Chapter 15

Chapter Title: Crab Cakes and Conundrums

Kathy

Ace Ryder lounged against the edge of my booth like he owned the place, all lean muscle and calculated nonchalance. His dark hair was a tousled masterpiece, kissed by some imaginary coastal breeze, and that charcoal-gray suit—tailored to within an inch of its life—clung to his broad shoulders and tapered waist like it was auditioning for a starring role in my daydreams. No tie, top two buttons undone, just enough to scream I make my own rules. A thin, jagged scar near his temple caught the light, a cryptic footnote to a story he hadn’t shared. In his hand, a to-go bag dangled casually, its contents a secret I wasn’t sure I wanted to unravel. But those eyes—caramel, sharp as a blade, and glinting with mischief—pinned me in place, suggesting he had no intention of leaving anytime soon.

My heart did a traitor’s skip, and I cursed it silently. Ace’s grin unfurled, slow and deliberate, the kind that could charm a nun or disarm a bomb. I wasn’t sure which I was today, but I was leaning toward explosive.

“Starting to think you’re tailing me,” I said, keeping my voice dry as desert sand, though a traitorous spark of amusement flickered through.

He tilted his head, that grin kicking up a notch, like he’d been waiting for me to throw the first punch. “And I didn’t think you’d stick around long enough for me to buy you a coffee. Or…” He leaned in just a fraction, eyes dancing. “Are you more of a crab cake kinda woman?”

I snorted, glancing down at the menu, my gaze skimming the beverage section to avoid those damn eyes. “Why wouldn’t I stay? Unless you’ve got a lead on my sister, I’m gone by sunrise.”

He raised a brow, nodding at the empty seat across from me, his posture loose but deliberate, like a panther deciding whether to pounce or play. “Mind if I join the fugitive breakfast club?”

I crossed my arms, leaning back to mask the sudden flutter in my chest. “Only if you’re footing the bill, hotshot.”

Ace’s smirk was a slow, dangerous thing, like he’d already won a game I hadn’t realized we were playing. “Crab cakes and moi? I’ve had worse lunch dates. There was this one time with a vegan and a tax auditor—don’t ask.”

He slid into the booth with a predator’s grace, as if the cracked vinyl and sticky tabletop were his natural habitat. The man radiated heat—not just the physical kind, though the way his suit stretched across his shoulders was doing unholy things to my focus. No, it was something else, a magnetic pull that made the air between us hum, like the tense hush before a thunderstorm. I could feel it in my bones, a warning to keep my distance. Problem was, I wasn’t sure I wanted to listen.

“What brings you to The Shack?” I asked, snapping the menu shut with a flourish and meeting his gaze head-on. Two could play at this staring contest.

“Appetite,” he said, his voice a low, velvet rumble that seemed to sink into my skin. “And maybe a pinch of curiosity. You were wound tighter than a cheap watch last time we met.”

The words hit like a well-aimed dart, sharp and on target. My fingers tightened on the table’s edge, memories of our run-in at Sweet and Savory flooding back—me, jittery from too much caffeine and too little sleep, him clocking every twitch like a human lie detector. Of course he’d noticed. Ace Ryder probably noticed when the wind changed direction.

“There’s a simple explanation for that,” I said, my voice flat but heavy, the weight of truth dragging it down. “My sister’s missing.”

Kimberly’s absence was a knife in my gut, twisting sharper with every hour. Saying it out loud didn’t dull the edge—it honed it. Ace’s expression softened, just enough to show he wasn’t a complete bastard, but those eyes stayed locked on mine, intense, searching, like he could see the cracks I was trying to hide.

“Fair point,” he said, leaning back, his gaze peeling me apart layer by layer—skin, muscle, secrets. “So, Kathy, why would Kimberly never mention you? Not once. Not even in passing.”

I set the menu aside with a practiced flick, dodging the question with a half-truth I’d perfected over years of sidestepping. “Hazards of my job.”

It was flimsy, and we both knew it. My work kept me ghosting through cities, swapping names like outfits, always one step ahead of questions like his. But Kimberly? She wasn’t part of that world. She had no reason to keep me a secret. Unless… I shoved the thought down, unwilling to let it take root under Ace’s scrutiny.

