Chapter 91: Danny
The drive home is tense, each mile making the air between us thicker, colder. Brittany and Lindsey, oblivious to the storm they’ve caused, laugh quietly in the backseat, probably already picturing themselves lounging around the house, making themselves comfortable. But we’re not giving them an inch more than they deserve.
The second we pull into the driveway, Nate speaks up, “You’re both going to the gym downstairs. There are blankets and pillows. Don’t get too comfortable.”
Brittany’s face twists, her voice going shrill. “The gym? You’re joking, right? Why can’t we sleep in her bed? It’s not like she’s here.” She sneers as if she’s already calculated the distance between her and Sofia. “Besides, isn’t that bed free now?”
Nate’s patience snaps like a thin line stretched too far. “That’s not happening,” he says, his voice cold and final. “No one’s stepping foot in Sofia’s room except her.”
The girls throw each other irritated glances but, wisely, don’t say anything more. Once they’re settled downstairs, a little less thrilled with the blankets and makeshift setup we threw together, we leave them there and head upstairs. Each step we take feels like it brings more silence, more weight. We all know Sofia’s furious, and the sting of her absence settles heavy around us.
In the office, we sit down to draft an email to Brittany and Lindsey’s parents. Riley takes the lead, typing with barely contained irritation as he drafts a straightforward demand for answers: Why did you communicate with Moretti’s men? Tell us everything, and you’ll see your daughters returned.
Nate looks over the draft, crossing his arms as he reads, and finally says, “This will either get us answers or backfire in a way we won’t see coming.”
Leo shrugs, his eyes fixed on the screen. “We have to try. They want their daughters back more than we want to keep them.”
As Riley sighs and says, “Can we all just agree to be done with this mess soon? I don’t think any of us can handle much more of it,” I feel a fire rise in my chest.
“Are you serious right now?” I snap, my voice louder than I intended. “You and Leo are the reason we’re in this mess tonight. You’re the ones who thought it was a brilliant idea to bring those girls here in the first place. They could’ve stayed at someone else’s house; we’ve got plenty of crew with extra rooms.”
Riley stares at me, taken aback. “Danny—”
“No, really,” I continue, unable to bite back the frustration building up. “Did it even cross your mind how this would make Sofia feel? She’s been through hell, and the second she’s out of the house, you both invite in two girls who’ve done nothing but try to crawl all over us since day one.”
Leo cuts in, looking defensive. “We weren’t thinking about it like that, Danny. We just wanted leverage on their parents. It wasn’t about—”
“It wasn’t about Sofia?” I interrupt, shaking my head. “She’s the reason we’re even doing this. You think she’s going to feel safe with those two snakes slinking around here, taking over her space?”
The room falls silent, everyone looking at each other, guilt slowly sinking in. Even Riley looks a little ashamed, glancing away.
“Look,” he finally says, softer, “you’re right. We messed up. We’ll fix it.”
I let out a breath, not quite forgiving but too exhausted to keep the fight going. “Let’s just get through tonight and figure it out in the morning,” I mutter. “I just don’t want us to lose sight of what matters.”
We all fall quiet again, the weight of what we’ve done and the fallout with Sofia hanging thick in the air. Wordlessly, we head to our rooms, each of us carrying our frustration and guilt into the night, hoping tomorrow we’ll find a way to make things right.
Lying in bed, I squeeze my eyes shut, trying to tune out the obnoxious giggling drifting up from the gym. The girls are probably sprawled out on the floor with their ridiculous blankets and pillows, acting like they own the place. Every laugh, every obnoxious whisper makes my jaw clench tighter. I want nothing more than to march down there and tell them to shut up, remind them this isn’t a vacation—but I force myself to hold back.
Instead, I grab my phone and stare at the screen, debating whether I should message Sofia. She hasn’t answered any of us since we left her at Cole’s place. It’s her choice, but it stings more than I’d like to admit. After a second, I decide to text her.
*Hey, you okay?*
I wait, staring at the screen, but the little “delivered” status stays silent. No bubbles, no reply. Just the emptiness of the message staring back at me. Exhaling hard, I decide to message Cole instead.
*She doing alright? *I type out, hating that I even have to ask. Part of me wishes I was the one there making sure she’s okay, not him.
A minute later, Cole’s reply buzzes back: *She’s fine, man. Pissed but okay. We’re home safe. I’ll keep an eye on her.*
I throw my phone down on the bed, trying to push down the jealousy bubbling up in my chest. The thought of her sleeping under another guy’s roof, no matter how trusted he is, eats at me. It feels wrong, but right now, it’s our best option. She needs space, and if this is what it takes to make her feel safe, then fine. But it doesn’t make it any easier.
Just as I’m about to shut my eyes and attempt sleep, another ping lights up my screen. An email. I click on it, recognizing the address immediately: The girls’ parents.
They’re agreeing to meet tomorrow morning. I grind my teeth, tension swirling in my chest, but this is the chance we need to get the answers we’re after.
I send a quick message to the guys: *You see the email?*
Riley’s reply comes in first: *Yeah. We’re on it.*
Leo’s follows a second later: *We’ll get what we need tomorrow. Then those bitches go back to where they came from.*
Nate’s message is simple but holds the same weight: *Let’s finish this.*
Satisfied for now, I toss my phone aside, letting my frustration simmer as I try to force myself to sleep.