trapped, maybe even threatened. But Clyde was offering another angle entirely.
“Her lawyer said she signed the prenup,” I said, keeping my tone neutral. “That makes the engagement official. Your theory doesn't add up.”
Clyde gave a dismissive shrug, but his eyes gleamed with the weight of gossip. “What do I know? I’m just a nosy old man who notices which cars come and go and makes trouble down at the marina.”
“Humor me, Clyde. Why do you think she ran off with someone else? And who?”
He glanced at his roses as though debating whether to answer. “I’m at the docks most mornings. Four a.m. sharp. Fresher catch, cheaper too, before the middlemen swoop in. And I saw her there—more than once. Dressed down, cap pulled low, track suit zipped to her chin. Thought she was invisible, but she wears this bracelet. Her initials are etched into the charm. One morning it slipped out of her sleeve, and I knew for certain it was her.”
The bracelet... Hearing about it now, in this context, sent a chill through me. What secrets was she hiding at dawn? Was she scared, desperate? My throat tightened; I swallowed hard, forcing the words out. “Who was she meeting?”
“You might have heard of him. His name's—”
“Hastings!”
A voice boomed from down the street, cutting Clyde off. A white Lincoln Corsair rolled up behind my rental, its engine purring like a smug cat.
Archer.
He wasn’t kidding about needing legroom; the SUV was practically a living room on wheels. Typical Archer—throwing money at toys while his diner was falling apart.
“Hey, Mr. Jones!” Archer leaned out the window, flashing a grin that didn’t reach his eyes. “I see you’ve met Kathy.”
Clyde didn’t answer. Didn't even nod. He just fixed Archer with a stare cold enough to frost the roses, his grip tightening on the clippers until his knuckles whitened.
I raised an eyebrow. “Are you related to Cole Jones?”
Clyde’s expression softened, a flicker of pride breaking through. “My grandson. I help him with his… culinary experiments at that monstrosity he calls Delish.”
“That’s sweet,” I said, handing him a business card. “If you ever feel like talking more, call me.”
He pocketed the card, lips twitching into a half-smile. “Might take you up on that. Maybe I’ll give you a tour of the marina one morning. Show you where I saw your sister.”
“I’d like that, Clyde.” I brushed his arm gently. “Would it be alright if I left my car here? I’ll be back later to pick it up.”
“Of course.” He hesitated, then looked me dead in the eye. “Be careful, Kathy.” His gaze flicked to Archer, sharp with disapproval, before he shuffled back to his porch, clippers in hand.
I grabbed my backpack from my car, slung it over my shoulder and shot Archer a smirk. “Clyde's not your biggest fan."
Archer grunted. “Can’t blame him. Had a run-in with his son, Calvin, a while back. Marina fees were bleeding the fishermen dry, and I called him out. Things got heated. He swung first; I hit back. Got arrested for it, but the charges were dropped after the fishermen protested on his lawn.” He glanced toward the Williamson gates, his expression darkening. “There’s Ace.”
I followed his line of sight. Ace was moving down the driveway, escorting a burly man in a tailored suit, his auburn hair streaked with white. The man’s face was thunderous, his eyes blazing with barely contained fury.
“Papa Benny,” Archer muttered, leaning close enough for his breath to graze my ear. “Allison’s father. He runs everything dirty in this town. And if he’s here…” Archer trailed off, eyes narrowing. “…then things just got complicated.”
Ace moved with a practiced calm, but Papa Benny was a hurricane. His voice sliced through the air, raw and jagged.
“She's lying to me, Ace!” Benny snapped, jabbing a thick finger into Ace’s chest. “Divine says Allison’s in New York? That’s bullshit. My girl doesn’t vanish without a word. If she was there, I’d know.”
Ace raised his hands, voice smooth but clipped. “That’s the truth, Benny. Divine sent her north. She’s safe, I swear.”
“Safe? After Kimberly's gone missing?” Benny’s laugh cracked like a whip. “Allison's phone’s dead, her apartment’s empty, and my guys say she never made it to New York. Never even left Crisfield.” His voice dropped, low and dangerous. “So you tell me—where the hell is she?”
The words hit me like a cold wave. Divine claimed Allison was in New York, but Benny was certain she was still here.
Ace lowered his voice, trying to defuse the situation. “Keep it down, Benny. You’re making a scene.”
“Screw you,” Benny snarled, his face flushed with rage. His whole frame trembled as he leaned in, voice a razor’s edge. “If I find out Divine's hiding her from me, if she's in trouble—” He broke off, jaw locking tight, the unfinished threat hanging in the air like a blade.
Suddenly, Benny straightened, smoothing his tie with a practiced flick of his wrist. He stormed toward his car, each step staking claim to the earth beneath him.
Then, Benny's red Porsche roared out through the gates, kicking up a trail of dust that hung like a ghost in the air.
Ace remained, fists balled at his sides, his composed facade fracturing for a fleeting moment before he turned and strode back toward the mansion.
Archer leaned in, his voice a low, grim murmur. “Divine claims Allison’s in New York. Papa Benny’s calling bullshit. Says she never left Crisfield.”
That was odd. The girl at Lace and Timber mentioned Allison was in New Jersey for some seminar. Now New York? And Benny was convinced she was still in Crisfield.
The stories didn't add up.
Allison... Al... Could they be the same person?
A cold heaviness settled in my chest. Kimberly was missing. Now Allison’s whereabouts were unraveling too. If Benny was right, two women had vanished under the Williamsons’ roof—and the lies were only getting deeper.
But it wasn't just the puzzle that gnawed at me; it was the fear that I'd failed Kimberly again, that my search might end with more questions than closure. I couldn't let that happen. Not this time. For her—for us—I had to keep pushing, even if it meant facing the ghosts I'd buried long ago.