He tilted his head, that slow, deliberate smile curling like smoke. “Hazards, huh? That’s what you’re calling it? Sounds like a story I’d pay to hear.”

“Cash only, no refunds,” I shot back, matching his grin despite myself.

Before he could counter, the waitress swooped in, notepad at the ready, her smile warm but seasoned, like she’d refereed a hundred tense booth-side standoffs. We ordered—crab cakes for both, hush puppies on the side, sweet tea for me, water for him (because of course Mr. Mysterious didn’t do sugar). She left, and the silence that settled wasn’t awkward but alive, crackling with the weight of unspoken questions and the thrill of whatever this was.

“I heard you were NYPD,” Ace said, breaking the quiet, his tone casual but laced with a probe sharp enough to draw blood.

I laughed, the sound sharper than I intended. Way off. “NYPD? Who’s feeding you that kind of fiction?”

He shrugged, unapologetic, his grin flashing white teeth that made my pulse do a traitorous little dance. “I do my homework. Comes with the territory.”

“Oh, enlighten me,” I said, sipping my tea to douse the heat creeping up my neck. “What else did your homework turn up?”

“That you vanished after Kimberly moved to Maryland. That you work under aliases. That you don’t stay anywhere long enough to leave a footprint.” His voice was steady, each word a chess move, and those eyes—God, those eyes—watched me like he was waiting for me to flinch.

A wild thought hit me: What if they think I’m a hitman? The idea was so absurd I nearly choked on my tea, but I hid it behind a smirk, arching a brow. “You sure you’re not writing a novel? Because you’re spinning quite the tale.”

He chuckled, low and warm, like a fire you wanted to lean into even if it might burn. “Nah. Fiction’s not my style. I prefer the truth, even when it’s slippery.”

“Is this your version of flirting?” I asked, leaning forward, my voice teasing but my eyes daring him to keep up.

His grin widened, a spark of something dangerous glinting in his gaze. “Sweetheart, if I was flirting, you’d know. This is just… foreplay.”

My breath hitched, and I hated how much I liked the way he said it, the way his voice curled around the word like a promise. For a moment, I let myself feel it—the spark, the heat, the electric tug that reminded me I was more than grief and suspicion. I was a woman, one who hadn’t been seen like this in too damn long. My throat tightened, and I leaned back, breaking the spell before it could pull me under.

“You’ve got dimples when you’re not scowling,” he said, his voice soft but deliberate, like he was tossing a pebble into still water just to watch the ripples.

“And you’ve got a mouth that doesn’t quit,” I fired back, my tone lighter than I felt, a shield against the warmth blooming in my chest. “Ever try shutting it?”

He laughed—a real, unguarded laugh that caught me off guard, his eyes crinkling in a way that made him look almost human, less like the enigma he’d been playing at. “Not when I’m winning.”

Our food arrived, the plates steaming with promise. The crab cakes were golden perfection, crisp outside, tender and bursting with flavor inside, each bite a fleeting escape to summers in Brooklyn—Kimberly and me, sunburned and giggling, pooling our pocket money for seafood at Brighton Beach. The hush puppies were warm, slightly sweet, a fried hug I didn’t know I needed. I savored the taste, letting it comfort me, even as Ace’s presence kept me teetering on the edge of something I couldn’t name.

He reached across the table, his fingers brushing a crumb from the corner of my mouth. The touch was light, fleeting, but it lingered like a spark, sending a jolt through me I couldn’t ignore. My breath caught, and for a split second, my body betrayed me, leaning into the contact before I jerked back, glaring like he’d set me on fire.

“Crumb patrol?” I asked, my voice dry but shaky, trying to reclaim the upper hand.

“Just keeping the view clear,” he said, his grin unrepentant, eyes locked on mine like he knew exactly what that touch had done to me.

I stabbed a hush puppy with my fork, muttering, “You’re trouble, Ryder.”

“And you’re a mystery, Hastings,” he countered, his voice low, teasing, but with an edge that said he wasn’t done digging. “Lucky for you, I love a good mystery.”

I met his gaze, my heart pounding, and for the first time in years, I wasn’t sure if I wanted to run from the challenge—or lean into it.